Gender-neutral language, persuasion, and policy preferences II

How to cite

Fujiwara, Thomas; Carpio, Lucia Del; Sanz, Carlos. 2024. "Gender-neutral language, persuasion, and policy preferences II." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014931. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14931-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Thomas Fujiwara* , Lucia Del Carpio , Carlos Sanz

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014931
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14931-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-12-02 – 2025-07-15
Countries
Private
JEL codes
P, Z13, J16
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14931

Abstract

This is a second pilot study for a project studying how inclusive language (particularly gender-neutral language) affects the persuasiveness of messages aiming to boost support for certain policies. The first pilot was registered as AEARCTR-0014012.

In Spanish, like many gendered-grammar languages spoken by 39% of the world population (Jakiela and Ozier, 2018), all nouns are assigned to a male or female gender. The traditional default is to use the masculine form as a “generic” when referring to an unspecified sex. A growing (and controversial) movement has challenged this norm, making it a political issue. For example, "employee" in Spanish is either the male noun "empleado" or the female noun "empleada," and historically there has been no word for a non-gendered "employee." Gender-neutral language in our context consists of stating "empleado o empleada" instead of only "empleado" when referring to an "employee.”

In an online survey in Spanish, Peruvian citizens will be provided with short briefs and policy proposals on two context-relevant topics: one related to social inclusion and diversity (bilingual education) and another related to a trade-off between environmental conservation and economic activity (mining). The research design cross-randomizes two aspects of the briefs and proposals that respondents see: i) whether the proposed policy is progressive (left-wing) or conservative (right-wing); and ii) whether gender-neutral language is used in the briefs.

This research design allows us to estimate the effect of gender-neutral language on the persuasiveness of the briefs (i.e., if using it makes the respondent more or less likely to support the proposal) separately for progressive and conservative messages and for each of the issues we study. For example, our design allows us to test if gender-neutral language makes a progressive (left-wing) message on an economic issue less persuasive, but would have smaller effects if the message was conservative or if it was about a social issue.

The research design also randomizes the salience and format of gender-neutral language (whether the respondent sees both proposals with gender-neutral language, both proposals without it, or one proposal with or without gender-neutral language).

Experimental design

See "Experimental Design (Hidden)" field and the pre-analysis document.

Design details

Randomization method
The Qualtrics platform will perform the randomization.
Randomization unit
Randomization is at the "brief" level: each respondent sees two briefs (one on each topic). Each time a brief is shown to her, a variation of the brief of a given topic is chosen. The order of the topics of briefs shown is also randomly determined.
Clusters
4,500 respondents collected in two waves (design is not clustered)
Observations
4,500 respondents collected in two waves (design is not clustered)
Arms
When a brief is shown to the respondent, there is a 25% probability it is assigned to each of the four previously discussed gender-neutral language arms. There is also a (independently and cross-randomized) 50%-50% chance the brief will have a "conservative" or "progressive" position on the topic. Which topic a respondent sees first is also randomized with a 50%-50% chance.
Primary outcomes
Our main outcome is whether the respondent is willing to provide a name for a potentially public online petition with text similar to the proposal she read. We also will use an outcome whether the respondent states if she agrees with the proposal. We will allow three potential answers to this question (agree, disagree, neither agree nor disagree).
Secondary outcomes
To study the intensive margin of agreement, we will also ask the respondents to rate their level of agreement on a 0-10 scale. Moreover, after reading both proposals and answering the questions that generate the primary outcomes, respondents are asked two questions that can, presumably, be affected by the different treatments. These are support for the use of gender-neutral language and how credible/trustworthy they found the proposals shown to them.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords