Emotional Eaters: The Effect of Anthropomorphic Messages on Emotions, Support for Meat Tax and Animal Welfare
How to cite
Perino, Grischa; Damania, Mrunali. 2024. "Emotional Eaters: The Effect of Anthropomorphic Messages on Emotions, Support for Meat Tax and Animal Welfare." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014925. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14925-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Background: Why do we love dogs and eat pigs? Serpell (2004) states that this inconsistency can be explained by the psychological categorization of certain animals as objects of affect and other animals as objects of utility. Research suggests that using anthropomorphic messages (i.e., messages that humanize animals) can reduce meat consumption or in other words, change the way individuals perceive animals that are typically considered objects of utility.
Objectives: To test the effectiveness of an anthropomorphic message (an image montage with voiceover) in influencing the emotional response to animal images, support for animal welfare policies and relevant individual efforts (revealed preference).
Method: We use an online survey and a within as well as between-subjects research design on a demographically representative, German sample of 1,500 participants. Those in the control group would not see any montage. Those in the experimental groups would watch a montage containing an anthropomorphic and emotional message about “farm animals”. The hypothesis is that participants in the experimental group will have a different emotional response to the images of farm animals than those in the control, greater support for policies supporting animal welfare and plant-based products, pay more for meat-replacement products, and donate more to an animal welfare charity.
Intervention
This study employs a mixed experimental design, combining within-subjects and between-subjects elements with random assignment to one of five groups to examine the effects of animal imagery and species-specific video content on emotions and support for animal welfare policies.
Experimental Conditions
Group 1 (Pure Control Group): Participants receive no animal-related stimuli.
Group 2 (Image-Only Control Group): Participants view images of all six animals and rate their emotional responses to these images.
Group 3 (Real Cow Video + Images): Participants first view a video about cows (with images of real cows), then images of all six animals, and subsequently rate their emotional responses.
Group 4 (Cow Video + Images): Participants view a video about cows (with AI-generated images), followed by images of all six animals and emotional rating.
Group 5 (Real Pig Video + Images): Participants view a video about pigs (with images of real pigs), followed by images of all six animals and emotional rating
Experimental design
This study employs a mixed experimental design, combining within-subjects and between-subjects elements with random assignment to one of five groups to examine the effects of animal imagery and species-specific video content on emotions and support for animal welfare policies.
1. Groups and Treatments:
o Group 1 (Pure Control Group): Participants receive no animal-related stimuli.
o Group 2 (Image-Only Control Group): Participants view images of all six animals and rate their emotional responses to these images.
o Group 3 (Real Cow Video + Images): Participants first view a video about cows (with images of real cows), then images of all six animals, and subsequently rate their emotional responses.
o Group 4 (Cow Video + Images): Participants view a video about cows (with AI-generated images), followed by images of all six animals and emotional rating.
o Group 5 (Real Pig Video + Images): Participants view a video about pigs (with images of real pigs), followed by images of all six animals and emotional rating
2. Outcome Variables:
o Emotional Responses: Participants rate the emotions elicited by the animal images.
o Support for Animal Welfare Policies: Measured through a series of policy-support questions.
o Individual Actions: Items assessing participants’ revealed-preferences and stated-preference for actions related to animal welfare.
The data will be collected by a survey company (Bilendi) in November-December 2024. The sample will include 1,500 German adult participants from the survey panel of the company. The company will contact the participants via email. The participants are requested to provide informed consent to participate in the study. The survey includes an attention/bot check and only those who pass the check are taken through the entire 15-minute survey. The survey company will also screen out all participants that complete the survey in less than 25% of the median time taken to complete the survey.
The sample will include 750 men and women each and the quota for other genders is open. The age range will be 18-74 [18-29 (20\%), 30-39 (20\%), 40-49 (20\%), 50-59 (20\%), 60-74 (20\%)]. The sample will include people with different levels of formal education [Without Abitur (High school diploma): (60\%); With Abitur: (40\%)].
All participants will be meat consumers. This is to check the effectiveness of the videos in enhancing support for animal welfare, specifically among meat consumers.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.