Disaggregating the Effects of Deliberation on Policy Attitudes in the United States
How to cite
Green, Donald; Fishkin, James S.; Luskin, Robert; Paluck, Elizabeth Levy; Farrar, Cynthia; List, Christian. 2016. "Disaggregating the Effects of Deliberation on Policy Attitudes in the United States." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001503. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1503-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Using data from a randomized field experiment within a Deliberative Poll, we examine deliberations effects on both policy attitudes and the extent to which ordinal rankings of policy options approach single peakedness (a help in avoiding cyclical majorities). The issues were airport expansion and revenue-sharing in New Haven, Connecticut and its surrounding towns. Half the participants deliberated revenue-sharing, then the airport, the other half the reverse. This split-half design enables us to distinguish the effects of the formal on-site deliberations from those of other aspects of the Deliberative Polling treatment. We find that the formal on-site deliberations accounted for much of the Deliberative Polling effect on one issue, though not the other—thus both confirming deliberations capacity to shape attitudes and preferences and raising the question of how its effects may depend on the kind of issue being deliberated. We suggest that deliberations effects are larger for less salient issues.
Experimental design
This study reports on a Deliberative Poll designed to estimate the specific contribution of the formal on-site deliberation. In an enfolded randomized experiment, the participants are randomly assigned to deliberate one or the other of two distinct policy issues, then answer the same questions as when first interviewed and recruited, then deliberate the other issue, then answer the same questions again.
To isolate the effects of the formal on-site deliberations, a randomized field experiment was built into a Deliberative Poll. A random sample drawn from the fifteen towns surrounding New Haven, Connecticut, deliberated two issues: the level of service to be provided by the local airport and what if any sharing there should be of property-tax revenues from new commercial development.
At the beginning of the weekend, the participants were randomly assigned to one of sixteen small groups, and the small groups in turn randomly assigned to one of the two possible orders in which the two issues could be deliberated. Eight groups (containing 64 participants) deliberated the airport Saturday morning and revenue-sharing Saturday afternoon, the other eight (containing 68 participants) the reverse. These two treatment groups are denoted as “A-first” and “R-first,” respectively. The formal on-site deliberations consisted of three “deliberative sessions,” each involving both small-group discussions and plenary questions-and-answers with panels of policy experts and advocates. The first two sessions, occupying the whole of Saturday, concentrated on one issue apiece, with the first confined to the airport for the A-first treatment group and to revenue-sharing for the R-first treatment group, and the second to revenue-sharing for the A-first group and to the airport for the R-first group. The third, on Sunday morning, was more synoptic, with all the participants revisiting both issues in their small groups and then questioning a panel of local and state officials about both.
Design details
Papers from this trial
- Farrar, Cynthia, James S. Fishkin, Donald P. Green, Christian List, Robert C. Luskin, and Elizabeth Levy Paluck. 2010. "Disaggregating Deliberation’s Effects: An Experiment within a Deliberative Poll." British Journal of Political Science 40(2): 333-347. https://www.povertyactionlab.org/sites/default/files/publications/689%20Disaggregating%20deliberation%20effects%20-%20Working%20paper.pdf
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.