Girl's Economic Empowerment: a Randomized Experiment in Tanzanian Schools
How to cite
Tungodden, Bertil; Somville, Vincent; Sekei, Linda Helgesson; Kida, Tausi; Bjorvatn, Kjetil; Berge, Lars Ivar Oppedal. 2013. "Girl's Economic Empowerment: a Randomized Experiment in Tanzanian Schools." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000150. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.150-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Teenage pregnancies are common in many low-income countries, but the reasons for why teenage girls become pregnant are not well understood. This is particularly unfortunate in a low-income context where pregnancy among young girls can result in illegal and often dangerous abortions, the spread of HIV/AIDS and, more generally, poor health, educational, and economic outcomes.
The present study takes place in Tanzania and investigates the fertility and economic decisions of girls when they are on the verge of making two of the most important decisions in their lives: what to do when leaving school and whether to start childbearing.
The present project investigates whether early childbearing reflects a lack of empowerment among young girls in Tanzania, with a focus on two different empowerment strategies. First, we offer an information treatment where young girls are targeted with detailed and extensive information about reproductive health, gender equality, and rights. Second, we offer an opportunity treatment where young girls are targeted with entrepreneurship training to improve their skills on how to run a business. Both treatments aim at empowering girls, but through different channels. The information treatment represents in many ways the classical approach in the field, where the underlying idea is that teenage pregnancies reflect lack of relevant information and personal control. The opportunity treatment, on the other hand, investigates whether teenage pregnancies to a large extent reflect a lack of economic opportunities. By comparing these two treatments, the study will provide novel insights on the relative importance of providing information and opportunities to adolescent girls, which is important both from a theoretical and a policy perspective. In addition, since there may be important complementarities in how the two treatments work, we also offer a cross-treatment to a sub-sample of the girls.
An ultimate goal of this research project is to inform the design of sound policies, and we are thus particularly careful to develop a cost-effective intervention with scaling-up potential: all treatments are evaluated and compared not only in terms of impact but also on their relative economic costs. The interventions are based on current practices of our partners, which makes it easier to scale up the successful parts of the project and, more generally, to use the knowledge from the project to improve existing policies.
Intervention
Together with our partner Femina HIP, a leading NGO on reproductive health in Tanzania, we have decided to focus on girls who are in their last year of secondary school (Form IV in Tanzania). They are in the age interval where we observe a sharp increase in fertility. Most of them will not have access to further schooling, and will thus have to consider other opportunities, including opening a small scale business, which is a very common activity in the areas of this study.
The interventions consist in training sessions offered in a classroom setting on a weekly basis for eight weeks:
1) Reproductive health information treatment: An information course on reproductive health, gender equality, and rights.
Femina HIP, together with the research team, designed a tailored information program for the targeted girls, which provided both practical and objective information about reproductive health, such as information about contraception and the consequences of risky sexual behavior. In addition, the course focused on gender equality, rights, and women’s empowerment.
2) Economic opportunity treatment: EntrepreneursHIP training to improve economic opportunities.
Femina HIP, together with the research team, designed a tailored entrepreneursHIP program for the targeted girls, which provided the girls with knowledge on how to establish and run their own business. Topics included customer care, marketing, record keeping, pricing of products, personal finance, and sessions aiming at improving entrepreneurial mindset and self-confidence.
3) Cross-treatment: Information and opportunity
We also offered a cross-treatment, where the students received both the reproductive health information and entrepreneursHIP training, to investigate possible complementarities in how the two treatments work. The girls that were offered this training met twice a week for eight weeks.
Experimental design
We sampled schools with at least 20 girls in Form IV in the following regions: Tabora, Singida, Morogoro and Dodoma. In each school, we did a baseline survey of the girls enrolled in Form IV and surveyed the headmaster of each school, who provided us with detailed information about school characteristics.
The schools were then randomly allocated to the control group or one of the three treatments. The randomization was blocked by school-size (below or above 40 girls in Form IV) and by region.
After the baseline survey, one or two teachers per (treated) school attended a one week instructor session organized by Femina HIP (two weeks for the teachers involved in the combined treatment). After this instructor sessions, the teachers implemented the training sessions (treatments) with all the Form IV girls of their school. The single treatments had 8 training sessions of 1.5 to 2 hours, 1 session per week. The cross-treatments had 16 training sessions of 1.5 to 2 hours, two sessions per week.
The short-term follow-up survey was done within six weeks after the last training session. The survey data was collected by the girls filling in a questionnaire in the classroom. In addition, we collected incentivized data on knowledge (i.e. the students received a payment for each correct answers) and their willingness to compete.
We also surveyed 5 boys in Form IV in each school to measure spill-over effects of the treatments.
For more details, see the attached questionnaires and instructions.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.