Gender Discrimination in Financial Advising: Evidence from the Chinese Market

How to cite

Li, Huailu; Leong, Kaiwen; Xu, Zhanyu; Lang, Kevin. 2024. "Gender Discrimination in Financial Advising: Evidence from the Chinese Market." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014873. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14873-1.4

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Huailu Li* , Kaiwen Leong , Zhanyu Xu , Kevin Lang

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014873
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14873-1.4
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2024-04-15 – 2025-06-30
Countries
China (Shantou)
JEL codes
D91, D14, J16, J71
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14873

Abstract

We conducted an audit study where trained potential investors visited securities firms in China during both bearish and bullish stock market conditions. Across all market conditions, women were consistently given more conservative financial recommendations and were advised to allocate a smaller proportion of their investments to stocks compared to men. Additionally, during bearish periods, financial advisors offered female investors significantly higher commission discounts than male investors, whereas less significant differences in discounts were observed during bullish periods.

Intervention

This audit study aims to investigate how financial advisors at securities firms offer gender-differentiated financial advice and commission discounts, and to explore the underlying mechanisms behind these behaviors.

To establish causal relationships, we use a RCT design. Auditors are randomly assigned to distinct “investor roles” based on a combination of individual characteristics such as gender, local status, risk preference, and other observable traits. The roles are assigned randomly to ensure that the only difference between auditors is their gender. This randomization allows us to infer that any differences in financial recommendations or commission discounts received by auditors are due to gender-based discrimination by the financial advisors.

Auditors are then sent to various branches of securities firms, where they are served by financial advisors who are also randomly assigned by the firms. This randomization of both auditors and advisors enables us to isolate the effect of gender on the financial advice and commission offers provided.

The audit study is conducted in two rounds. Round 1 takes place during a typical bearish market, while Round 2 is conducted during a 'bullish' market influenced by an unexpected positive policy shock. This two-round approach allows us to assess how financial advice and commission offers may change in response to shifts in market conditions.

Additionally, we survey financial advisors to better understand the motivations and factors influencing their behavior. These surveys provide valuable insights into the mechanisms driving gender-differentiated financial advice.

Experimental design

Our study investigates the investment advisory practices of securities firms in a southern city in China. We identified the full universe of securities firms and their branches using publicly available data platforms and confirmed their eligibility for the study through direct contact. Auditors, resembling typical retail investors, visited branches to interact with financial advisors. The study comprised four rounds, with the first round spanning four months, the second conducted over two weeks, and the third and fourth rounds each lasting less than three weeks. Auditors were trained with standardized guidelines and conversation templates to ensure consistency in their interactions. During the visits, auditors collected detailed information about investment recommendations, commission practices, and other related advice. Compensation for auditors ensured their commitment to the study.

Design details

Randomization method
Random assignment of auditor characteritics was done by a computer.
Randomization unit
Individual (auditor)
Clusters
N/A
Observations
In total, there are 10624 visits.
Arms
In each round, 32 auditors with unique randomized characteristics visited each branch for two meetings. In Round 1, they visited 42 active branches across 26 securities firms, completing 2,880 total visits. In Round 2, auditors visited 41 branches across 25 firms, completing 2,624 visits. In Rounds 3 and 4, they visited 40 branches across 25 firms, completing 2,560 total visits. Since four distinct sets of auditors were dispatched across the four rounds, a total of 128 unique auditors were hired for the entire study.
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes examine whether financial advisors provide differentiated investment suggestions based on the gender or other characteristics of potential investors. Since the commission charged varies with the investment bundles recommended, we also investigate whether the discounts offered by financial advisors differ based on the investor's characteristics.
Secondary outcomes
The second outcome examines the mechanism behind the observed discriminatory behavior of financial advisors towards potential investors.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords