When Parents Are in the Room: Experimental Evidence on Job Information and Youth Job Search
How to cite
Nagy, Abdelrahman. 2025. "When Parents Are in the Room: Experimental Evidence on Job Information and Youth Job Search." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015031. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15031-1.2
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Employment programs deliver job information to individual jobseekers, although employment decisions are often made within households. We study both margins in two separately randomized experiments covering 11,781 unemployed youth in rural Upper Egypt: what concrete, verified, tailored job information does on its own, and whether the household configuration in which the same information is delivered changes what youth do with it. Information moves behavior sharply. It raises the probability of taking a concrete step toward employment by 16.1 percentage points in the first experiment and 11.2 in the second, against control rates near a third, and men and women respond alike despite very different prior work histories. It produces no statistically detectable employment gain within seven to eight weeks. Conditional on the same information, parental co-presence has little detectable effect for sons. For daughters, father and mother co-presence generate short-run increases of about five percentage points in action on the offered opportunities; the two estimates are statistically indistinguishable, and their estimated trajectories subsequently diverge. Involving both parents has no detectable effect. Information appears sufficient to move youth from awareness to action but not to carry that action into employment over this horizon.
Intervention
The study evaluates a tailored job-information intervention and experimentally varies the household configuration in which the information is delivered.
Before the intervention, project staff identified and verified available vacancies at the village, district, and governorate levels. For each eligible youth assigned to receive information, staff selected up to three job opportunities based on geographic accessibility, compatibility with the youth’s circumstances, and the match between the youth’s qualifications and job requirements. If none of the initial opportunities was considered suitable, up to two additional opportunities were offered. Information included the employer, job title and description, location, required qualifications, working hours, compensation, and employer contact information.
The study consists of two separately randomized experiments:
Experiment 1
* Control: no tailored job information.
* Youth Only: tailored job information delivered privately to the youth.
* Youth + Father: the same tailored information delivered to the youth with the father present.
* Youth + Mother: the same tailored information delivered to the youth with the mother present.
Experiment 2
* Control: no tailored job information.
* Youth Only: tailored job information delivered privately to the youth.
* Youth + Both Parents: the same tailored information delivered to the youth with both the father and mother present.
Parents received no separate information, training, persuasion message, transfer, or other intervention. The parental treatments vary only whether the assigned parent or parents are present while the youth receives the same job information.
Experimental design
The study consists of two separately randomized controlled experiments conducted among unemployed youth aged 18–35 in rural Upper Egypt.
Randomization was conducted at the individual level within villages.
The analytical sample contains 11,781 youth across 287 villages in six governorates.
Experiment 1 includes 7,912 participants:
* Control: 2,028
* Youth Only: 1,978
* Youth + Father: 1,973
* Youth + Mother: 1,933
Experiment 2 includes 3,869 participants:
* Control: 1,294
* Youth Only: 1,283
* Youth + Both Parents: 1,292
The two experiments were randomized separately and are analyzed separately. Experiment 1 identifies the effects of father and mother co-presence relative to Youth Only and permits a direct randomized comparison between the Father and Mother arms. Experiment 2 identifies the effect of Both Parents relative to Youth Only. The design does not permit a causal comparison between the Both Parents arm and the Father or Mother arms.
Within each experiment, comparison of Youth Only with Control identifies the effect of receiving tailored job information. Comparison of the parental treatment arm(s) with Youth Only identifies the effect of parental co-presence while holding the information intervention fixed. If this registry field expects short descriptors, I would use:
Unit of randomization: Individual youth, within village.
Randomization: Individual-level randomized assignment, stratified by village.
Number of experiments: Two separately randomized experiments.
Study population: Unemployed youth aged 18–35 who expressed an interest in finding work and were living with both parents at enrollment.
Analytical sample: 11,781 participants.
Geographic coverage: 287 rural villages across six governorates of Upper Egypt: Beni Suef, Fayoum, Minya, Assiut, Sohag, and Qena.
Treatment arms: Seven experiment-specific arms in total: four in Experiment 1 and three in Experiment 2.
Follow-up: Approximately 2 weeks, 4 weeks, and 7–8 weeks after intervention delivery.
Intervention delivery: Individual jobseeker session lasting approximately 20–30 minutes; parental presence varied experimentally.
Primary treatment contrasts: Youth Only vs Control for information provision; Father vs Youth Only and Mother vs Youth Only in Experiment 1; Both Parents vs Youth Only in Experiment 2; Father vs Mother as a direct Experiment 1 contrast.
Inference: Intent-to-treat estimates with village fixed effects and heteroskedasticity-robust standard errors in the final paper.
One important registry point: if this is an existing registration that you are updating rather than creating for the first time, I would preserve the original registered outcomes/design language wherever possible and clearly mark additions as retrospective amendments. Given that the paper explicitly says there was no pre-analysis plan, we should avoid making today’s final-paper outcome hierarchy look prospectively registered if it was not.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.