Scientists as Citizens: Towards Human-First Network State

How to cite

Saqr, Khalid. 2025. "Scientists as Citizens: Towards Human-First Network State." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014840. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14840-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Khalid Saqr*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014840
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14840-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-10-01 – 2026-09-30
Countries
United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland (), Japan (), Malaysia (), Turkey (), United States of America ()
JEL codes
D72, D83, D91, E71
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14840

Abstract

This randomized controlled trial, Scientists as Citizens: Towards Human-First Network State, explores how decentralized governance models, augmented by AI for knowledge discovery and synthesis, can empower scientists as digital citizens, knowledge creators, and decision-makers. The study addresses systemic challenges in global science, such as funding inequities, irreproducibility, and peer-review inefficiencies.

The trial engages a stratified random sample of 384 scientists from the ORCID database, distributed across three experimental groups to examine varying interaction models: individual engagement (non-cooperative), team-based collaboration (semi-cooperative), and AI-assisted collective interaction (human-first network state). Participants will engage in five structured scenarios representing real-world challenges: resource allocation, collaborative research, peer review, ethical dilemmas, and policy deliberation. AI agents will play a facilitative role in enhancing data analysis, decision-making, and policy evaluation processes.

Key metrics include collective intelligence, equity in governance, trust in AI systems, ethical alignment, and participant well-being. The trial hypothesizes that the human-first network state model will outperform non-cooperative and semi-cooperative models in fostering superior behavioral and decision-making outcomes, including trust, efficiency, and ethical alignment.

This research aims to provide actionable insights into how AI-augmented governance frameworks can redefine global scientific ecosystems, promoting equitable, sustainable, and impactful practices for academia and R&D communities. By analyzing scientists' behaviors as digital citizens, the trial seeks to validate the transformative potential of the human-first network state in creating a new paradigm for decentralized governance.

Intervention

The trial involves five distinct scenarios tailored to test the impact of decentralized governance augmented by AI on the behavior of scientists as digital citizens. These scenarios are designed to reflect real-world challenges and decision-making processes encountered by scientists in academia and research-based organizations. The interventions aim to bridge the gap between traditional governance models and innovative, AI-powered frameworks for knowledge management and policy implementation.

Experimental design

This trial is designed to investigate the role of AI-assisted governance systems in enhancing collaborative decision-making, ethical alignment, and equitable resource allocation within a human-first network state framework. Conducted entirely online, the study focuses on how scientists interact with AI agents and each other under varying levels of collaboration.

Study Overview
Participants are randomly assigned to one of three groups to explore different interaction models:

Individual Engagement (Non-Cooperative Model): Participants work independently to complete tasks without external collaboration or AI assistance.
Team-Based Collaboration (Semi-Cooperative Model): Participants form small teams to collaboratively complete tasks with minimal AI involvement.
AI-Assisted Collective Interaction (Human-First Network State Model): Participants work together as a single team, with AI agents facilitating communication, decision-making, and conflict resolution.
The trial comprises five progressive scenarios:

Resource Allocation and Prioritization
Collaborative Research Design
Peer Review and Ethical Decision-Making
Ethical Dilemmas and Governance Policies
Policy Deliberation and Voting
Key Outcomes
The primary outcomes include:

Collective Intelligence: Measuring the quality and efficiency of decision-making processes.
Equity in Governance: Evaluating fairness in resource distribution and participation.
Trust in AI: Assessing participants’ confidence in AI-assisted systems.
Ethical Alignment: Determining the alignment of decisions with shared ethical principles.
Secondary outcomes explore technological usability, interdisciplinary collaboration, and conflict resolution.

Public Accessibility
The trial focuses on building foundational insights into how AI-augmented governance can enhance equity and efficiency in scientific and organizational contexts. While specific data and findings will remain confidential until the trial concludes, the overall design and methodology are publicly available to encourage replication and further exploration in related studies.

All participant data will remain perpetually anonymized to ensure privacy and confidentiality. Results will be disseminated after trial completion to advance the understanding of human-machine interactions in governance contexts.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is done on two stages. First a random number is assigned to every participant upon registration, then a digital lottery algorithm is used to assign participants to each group.
Randomization unit
Participant
Clusters
384 participants.
Observations
384 participants
Arms
128 participant for the individual group, 128 participants for the human-teams group, 128 for the human-AI teams group
Primary outcomes
The primary outcome variables in this experiment are designed to evaluate the transformative potential of the human-first network state in facilitating equitable, participatory, and efficient human-machine interactions. Drawing inspiration from leading social experiments in human-machine collaboration, the outcomes are defined as follows: Collective Intelligence Enhancement (CIE): Measures the improvement in group problem-solving capacity, informed by the synergy between human participants and AI agents. This includes indicators such as solution diversity, time-to-solution efficiency, and the quality of outputs in collaborative tasks. Equity in Governance and Participation (EGP): Assesses the fairness and inclusiveness of decision-making processes within the network state. Key metrics include the balance of resource distribution, representation of diverse viewpoints, and engagement levels across participant demographics. Trust and Ethical Alignment with AI (TEA): Evaluates participant trust in AI systems and their alignment with the ethical norms of the group. Metrics include trust scores derived from surveys, adherence to ethical guidelines, and the perceived transparency of AI-mediated processes. Behavioral Adaptation and Agency (BAA): Tracks shifts in individual and collective behavior when interacting with AI-driven governance mechanisms. Indicators include participant autonomy, acceptance of AI recommendations, and the evolution of decision-making strategies over time. Satisfaction and Well-being (SWB): Gauges participant satisfaction with the network state's processes and outcomes, alongside their overall sense of well-being. Metrics include self-reported satisfaction scores, stress levels, and qualitative reflections on their experiences.
Secondary outcomes
The secondary outcomes in this experiment focus on assessing the broader implications and ancillary effects of the human-first network state on participants’ cognitive, social, and technological interactions. These outcomes aim to capture latent variables and emergent behaviors that contribute to the robustness of the primary outcomes. Key secondary outcomes include: Technological Adoption and Usability (TAU): Evaluates the ease of use, adoption rates, and participant engagement with AI tools in the network state. Metrics include interaction frequency, system usability scores, and feedback on AI features. Cultural and Interdisciplinary Collaboration (CIC): Assesses the extent to which the network state fosters cross-disciplinary and cross-cultural collaboration among participants. Indicators include diversity in team contributions, interdisciplinary knowledge integration, and inclusivity of perspectives. Resilience and Conflict Resolution (RCR): Measures the network state’s capacity to mediate disputes and resolve conflicts among participants. Metrics include the resolution time for conflicts, the frequency of escalations, and satisfaction with conflict outcomes. Knowledge Synthesis and Dissemination (KSD): Captures the ability of the network state to generate, synthesize, and disseminate actionable insights. Metrics include the quality of synthesized outputs, participant knowledge retention, and the rate of sharing outputs within and outside the system.
Partners
Name: ScienceWerx Inc Partner_type: ngo Url: https://www.sciencewerx.org/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords