The Impacts of Employee Excellence Rewards on Workers and Firms: The Role of Managerial Discretion vs. Worker Empowerment
How to cite
Kala, Namrata; McKelway, Madeline. 2024. "The Impacts of Employee Excellence Rewards on Workers and Firms: The Role of Managerial Discretion vs. Worker Empowerment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014861. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14861-3.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In this project, we will investigate the impact of workplace excellence rewards on workers’ productivity, attendance, earnings, and firm culture. It would be conducted in rural Uttar Pradesh, India in partnership with a large carpet producing firm, in 150 small firms that the partner firm sources from. The intervention will randomize whether and how bonuses for workplace excellence worth about 10% of the average worker wage are allocated. We would randomize, at the firm-level, whether bonuses for carpet workers are allocated (a) based on managerial discretion or (b) worker voting. We will use data on productivity, attendance, earnings, and perceptions about firm culture to understand whether and how different systems of rewarding workers can improve outcomes for workers and firms.
Intervention
Our partner firm sources carpet orders from many small firms, each with around 5-50 carpet weavers (the workers) and one manager. The intervention we study will be a clustered randomized control trial, with 150 small firms. We will randomize whether a firm gets a workplace excellence reward program or not (the control group will also get rewards, but allocated at random). The recipient of the reward would either be decided by the manager, or via worker voting (the allocation mechanism would be randomly chosen). There will be one bonus for every 10 workers. Every two weeks, the recipients will be announced, and the reward will be given out in a small ceremony. The intervention will continue for 3 months. The random allocation (for the control group) would be done through a public lottery to ensure workers knew the allocation was truly random.
Experimental design
We would randomize each of 150 loom centers to one of the following treatments (each arm will have 50 loom centers):
1. The manager chooses which worker the bonus is paid to (managerial discretion treatment).
2. Workers choose via voting which worker the bonus is paid to (worker empowerment treatment).
3. The bonus is allocated at random (control group).
Bonuses will be given fortnightly for three months, and will be roughly equal to 10% of workers’ average monthly wages.
We will use pairwise stratification to maximize power. Specifically, we will form groups of three firms, matched on gender and average worker attendance at baseline, and randomize within these groups. Firms may attrit, leaving their strata without observations from each treatment group for many outcomes. In such cases, we will pool the incomplete strata with the strata of the same gender that has the closest baseline attendance level when estimating treatment effects.
Outcomes will be measured both during and after the three months of bonuses.
We will estimate two main specifications: one that pools both treatments and compares them to the control, and one that estimates effects of the two treatment arms separately. We will use baseline controls and LASSO to improve precision.
We will test for heterogeneity by: firm gender (these are single-gender workplaces), whether worker is a worker the manager said at baseline they were close to, and worker’s baseline preference for bonus allocation mechanism.
We will also record the workers who came in second place in each treatment arm. In the control arm, all workers not randomly selected for the reward will be considered second place. This will allow us to estimate the impact of winning a bonus on workers' outcomes (described above), and also how that impact differs based on how the bonus was allocated.
Note: we revised the outcomes and proposed analyses described here on Feb 7, 2025. This was about a third of the way into our intervention phase but before we estimated any treatment effects.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.