Measuring subjective probabilities about future income: the effect of question modes on the use of focal responses and moments of the predictive distribution
How to cite
Denis, Angela; Hospido, Laura; Basso, Henrique; Gálvez, Julio. 2025. "Measuring subjective probabilities about future income: the effect of question modes on the use of focal responses and moments of the predictive distribution." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015009. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15009-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The ability to assess probabilities of future outcomes is an essential component of individuals’ decision-making under risk. A growing number of surveys ask people to assess their subjective probabilities for future events, and there is ample evidence that these beliefs matter for individuals’ choices. At the same time, different surveys employ different formats when asking for beliefs, and answers to these expectations questions show inconsistencies and measurement error. The objective of this project is to study how different formats relate to the measures of beliefs we derive from them. We implement an online survey of 4,400 participants to test how the format of income-expectation questions relates to measures of coherence, rounding, and estimated moments of the underlying beliefs. The survey randomizes the format of the income-expectation question, between a baseline format based on distributing points in a pre-set scale of income growth, a second and similar format distributing more points in more intervals, and a third min-max format based on distributing points among individual-specific intervals of income levels.
Intervention
We will implement an online survey that randomizes participants into different formats of the income-expectation questions. The survey will be completed by 4,400 participants aged 25-64, representative of the population living in Spain. The goal is to measure how different expectations formats relate to coherence, rounding and estimated moments of the underlying beliefs.
Experimental design
There are 3 experimental arms, each with a different format of the question asking for income expectations in the following next 12 months. The first arm corresponds to asking for expectations of income growth, where individuals are asked to distribute 10 points among 5 different intervals. The second arm is similar, asking for expectations of income growth too, but where individuals are asked to distribute 100 points among 6 different intervals. The third arm corresponds to asking for income expectations in levels using the min-max format. That is, individuals are first asked the minimum and maximum expected income, and then they are asked to distribute 100 points among 4 equally sized intervals between the minimum and the maximum they reported.
Our target population corresponds to individuals living in Spain, between 25- and 64-year-old. We aim for 4,400 completed interviews, distributed evenly among the three experimental arms. This will be an online survey, for a convenience panel of the partner organization, who will randomize the question format, ensuring representative quotas in terms of gender, age group (25 to 34, 35 to 49, and 50 to 64), education level (primary, secondary and tertiary), and labor status (employed, unemployed, other).
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.