Randomized Impact Evaluation of the Community Auxiliary Police, Bougainville, Papua New Guinea
How to cite
Cooper, Jasper. 2016. "Randomized Impact Evaluation of the Community Auxiliary Police, Bougainville, Papua New Guinea." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001505. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1505-3.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In developing countries, the state is often unable to deliver the protections of the law to all its citizens. When the state’s reach is limited, the few interactions citizens have with police are often marked by corruption, absenteeism, or abuse, contributing to dissatisfaction and distrust. These citizens sometimes instead rely on informal security providers, such as chiefs, families, or mobs, whose punitive and remedial procedures may be biased toward certain social groups at the expense of other groups. For example, men may receive systematically more beneficial outcomes from the informal justice system than women.
This study seeks to measure the effectiveness of a novel project implemented in Papua New Guinea by the New Zealand and Bougainville Police Services that seeks to overcome the challenges of policing in weak state environments, called the Community Auxiliary Police (CAP). The CAP project transfers the state’s constitutional police powers to carefully selected community members in villages located in remote parts of the country, and trains those officers in investigative techniques and legal norms, particularly surrounding gender-based violence. CAP officers are unarmed but do have powers of arrest, detention and investigation in the communities that they come from.
In partnership with the Bougainville and New Zealand Police, researchers are conducting the first randomized evaluation to study the impact of the Community Auxiliary Police program on crime, norms and citizens’ relationship to the state.
Intervention
Within the communities in which they live, CAP officers are authorized by the Police Act of 1988 to use the full powers of the police for offenses whose punishment comprises a prison term of no more than 12 months, and the power of detention and referral to the central police for all other offenses. They are uniformed officers and in practice work in their communities as full time police, conducting arrests, dispelling tension, investigating crimes and mediating conflicts. Importantly, they are not armed. The study randomizes the areas in which the CAP program is implemented. Treatment villages have a uniformed CAP officer work and live there as full time agents of the state police. Villages in the comparison group will maintain the status quo, which often means very poor access to state policing, or none at all.
Experimental design
In December 2015 and January 2016, the Bougainville Police Service and the New Zealand police service expanded the serving CAP force in the North and Central regions. Candidates cannot apply directly, but must be nominated by the council of paramount chiefs in their Council of Elders (local government unit). Each COE receives an allotted share of the new recruits - usually 1-2. From the shortlist of candidates that the police had interviewed, tested and among whom they were indifferent about hiring, some candidates were hired through a COE-level lottery, and others were not. Although the Columbia Univerity research team advised on the randomization procedure, it was designed and implemented entirely by the police. Candidates police their own communities if they are hired. Thus, for households in villages that are part of the study ("households"), there are two treatment conditions: having a candidate to the CAP recruited in one’s village (treatment); and not having a candidate to the CAP recruited in one’s village (control). The study also analyzes outcomes among those who applied and were hired or almost hired as CAP officers ("candidates"), thus the two treatment conditions for those subjects are: being hired as a CAP officer (treatment), and not being hired as a CAP officer (control).
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.