Land Consolidation and Agricultural Productivity: Experimental Evidence from Kenya

How to cite

Bergquist, Lauren; Donovan, Kevin. 2024. "Land Consolidation and Agricultural Productivity: Experimental Evidence from Kenya." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015043. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15043-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Lauren Bergquist* , Kevin Donovan

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015043
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15043-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-01-01 – 2027-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15043

Abstract

One often-postulated driver of cross-country disparities in agricultural labor productivity is differences in farm size. This project aims to provide some of the first experimental evidence on the returns to land consolidation in low-income countries. In doing so, we also test the impact of a commonly proposed (but rarely empirically tested) solution to the “too many small farms” problem: large, less credit constrained private-sector companies could be better positioned to consolidate land than smallholder farmers themselves. We partner with a Kenya-based company that leases small, adjacent plots of land from farmers, which it then consolidates to enable investments that demand scale, including irrigation, tractors, and professional managers. Using a randomized encouragement design that randomizes borehole location, we will measure the impacts of the induced land consolidation on agricultural productivity, with the ultimate goal of exploring land consolidation in the context of a structural change model. Further, we will study the structural adjustment in labor markets that land consolidation may unlock, by collecting data on employment outcomes of farmers potentially released from their land.

Intervention

We partner with a Kenya-based start-up that leases small, nearby plots of land from farmers. It then consolidates these farms to enable investments that demand scale, including irrigation, tractors, and professional managers. Although the plots must be in close proximity to each other to take advantage of large, fixed investments in mechanization and management, plots do not have to be completely adjacent (e.g., irrigation water is piped specifically to the participating plots and is certified by the government not to deplete reserves, implying no positive or negative impact on uninvolved plots).

Experimental design

When opening a new consolidated farm, the company first evaluates the agronomic, economic, and geological conditions of a wide range of areas across the country. This process typically results in a 30-50km area that is suitable for the new farm. Within this area, the company conducts a hydraulic survey to identify 3-4 possible locations where a borehole could be drilled. The borehole is used to pump groundwater to the surface and is critical for the establishment of an irrigation system. The borehole has a 2-3km catchment radius, making it unprofitable for the company to include plots outside of this radius. The company then offers lease terms within the catchment radius. Because the company offers an above-market premium on its lease terms, it typically enjoys high take up within this radius.

For the purpose of this study, the company will randomize which of the 3-4 possible borehole locations is actually used. This will generate one treatment catchment area and 2-3 control catchment areas per each consolidated farm. Each catchment area typically contains between 30 and 50 plots of land. We will use being located in a treated catchment area as a randomized encouragement for the plot to join the consolidated farm.

The company plans to roll out 10 new farms over the next two years. We will survey farmers before and after the company enters in all treated and control catchment areas to measure agricultural productivity, employment outcomes, and any non-market activity that respond to the freed time now available to farmers and their families.

Design details

Randomization method
This study will employ a randomized encouragement design. Among the feasible borehole locations, the one randomly selected for treatment will be determined in office by a computer.
Randomization unit
Borehole catchment area. Each possible borehole location has a 2-3km catchment radius, typically containing between 30 and 50 plots of land.
Clusters
We plan to have one treated borehole and three control boreholes for each consolidated farm. We expect to have ten consolidated farmers, for a total sample size of 10 treated boreholes and 30 control boreholes. More may be included if the company expands more quickly.
Observations
Each catchment area typically contains between 30 and 50 plots of land. There are 40 catchment areas (10 treated and 30 control). We therefore exact about 2,000 plots included in our sample.
Arms
500 plots coming from 10 catchment areas will be in treatment, while 1,500 plots coming from 30 catchment areas will be in control.
Primary outcomes
Our key outcomes of interest are agricultural outcomes, include yields, farm revenues, and farm profits.
Secondary outcomes
We will also explore two secondary outcomes: (1) Impacts on inputs and mechanization, to understand mechanisms (2) Impacts on landowner labor use, to understand how land consolidation can spur a transition into market activities, non-agricultural employment, and/or urban migration – as well as the labor market frictions that may constrain this adjustment.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords