Immigration and Citizenship: Labor Market Discriminations

How to cite

Govind, Yajna; Rapoport, Hillel; Schneider-Strawczynski, Sarah; Parraud, Joyce Sultan. 2024. "Immigration and Citizenship: Labor Market Discriminations." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014892. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14892-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Yajna Govind* , Hillel Rapoport , Sarah Schneider-Strawczynski , Joyce Sultan Parraud

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014892
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14892-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-12-02 – 2025-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
J71, J15, C93, J61
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14892

Abstract

This study investigates the role of citizenship in mitigating labor market discrimination against first- and second-generation immigrants in France. Using a large-scale correspondence experiment with 6400 fictitious job applications, we aim to understand the extent to which hiring discrimination is related to immigrant status and ethnic origin, and the role that citizenship acquisition plays in mitigating this discrimination. The findings will provide insights into employer discriminatory behavior, informing policies to reduce discrimination and promote ethnic minorities and immigrant integration in labor markets.

Intervention

To understand how citizenship can help reduce hiring discrimination among first- and second-generation immigrants, we will conduct a large-scale correspondence experiment in France varying the profiles’ immigration status and origin. We will send 6,400 fictitious resumes to occupation openings in eight professions, carefully selected based on variations in labor-market tightness and the level of French required for the occupation

Experimental design

In this project, we run a correspondence audit study to test whether and the extent to which candidates are discriminated at the hiring stage based on their origins and citizenship. To do so, we will send 6,400 fictitious resumes, varying citizenship, and origins, to occupation openings in eight professions, carefully selected based on variations in labor-market tightness and the level of French required for the occupation.

Design details

Randomization method
We will send four fictitious applications to each vacancy. Randomizing the CV templates, sending order and signals. Randomization will be performed by a computer program. (See Pre-Analysis Plan for more details).
Randomization unit
Application within each occupation. Randomisation takes place to create the 4 applications with which we apply to each job vacancy and the assignment of these four to each job vacancy for a given occupation. For each of the 8 occupations, a single application is characterized by a profile (which is a combination of nationality, lastname origin and place of work), a combination of core signals (gender and type of the third hobby), specific signals that vary according to each profile (firstname origin, french mastery, residency rights), a template (layout of the CV), a firstname and a lastname, the fact that nationality is mentioned at the top of the application, the fact that this mention is primed, and specific wording according to residency rights. CV templates are randomly selected at the vacancy level as well as the order in which the applications are sent. Nationality is explicitly written for all of the applications sent with 3 of the 4 profiles. However, only 1/4 of applications associated to the first profile mention the nationality. The priming of the nationality signal will be included whatever the profile (and only if the nationality is explicitly mentioned for profile 1) in the half of the CV templates that include a short text in the CV (only 2 of 4 templates among authorize short sentences). There are three hobbies for each of the four applications. The first two hobbies are “template dependent” while the third CV varies according to the type of the third hobby (core signal). Firstnames and lastnames are randomly selected from separate lists of first names and surnames associated with the different origins. Finally, specific wording for residency rights is selected, if necessary, from three different formulations.
Clusters
6400 CVs sent to 200 applications in 8 occupations.
Observations
6400 CVs
Arms
1600 CVs for Profile 1 1600 CVs for Profile 2 1600 CVs for Profile 3 1600 CVs for Profile 4
Primary outcomes
Callback by nationality ; country of origin ; perceived country of origin ; gender and cross-tabulations
Secondary outcomes
- Intensity of callbacks (number of callbacks) – Callback on the intensive margin – Signals (gender, origin, civic engagement, experience, level of French, explicit mention of type of residence permit, citizenship priming, place of education (as a proxy for place of birth) – Occupation characteristics (level of French proficiency, labor market tightness, share of foreigners, share of women) – Firm characteristics (share of foreigners, share of women, size of the firm, age of the firm) – Characteristics of HR (gender and origin – subject to DPO agreement)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords