Promoting pro-environmental behavior of tourists using pro-environmental messaging: an experimental study in Vietnam

How to cite

Nie, Zihan; Ho, Thong; Tran, Chau. 2024. "Promoting pro-environmental behavior of tourists using pro-environmental messaging: an experimental study in Vietnam." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015030. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15030-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Zihan Nie* , Thong Ho , Chau Tran

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015030
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15030-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2024-11-22 – 2024-12-27
Countries
Private
JEL codes
Q53, C93, Z3
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15030

Abstract

In an experiment that combines survey and field observations, we examine the effectiveness of different framings of the pro-environmental messages in the promoting pro-environmental behavioral changes in the highly hedonic context of tourism. We experimentally manipulate the assignment of two framings, i.e., a normative framing and a hedonic framing, in a survey targeting tourists on ferry trips in Vietnam. We set to examine with framing is more effective in changing actual behavior of tourist with actual behavioral measures from the field and the heterogeneity in the treatment effects with regard to hedonic motives held by the tourists.

Intervention

Pro-environmental messaging aiming at promoting pro-environmental behavior among tourists. with two different framing of the message: normative framing and hedonic framing.
The hedonic framing of the pro-environmental message (Hedonic) refers to making the message stress how acting pro-environmentally can help increase the psychological pleasure of the vacation.
The normative framing of the pro-environmental message (Normative) appeals to individuals’ pro-environmental preference and personal and social norms, which is typical in pro-environmental messaging in every day context.
The intervention is delivered in the middle of a tourist survey conducted on a popular tourism route.

Experimental design

We conduct a survey experiment among tourists in a natural tourism setting to study the research questions. Tourists are invited to join a survey about their views on the topics related to their visits by the enumerators. The survey contains largely three sections. In first section, we elicit respondent’s attitudes and perceptions with regard to hedonic motivations and environmental concerns, as well as individual characteristics and trip information. In the second section, we introduce the pro-environmental messaging that calls for pro-environmental behavioral changes during their trips. We randomly assign respondents to one of the two version of pro-environmental messaging, one with hedonic framing and one with normative framing. In the third section of the survey, we elicit respondents’ pro-environmental behavioral intentions and policy support as self-reported outcome variable.
The pre-intervention questions are to obtain basic information on the respondent and understand their “natural” attitudes and perceptions towards vacations and environmental issues, with a focus on hedonic goals and motivations. This section provides baseline information that will be used to explore effect mechanisms and heterogenous effects.
The intervention occurs as a message in the middle of the service. The intervention design had already been described above. Beside the two treatment conditions, we have a control group where respondents only see the pictures in the interim between the first and third survey sections.
We use the between-subject design, where one respondent will only experience one treatment arm.
Because tourists tend to travel in groups, to reduce contamination across treatment arms, we randomize the treatment assignment at group level.
After delivering the intervention, we elicit respondents’ pro-environmental behavioral intentions with survey questions and observe their pro-environmental behavior in a field setting. The observed pro-environmental behavior is our primary outcome variable and the pro-environmental behavioral intentions are the secondary outcome variables.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization by rolling a dice on site.
Randomization unit
Randomization by tourist groups. The enumerator on site would identify respondents traveling in the same group and assign the respondents from a group to the same treatment arm.
Clusters
About 375 tourist groups (assuming the average group size is 4)
Observations
1,500 tourists from around 375 groups
Arms
00 from about 125 groups in each treatment arm.
Primary outcomes
The primary outcome variable is the consumption of single-use items. We frame and observe the consumption decisions in a natural gift redeem setting. We offer the respondents a fruit tea and a cake at the terminal café the compensation for participation. The respondents are asked to order from a menu in advance to save waiting time upon arrival. An order includes what type of fruit tea and cake they want and what accessory items they want to have alone with the tea and cake. The accessory items include typical single-use items such as straws, spoon, stirring sticks, cup holders and plastic bags. We count the total number of items used as the main outcome variable in the analysis.
Secondary outcomes
Behavioral intentions measured with survey questions. Intentions are measured on a 1-7 Likert scale.
Sponsors
Name: EfD Initiative Location: Sweden Url: https://www.efdinitiative.org

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords