CEO Gender and Beliefs about Firm Performance: an experimental approach

How to cite

Ferrario, Beatrice; Carvalho, Marcela. 2024. "CEO Gender and Beliefs about Firm Performance: an experimental approach." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014832. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14832-3.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Beatrice Ferrario* , Marcela Carvalho

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014832
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14832-3.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-03-04 – 2025-03-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14832

Abstract

Does CEO gender influence how we perceive firm performance? If so, why? In this paper, we take an experimental approach to address these issues. We design an experiment where the assignment of CEO gender is randomized and measure the extent to which gender affects participants’ forecasts of firm profits. In the experiment, participants predict the profits of three real US public companies, one of which has the gender of its CEO (disclosed via a picture) altered. The design includes a ‘pessimism’ versus ‘optimism’ treatment that allows us to randomly induce participants to make positive or negative forecast revisions. By defining positive (negative) forecast revisions as good (bad) news, this allows us to test whether the effect of CEO gender on beliefs is intermediated through the sign of the news received.

Intervention

The experiment is an online study ran on Prolific. The main task that participants are asked to perform is to forecast firms’ profits upon the provision of information.
Main Randomization: Participants will be asked to review information about and make predictions for the profits of three real US firm-quarter pairs. For two out of the three pairs, all the information provided will be true. But for one randomly chosen firm-quarter pair out of the three, there will be a fictional component. This fictional component will be the identity of the CEO, which will be female in case the real CEO is male, or vice-versa. For each participant, the three firm-quarter pairs will be randomly selected out of a population of 48 firm-quarter pairs – 24 whose actual CEO in a given time period is a woman and 24 whose CEO is a male.
For each of the three firm-quarter pairs, there will be eight steps that participants will be asked to complete the following steps:
1. Read information about the firm and the CEO.
2. Observe a graph with past profits (past three quarters). Respondents will be asked for a qualitative prediction for the next quarter.
3. Observe the same graph with past profits, but now with an additional feature: two expert forecasts for profits in the next quarter.
4. Make predictions for profits in the next two quarters.
5. Build a confidence interval around the prediction for the second quarter.
6. Learn the actual profit in the first quarter. Make a new prediction for the second quarter.
7. Answer understanding questions.
8. Answer evaluation questions
After completing the eight steps for each of the three firm-quarter pairs, participants will be asked to answer standard demographic and financial literacy questions.

We embed two other randomizations in the experiment:
Optimism vs Pessimism Treatment: For each firm-quarter pair, we randomize whether the pair of experts’ forecasts is optimistic (in the sense that forecasts are higher than the actual realization) or pessimistic (in the sense that forecasts are lower than the actual realization). By providing experts’ forecasts, we aim to benchmark individual’s forecasts. This randomization then allows us to exogenously induce a positive revision (good news)
or negative revision (bad news) in step 6.
"Before and After" vs "Only After" Treatment: For each participant, we randomize whether evaluation questions will be answered "only after" their forecast revision, in step 8, or will be answered both "before and after" making this revision. In the latter treatment, we add a page between steps 1 and 2 where respondents answer evaluation questions. The purpose of this randomization is twofold. It allows us to observe whether "prior" answers are different from "posterior" answers. It also works as a salience treatment: since one of the questions points to the role of the CEO in affecting firm performance,
the relevance of the CEO should be more salient for respondents who answer the evaluation questions before making predictions.

Experimental design

Participants will be asked to review information about and make predictions for the profits of three real US companies. For two out of the three companies, all the information provided will be true. But for one randomly chosen company out of the three, there’ll be a fictional component. This fictional component will be the identity of the CEO, which will be female in case the real CEO is male, or vice-versa. For each participant, the three companies will be randomly selected out of a population of 48 company-quarter pairs – 24 whose actual CEO in a given time period is a woman and 24 whose CEO is a male.

For each of the three companies, there will be six steps that participants will be asked to complete:
1. Read information about the company and the CEO.
2. Observe a graph with past profits and two expert forecasts for profits in the next quarter.
3. Make predictions for profits in the next two quarters.
4. Build a confidence interval around the prediction for the first quarter.
5. Learn the actual profit in the first quarter. Make new prediction for the second quarter.
6. Answer some questions regarding one’s personal opinion.
For each company there is a “good news” versus “bad news” treatment which will be randomly assigned. Under the “good news” treatment, the participant will observe two expert forecasts in step 2 that are both below the actual profit in that period. Hence, in step 5, this participant will receive “good news” because the actual profits will be above what experts expected. Under the “bad news” treatment, the two expert forecasts will be both above the actual profit in that period so that there will be “bad news” in step 5. This allows me to understand if the gender-treatment effects depend on whether good or bad news is observed. Note that under both treatments – good news or bad news – participants are observing true information that has been curated to that specific case. In the database of analysts’ forecasts, the companies in this experiment are among those that have at least four analyst forecasts: at least two forecasts above and at least two forecasts below the realization for a given quarter. After completing the 6 steps for each of the three companies, participants will be asked to answer standard demographic and financial literacy questions.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization coded in the software (i.e., done by a computer).
Randomization unit
The randomization of the CEO gender is performed within individuals (i.e., at the firm- quarter level). Every individual will have the CEO gender of one of the three firm-quarter pairs altered.
Clusters
We plan to survey 1,500 respondents in total, excluding respondents who fail both attention checks (these respondents are indeed "dropped" directly in Prolific and will not count towards the target of 1,500). However, the target size of 1,500 participants includes those respondents that will be excluded from the analysis, either because they failed one or more of the understanding questions or because they failed one of the attention checks.
Observations
Since each respondent will perform the forecasting exercise for three firm-quarter pairs, we plan to have 4,500 firm-quarter-respondent observations in total. Note that some of these observations will be removed from the analysis as explained above.
Arms
One third of the firm-quarter-respondent observations are treated (i.e., they see a manip- ulated CEO gender) and two thirds firm-quarter-respondent observations are not treated (i.e., they observe the true CEO gender). This will result in half of the sample observing a male CEO and the other half observing a female CEO. Half of the respondents will answer the evaluation questions both before and after the forecasting exercise and half of the sample will answer these questions only after the forecasting exercise. Half of the firm-quarter-respondent observations will be randomly assigned a pair of opti- mistic experts’ forecasts and the other half will be randomly assigned a pair of pessimistic experts’ forecasts.
Primary outcomes
Forecast errors for profits in the second quarter.
Secondary outcomes
Qualitative prediction for profits in the next quarter; Confidence intervals on point forecast; Evaluation questions.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords