Addressing Gender Bias in Small Business Lending
How to cite
Jung, Youngjoo. 2024. "Addressing Gender Bias in Small Business Lending." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015025. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15025-1.5
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This project investigates gender bias in small business microfinance lending through a framed experiment conducted in Egypt. Loan officers evaluate previously approved loans with randomized applicant names. By comparing whether the same portfolios are rejected more frequently with names suggesting different genders, the study aims to identify the existence of bias. Additionally, the project explores the origins of this bias, examining whether it is inclusionary or exclusionary errors. It also investigates whether the amount of bias varies based on the incentive structure that loan officers face. The project aims to explore how to mitigate bias and improve accuracy in loan decisions. For example, it tests whether sensitivity training, AI-assisted decision-making, or higher incentives and penalties for incorrect decisions have a positive impact or not.
Intervention
In the first stage, loan officers in the control group make either approval or rejection decisions with a smaller incentive and penalty. Loan officers in Treatment Group 1 receive their Gender-Career Implicit Association Test (IAT) score before making their decisions. Loan officers in Treatment Group 2 receive a higher incentive and penalty for their decisions. Lastly, loan officers in Treatment Group 3 receive both treatments simultaneously: they are notified of their IAT score and receive higher incentives and penalties.
In the second stage, loan officers make approval or rejection decisions with different portfolios. The control group loan officers repeat the same approval/rejection process as before. Loan officers in the non-interactive AI group receive the help of ChatGPT, but without the communication feature in their approval decisions. Loan officers in the interactive AI group receive the help of ChatGPT with the communication feature enabled.
Experimental design
To investigate gender bias in loan decisions and assess interventions to mitigate it, I am conducting a framed field experiment in Egypt. This study involves approximately 750 experienced loan officers. Loan officers make hypothetical decisions about 10 previously approved small business loan portfolios, with randomized five male and five female names. They decide whether to approve or reject loans. Correct decisions, such as approving performing loans or rejecting non-performing loans, will be incentivized, while incorrect decisions will incur penalties.
The experiment consists of two stages. In the first stage, loan officers are randomly assigned to one of four groups. The control group will make decisions without additional interventions. In Treatment Group 1, loan officers receive feedback on their IAT scores before making decisions. Treatment Group 2 involves imposing higher incentives and penalties for their decisions, while Treatment Group 3 combines IAT feedback with the higher incentive and penalty structure.
In the second stage, loan officers evaluate a new set of 10 loan portfolios with assistance from ChatGPT. Loan officers are further randomized into three subgroups: The first group does not get any help from AI. The second group will use non-interactive AI, where recommendations are viewed without communication, while the last group will use interactive AI, allowing officers to ask follow-up questions.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.