Inequality and Preferences for Distribution: Insights from a Large-Scale Experiment
How to cite
Pignataro, Giuseppe; Joxhe, Majlinda.
2024. "Inequality and Preferences for Distribution: Insights from a Large-Scale Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014808.
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14808-1.1
Download:
BibTeX
·
RIS— for reference managers without a browser
translator. Zotero and most
others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
D31 – Personal Income, Wealth, and Their Distributions; D63 – Equity, Justice, Inequality, and Other Normative Criteria and Measurement C91 – Laboratory, Individual Behavior H23 – Externalities; Re-distributive Effects; Environmental Taxes and Subsidies
Inequality has long been a pervasive issue within societies worldwide, perpetuating disparities in wealth, opportunity, and access to resources. Despite advancements in various domains, the persistence of inequality remains a significant concern. Central to this discourse is the notion of redistribution -- an approach aimed at rectifying disparities by reallocating resources, opportunities, or privileges among members of a society. The effectiveness of such measures often depends on the support and willingness of individuals within the community to endorse and advocate for re-distributive policies. However, understanding the factors that influence individuals' preferences for redistribution remains an ongoing area of inquiry. One compelling feature for exploring the dynamics of preferences for redistribution lies in the idea of raising awareness about inequality. Our study underlies on the idea that increasing awareness about the extent and consequences of inequality might significantly impact individuals' attitudes and preferences towards re-distributive policies. This assumption is grounded in the belief that a deeper understanding of the injustices and ramifications of inequality could potentially stimulate greater support for measures aimed at rectifying these disparities. Hence, this research aims to investigate the relationship between raising awareness about inequality and its subsequent influence on individuals' preferences for redistribution. Through an experimental setup employing a -controlled intervention-simulated video -- this study aims to investigate the causal link between created awareness of inequality and the inclination towards endorsing altruism and re-distribute behavior. The insights from this study may offer valuable guidance in shaping inclusive and equitable policies that align with the sentiments and aspirations of diverse societal segments. Our research motivation underscores the importance of exploring how raising awareness about inequality may serve as a catalyst in influencing individuals' support for redistribution, thereby offering a nuanced understanding crucial for fostering a fairer and more equal society. To achieve our research objectives, we developed a comprehensive methodology combining a survey framework with an experimental intervention designed to manipulate information perception through a targeted video presentation on inequality.
Intervention
Inequality in various forms -- economic, gender-based, educational, and migratory -- shapes societies profoundly, influencing everything from social cohesion to individual opportunities. Despite widespread attention to these issues, there remains a critical gap in understanding how people perceive different forms of inequality and what drives their willingness to support policies aimed at reducing disparities. Our randomized controlled trial seeks to fill this gap by exploring how individuals react to diverse forms of inequality and how these reactions influence their attitudes and beliefs toward policies that could address these issues. This study involves the presentation of four unique video interventions, each crafted to illustrate one type of inequality. Participants will be randomly assigned to one of these videos, which specifically address economic, gender, educational, or migration inequalities. Each video combines real-life examples, statistics, and narratives to highlight the impact of these disparities on individuals and communities, with the intention of eliciting thoughtful reflection and emotional engagement. The core objective of this intervention is to assess whether raising awareness through targeted visual storytelling can shift beliefs and increase support for redistributive and inclusive policies. By analyzing the differences in responses across groups, we hope to uncover insights into the specific factors that shape individuals' perceptions and motivations regarding inequality. This research ultimately seeks to inform the design of policies and campaigns that resonate more deeply with public values and priorities, supporting a more inclusive and equitable society. Our main goal is to capture the responses to each type of inequality and identify how exposure to information about different forms of disparity impacts individuals' support for policies aimed at reducing such inequalities. We believe that a better understanding of these dynamics can lead to more effective advocacy and policymaking, aligning public support with initiatives that address inequality holistically. Our hypothesis is that targeted awareness-raising interventions can create a measurable change in the way individuals perceive and are willing to act upon different forms of inequality. Specifically, we expect that those exposed to information on economic inequality may show greater support for policies like progressive taxation, while those who view content on gender inequality may become more inclined to support workplace equality measures. This nuanced approach will provide a comprehensive view of how different aspects of inequality are prioritized by individuals and what types of messaging are most effective in promoting social cohesion and equity.
Experimental design
This study aims to examine how different forms of inequality -- economic, educational, gender, and migratory -- are perceived by individuals and influence their attitudes towards redistributive actions. Participants are randomly assigned to one of four treatment groups, each exposed to a video addressing a specific type of inequality. Each video aims to raise awareness and provoke thought on the respective inequality topic. Following the video, participants complete tasks designed to measure their beliefs, intentions, and possible actions related to inequality and redistribution.
Design details
Randomization method
The randomization process for this study was designed to ensure a fair and unbiased distribution of participants across the various treatment and control groups. The agency awarded the contract for this experiment has employed a computer-based random number generator, executed in an office environment under controlled conditions, to allocate participants randomly. Specifically, each participant was assigned a unique identification number upon enrollment. Using specialized software, we then applied a randomization algorithm that assigned each individual to one of the four treatment groups or the control group with equal probability.
