This document proposes a study to examine pre-service teachers’ (PSTs) valuations of internship amenities in Salvador, Brazil, through the lens of the Pedagogical Support and Activities Program (PAAP). Despite PAAP’s potential to benefit both student learning and PST development through active tutoring roles, the program currently operates below capacity, filling only about 800 of 1,500 available positions. Using survey data and a discrete choice experiment, we investigate the questions: how do PSTs value different internship amenities such as salary, schedule flexibility, and internship quality? Our findings will inform the Municipal Secretary of Education’s (Secretaria Municipal de Educação, SMED) efforts to improve PAAP recruitment and contribute to the broader literature on how PSTs value internship amenities. This research has immediate policy implications for the design of teacher training programs and adds to our understanding of PST preferences when determining where to complete student-teaching experiences.
Intervention
This is not an intervention study, but rather a proposal to conduct a discrete choice experiment examining pre-service teachers' willingness to pay for internship amenities.
Experimental design
The experiment uses a discrete choice design where PSTs select between two hypothetical internship options in a series of tasks, with each option differing by randomly assigned attributes. These tasks allow us to estimate the relative importance of each attribute in PSTs' decision-making and calculate WTP for each attribute. We additionally conduct heterogeneity analyses across subgroups identified as potentially significant through preliminary focus group discussions.
Design details
Randomization method
The randomization method for this experiment involves independently varying each attribute level in the hypothetical internship scenarios across choice tasks. Specifically:
1. Random Assignment of Attributes: For each choice task, internship attributes—salary, commute time, schedule flexibility, mentor teacher support, and teaching practice opportunities—are independently and randomly assigned to create two unique internship options. This ensures that PSTs view a range of attribute combinations and that each attribute is orthogonally varied across tasks.
2. Choice Tasks Per Participant: Each participant completes six choice tasks. Within each task, the attribute levels are randomly determined, creating two internship options that differ across the five attributes. This randomization across tasks enables us to estimate how changes in each attribute affect the likelihood of an internship being chosen, as well as the WTP for each attribute.
3. Survey Implementation: The randomization is implemented within the survey platform (Qualtrics), which assigns attribute levels based on predefined probabilities. This platform ensures the random assignment is conducted correctly and consistently across participants.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization in this experiment is the individual participant (pre-service teacher). Each PST is independently presented with a set of choice tasks, where internship attributes are randomly assigned to create unique internship options within each task.
Clusters
No clusters
Observations
300 respondents given six tasks with two choices. n = 3,600.
Arms
N/A
Primary outcomes
The key outcome variables in this experiment are the pre-service teachers' (PSTs) choices in hypothetical internship scenarios with varying attributes. These attributes include monthly salary, commute time, scheduling flexibility, mentor teacher support, and teaching practice opportunities. Our primary outcome of interest is PSTs' willingness-to-pay (WTP) for each of these internship amenities.
Secondary outcomes
Secondary outcomes include the heterogeneity in preferences across subgroups, such as socio-economic status, gender, level of preparedness for teaching, certification area, and university type (public vs. private). We are also interested in the likelihood of PSTs’ participation in PAAP based on demographic and background characteristics.
Partners
Name: Secretaria Municipal da Educação, Prefeitura de Salvador
Partner_type: municipality
Url: https://educacao3.salvador.ba.gov.br/
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.