Social registry targeting in Mauritania
How to cite
Stoeffler, Quentin; Vinez, Margaux; Vandeninden, Frieda. 2024. "Social registry targeting in Mauritania." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015027. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15027-1.2
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Can social registries identify potential beneficiaries for social protection interventions at scale–in countries with low administrative capacities? The objective of this research is to answer this question in the context of Mauritania, which is currently updating its national social registry. Specifically, will explore targeting options offered by the new innovative process implemented by the social registry for improving targeting efficiency and legitimacy. While the identification of beneficiaries previously was based on community-based targeting (CBT), it has now moved largely to a system based on scoring, combined with community adjustments. In addition, the number of beneficiaries per village (quota) is now determined by the actual score of households, while it was previously based on imprecise poverty estimates at the commune level. We are implementing a 2 x 3 RCT design with the government of Mauritania to test the improvements introduced by the new process. In doing so, we are exploring questions related to the selection of beneficiaries of social programs related to thresholds, inclusive combination of methods, and legitimacy among local communities.
Intervention
We partnered with the government and the World Bank to study the improvements introduced by an updating of the social registry. Mauritania was one of the first countries of the Sahel region to implement a social registry and to reach national coverage by 2020. The social registry includes 28% of the population and is used by more than 20 programs, including its national food and cash transfer programs. The government has started to update and expand the social registry in 2023, which should be completed by the end of 2024. In doing so, the government introduced a series of important improvements of the social registry process:
- While the identification of beneficiaries was based on community-based targeting (CBT), it has now moved largely to a system based on scoring combined with community selection.
- The number of beneficiaries per village (quota) is now determined by the actual score of households, while it was previously based on imprecise poverty estimates at the commune level.
Experimental design
This research will assess whether these improvements lead to changes in targeting in terms of efficiency, legitimacy and impacts. We will test three main hypotheses:
a. The union of scoring (60 to 80%) and CBT (20 to 40%) reduces exclusion errors compared to traditional hybrid methods that selects the intersection of PMT and CBT, while improving the legitimacy of the targeting scheme.
b. Targeting thresholds have important effects on targeting outcomes, with higher selection rates leading to lower levels of targeting errors and higher legitimacy.
c. The two previous improvements translate into larger impacts of social programs that rely on the improved targeting mechanism of the updated version of the social registry.
To test the efficiency, legitimacy and impacts of these innovations of the social registry, we will conduct a randomized control trial (RCT) comparing different targeting mechanisms. Specifically, we will test the improvement in terms of selection quota by randomizing this innovation at the commune level. Then, at the locality (village) level, we will randomly allocate targeting as a scoring mechanism, a community-based targeting method, or a combination of both (with the union approach).
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.