This computer-generated approach was chosen to eliminate any potential human bias and to maintain the integrity of the randomization process. By leveraging advanced randomization algorithms, we ensured that each participant had an identical chance of being assigned to any group, enhancing the internal validity of our study. Furthermore, this method allows for replicability and transparency in our methodology, as the computer algorithm used can be independently reviewed and audited if necessary.
To further reinforce the reliability of our randomization procedure, we conducted a series of preliminary checks post-randomization to confirm that key baseline characteristics (e.g., age, gender, socioeconomic background) were evenly balanced across groups. This additional step ensures that any observed effects in our results are more likely attributable to the intervention itself, rather than to underlying differences between groups.
In sum, the use of a computer-based randomization method in this study reflects our commitment to upholding rigorous scientific standards, fostering confidence in the robustness of our findings, and contributing valuable insights to the field.
Randomization unit
In this study, the primary unit of randomization is the individual participant. Each participant is assigned to one of the treatment groups or the control group independently, ensuring that each person has an equal chance of being allocated to any of the experimental conditions. This individual-level randomization approach allows us to capture a wide range of personal reactions and preferences to the interventions, thus enhancing the robustness of our findings by controlling for individual variability.
Additionally, to manage logistical aspects of our study design, sessions were organized for small groups where randomization was implemented at the individual level within each session. This approach maintains random assignment integrity while optimizing data collection procedures.
If applicable, any subsequent analyses will account for the session clustering in our statistical models, ensuring accurate inferences about the treatment effects.
Clusters
The design of our study prioritizes the formation of diverse clusters to capture a wide spectrum of gender, demographic, and geographic characteristics within the target population. Each cluster will be composed of participants selected to represent specific population segments relevant to our research objectives, allowing us to explore variations in response to the intervention with greater granularity. These clusters will serve as the primary unit of randomization, ensuring that the diversity within each grouping mirrors broader social patterns. By structuring the clusters to capture heterogeneity in terms of age, gender, income, and regional factors, we aim to facilitate a more precise understanding of how various groups may experience or respond differently to the interventions being tested. The organization into clusters not only enhances the robustness and representativeness of the data but also allows for targeted analysis of subgroup effects. This approach ensures that the study outcomes will be both nuanced and reflective of the complex social dynamics at play, providing insights that are generalizable yet sensitive to distinct population characteristics.
Observations
Our study aims for a planned number of observations around 20,000 individuals, as specified in our agreement with the implementing agency. This large sample size is systematically divided into clusters, designed to capture a representative cross-section of the target population. Each cluster will consist of a subset of these 20,000 participants, ensuring that our observations cover a broad array of characteristics and allow for a relevant analysis across various segments. The approach of clustering within a substantial sample size enhances the generalizability of our findings and provides a robust framework for identifying patterns, behaviors, and responses that may differ based on factors like region, gender, income, and age.
Arms
We have organized the 20,000 participants into four treatment groups and one control group, each containing 4,000 individuals, to examine the distinct effects of interventions focused on different types of inequality: economic, gender, educational, and migration-related. This structure allows us to analyze the impact of each intervention separately, while the control group provides a crucial baseline for comparison. To achieve a representative sample, participants are grouped into clusters, with each cluster assigned to one of the treatment groups or the control. This clustering strategy ensures a diverse representation of demographic and geographic characteristics across the sample, enhancing the validity of our findings. By carefully balancing these factors, we can perform a nuanced analysis of how beliefs and behaviors vary across the different dimensions of inequality, as well as explore potential interactions when multiple inequalities are addressed simultaneously.
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes of this study is the measurement of individuals' preferences for re-distribution.As literature show, individuals are more likely to favor a progressive tax system where the wealthiest segment of the population (top 1%) contributes a disproportionately higher share of public taxes compared to lower-income groups. Specifically, the perception of fairness in tax distribution will lead respondents to allocate a higher tax burden to the richest groups while reducing the burden for the bottom 50% of the population, reflecting
We aim to examine the impact of awareness-raising videos on participants' preferences for tax distribution across income groups. Participants are initially asked to allocate what they believe to be a fair percentage of the tax burden across various income segments (top 1%, next 9%, next 40%, and bottom 50%). After responding, the treatment group watches videos on inequality, addressing income and gender disparities, while the control group does not view any video. Following this, all participants are asked to reassess their preferred tax distribution. By comparing changes within individuals' responses (pre- and post-video) and across the treatment and control groups, this study seeks to determine whether increased awareness influences willingness to endorse a more progressive tax distribution, where higher-income groups bear a larger share of the tax burden relative to lower-income groups.
The other relevant outcome of of this study is the inclusion of experimental games for measuring individuals' preferences and behaviors regarding altruism, and risk-taking. These outcomes will be assessed through two distinct games designed to reveal participants' willingness to share, reciprocate, and engage in financially risky behavior. These games will be introduced after participants have viewed one of four videos, each addressing different forms of inequality: economic, educational, gender, or migration related.
Secondary outcomes
The secondary outcomes assess participants' intentions and beliefs related to charitable giving and social support. After completing the primary games, participants are asked about their willingness to donate to a charity focused on social equity and support. This measure allows us to examine the potential spillover effects of awareness on direct altruistic behaviors.
In addition to donation intentions, secondary outcomes include self-reported measures of attitudes and beliefs towards inequality across economic, educational, gender, and migration domains. These attitudes will be measured using survey items that gauge participants' support for policies or actions that address these types of inequality.
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.