Take-up of efficient cooking fuels and equilibrium outcomes for women's work

How to cite

Barnwal, Prabhat; Afridi, Farzana; Dinkelman, Taryn. 2024. "Take-up of efficient cooking fuels and equilibrium outcomes for women's work." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014920. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14920-1.3

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Prabhat Barnwal* , Farzana Afridi , Taryn Dinkelman

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014920
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14920-1.3
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2024-06-10 – 2026-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14920

Abstract

Why is the adoption of efficient cooking fuels so low in LMICs, despite well-documented health and potential time-saving gains? This is puzzling for two reasons. Many countries subsidize cleaner fuels for low-income households to facilitate a switch out of firewood. Moreover, freeing women’s time spent on collecting and cooking with solid fuels can potentially raise household incomes, if women have opportunities to do more market work.

We identify two opportunities. First, despite the provision of heavy subsidies, recent research has highlighted financial constraints in the adoption of cooking fuel technology. Second, switching from firewood to clean fuels requires financial consideration often by men in the household, while women are to gain from switching away from firewood collection and cooking. Intrahousehold decision-making has important implications for energy transition, but is relatively less studied. Access to a suitable labor market can help women gain financial resources as well as realize returns from time and “energy” saved in home production.

Our core research premise is that clean fuel subsidies alone cannot lead to sustained energy transition in cooking fuel until informational and intra-household constraints are addressed. We seek to answer two main questions by experimentally evaluating a novel combination of two treatments — information on clean fuel cost and access to digital work for women. First, we assess how information on clean fuel costs and increasing women’s access to income-generating employment affect households’ transition from biomass to clean cooking fuel. Second, we seek to understand whether information on clean fuel costs and government subsidies on LPG and women’s access to income-generating employment complement each other in boosting adoption of LPG and other clean fuels. Specifically, we posit that there are strong complementariness between easing information constraints on clean fuel expenditures and women’s employment.

Intervention

This intervention includes two treatments that are randomly assigned to households, primarily targeting women who have the main responsibility of household chores. First, the provision of jobs to women that can be completed virtually using a smartphone/tablet/laptop. Second, the provision of information on clean cooking fuel subsidies.

Experimental design

Our intervention targets women who also have primary household chores responsibility. We randomly assign households to three primary treatment groups and one control group– (1) access to digital jobs, (2) clean cooking fuel subsidy information, and (3) combined treatments (digital jobs and clean fuel subsidy information), (4) Control group. These jobs are primarily targeted at the women in the household. However, for a subgroup of randomly selected households within groups 1 and 3, we provide job offers to men instead of women. An additional sample of households from villages where no treatment is provided to any household serves as pure control.

Design details

Randomization method
randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
We have two stages of randomization, with a primary focus on household-level randomization in the second stage. We start with 104 villages with a total of 1531 households. We first randomly assign 34 villages to the pure control group where no household receives any treatment. In the remaining 70 villages, we randomly assign households to treatment groups 1 to 3 and to the control group.
Clusters
Total 104 villages and 1531 households. In the first stage, we clustered the treatment at the village level for comparison between villages with any treated households (70 villages) and villages with no treated households (i.e., 34 pure control villages). In the second stage, we randomize treatment at the household level in 70 villages.
Observations
1531
Arms
Out of 1027 households from 70 villages, 230 households are assigned to digital job (women) treatment, 140 households are assigned to clean cooking fuel subsidy information treatment, 274 households are assigned to the combined job (women) and information treatment arm, and 140 households are assigned to the control group. Additionally, 112 households are assigned to digital job (male) treatment, and 131 households are assigned to the combined job and information treatment. The remaining 34 pure control villages have 504 households.
Primary outcomes
1. Monthly LPG refill purchase by household 2. Any clean cooking fuel usage (LPG or electric or both) by household 3. Solid fuel usage by household 4. Time spent on home production by primary cook 5. Any market work by primary cook 6. Time spent on any market work by primary cook 7. Earnings from any market work by primary cook

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords