Sexual Orientation and Racial Discrimination in Mortgage Lending: An Audit Correspondence Field Experiment

How to cite

Selman, Javiera; Button, Patrick; Schwegman, David; Hadah, Hussain. 2024. "Sexual Orientation and Racial Discrimination in Mortgage Lending: An Audit Correspondence Field Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015081. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15081-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Javiera Selman* , Patrick Button , David Schwegman , Hussain Hadah

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015081
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15081-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2024-04-03 – 2027-09-30
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15081

Abstract

We conduct a national audit field experiment to quantify sexual orientation discrimination in access to mortgages. We focus on mortgage loan originators (MLOs), who help prospective borrowers get the right mortgage, working with the borrower from application and approval through the closing process (it can be a lending company, mortgage broker or loan officer). Discrimination by MLOs could lead to reduced access to mortgage loans and/or delays, lower loan amounts, or worse terms.
This research examines how mortgage loan originators (MLOs) respond to on-average identical emails inquiring about mortgage loans from different-gender or same-gender married couples. We ask two research questions: Do mortgage loan originators (MLOs) discriminate against credit-worthy individuals based on their sexual orientation? And What mechanisms drive potential differences in response rates to same and different-sex couples by MLOs?

Intervention

We send emails to mortgage loan originators (MLOs) requesting assistance with obtaining a mortgage loan. Each MLO receives two emails from two fictitious married couples who are first-time homebuyers and are looking to get pre-qualified for a mortgage loan.
Each MLO will receive, in random order:
1. One email from a same-gender couple (randomized to be either female or male) and one email from a different-gender couple (randomized so that the email sender is either female or male.)
2. Independently and randomly assigned, one email from a White couple (both individuals with White-signaling names) and a second email from either an African American couple (African American-signaling names) or another White couple. The order of these emails is also randomly assigned.

Experimental design

Our general experimental design follows those of similar email-correspondence studies (Ahmed and Hammarstedt 2009; Hanson et al. 2016; Giulietti, Tonin, and Vlassopoulos 2019; Schwegman 2019).

Treatment is clustered at the mortgage loan originator (MLO) levels, and we send two emails to each MLO. We paired our two emails to each MLO as follows. In random order, we sent one email from a same-gender couple (randomized to either be female or male), and one email from a different-gender couple (randomized so that the emailer is either female or male). Independently and in random order, one couple was always White (both individuals have White names), and the other couple was African American (both African American names) with 75% probability on average, and White otherwise. We varied the average probability of 75% for having an African American couple by the proportion African American in the metropolitan (or micropolitan) statistical area (MSA) so-as to make our sample of African American couples more population representative.
In addition to race and sexual orientation signals, we randomly vary some demographic and socioeconomic characteristics of prospective borrowers: credit scores, occupation, and fertility. We signal for creditworthiness by randomly assigning both the prospective borrower and their spouse either low credit scores, high credit scores, or no mention of credit scores, each with a probability of one third. We randomly include occupation and tenure of employment, which are both seen as important in the loan decision. Using data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2021), we select low-income and high-income occupations that are common enough to be needed in all communities and provide variation in wages or salaries. Finally, for one third of our sample of MLOs, we add mention of expecting a child.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
Mortgage loan originator is the unit of randomization
Clusters
Our planned number of clusters is 7,096 MLOs.
Observations
There are two emails sent per MLO. Therefore, our goal is 14,192 observations (mortgage inquiries).
Arms
Treatment and control groups were comprised of 7,096 MLOs.
Primary outcomes
Our primary outcome variable will be the response rate.
Secondary outcomes
We will also measure a set of secondary outcome variables capturing the quality of the response. This set of secondary outcome variables is the same as in Hanson et al. (2016): wait time before receiving a response (total minutes, converted to fractional days); if the MLO sends a follow-up email; and email length (in characters). These are all objective quality measures. We might also include subjective measures using, for instance, sentiment analysis.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords