Unlocking agricultural potential through bundled services? Experimental evidence from a digital platform in Ghana
How to cite
Petrik, Christina; Asiedu, Edward; Grimm, Michael; Lay, Jann; Wirth, Olivia. 2024. "Unlocking agricultural potential through bundled services? Experimental evidence from a digital platform in Ghana." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014802. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14802-3.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Agricultural productivity in Sub-Saharan Africa remains low compared to other areas of the world due to the various constraints that smallholder farmers face. Since addressing one constraint is typically insufficient, we evaluate the effects of bundled agricultural services that simultaneously tackle multiple constraints for farmers. We will implement a randomized controlled trial to investigate the impacts of four different service bundles for predominantly female soybean farmers in Northern Ghana. Initially, the implementation was planned for the 2024 season, however a severe drought in Northern Ghana and a flood in some communities prevented our implementing partner WamiAgro Ltd., an agricultural platform, from offering the intended service bundles in most of the communities in our sample. Therefore, we decided to conduct a second baseline survey in 2025 to elicit farmers' perceptions of changing weather patterns and their adaptation strategies, which may vary depending on the severity of droughts and floods. We proceed with the original experimental design in the 2025 season. In control communities, WamiAgro will provide farmers with weather information and training on farming practices, as well as the option to sell their soybeans via the platform, termed “Info + Market”. Our three treatment arms will add a soil test (“Soil test”), credit for harvesting and threshing (“Credit”), or a soil test and credit for harvesting and threshing (“Soil test + Credit”). We will analyze the effects of each treatment on agricultural production, land use, labor demand, and household welfare. The hypothesized impact of the soil test is that it will enhance farmers' understanding of their soil's health, enabling them to adjust their input selections and optimize the timing of their applications accordingly. We also expect improvements in self-reported soil quality, changes in production costs, and higher yields. For the credit treatment, we hypothesize that it increases the efficiency of harvesting and threshing. Mechanized threshing preserves the output quality, potentially leading to higher output prices, sales, and incomes. We predict changes in labor demand and costs, as well as changes in household labor allocation due to increased mechanization. Households may also have lower levels of financial distress. One of the main research questions is whether soil tests and credit services are complements. Once farmers have optimized their inputs and practices based on soil test results, they are more likely to achieve higher yields. However, without sufficient resources for harvesting and threshing, these gains could be lost. Access to credit ensures that farmers can fully capitalize on the improved productivity by enabling timely and efficient post-harvest operations, thus preserving the quality and quantity of the produce. These synergies can improve outcomes in the short term and in future planting seasons. Lastly, we will assess whether the provision of agricultural extension services affects farmers strategies to cope with adverse weather events.
Intervention
This study evaluates the effectiveness of different bundles of agricultural extension services on smallholder soybean farmers. We implement a randomized controlled trial (RCT) using a 2x2 design. Farming communities are randomized into one of three treatment groups and a control group. The control group receives the standard services offered by WamiAgro Ltd., which consist of information provision, trainings, and granting smallholders access to international markets. In the first treatment group (“Soil test”), each smallholder receives information on their soil’s nutrient composition and crop-specific input recommendations, in addition to the general information provision and market access services provided to the control group. The second treatment group (“Credit”) receives harvesting and/or threshing services on credit along with the general information and market access services. The third treatment group (“Soil test + Credit”) receives both the soil test and the credit service, in addition to the general information and market access service. This design allows to estimate the combined impact of the soil test and credit services as compared to their individual impacts.
Experimental design
Sampling
Our sample consists of smallholder farmers who either previously collaborated with the platform or became new clients in 2024, prior to the start of the trial. We included only those communities that had reported to WamiAgro that they would be farming soybeans in 2024. The platform selected 17 communities based on these eligibility criteria. Each community comprises between one and 14 farmer groups, and a random subset of farmers was selected from each group.
Due to the planting phase already commencing in five communities in the Northern region before the baseline survey could be conducted in June, these communities were replaced with five others in the North East region, ensuring an equivalent number of farmers per group. In total, 1,363 farmers were surveyed for the baseline.
We will also conduct a short survey among the field officers of WamiAgro to collect data on the effects of weather shocks on the community level. These data will provide additional information how the field officers interact with farmers in the face of weather shocks and how services are delivered.
Randomization procedure
The original 17 communities were divided into five strata based on the number of registered farmers in each community. The random assignment into the three treatment groups and the control group was then done within each stratum. Within each treatment group and the control group, the number of farmers to be interviewed was determined so that the number of farmers drawn per group was inversely proportional to the number of farmer groups in each treatment and control group.
The randomization had been done before the five communities had to be replaced. The random assignment was then transferred from the “old” to the “new communities” with only very minor adjustment to the number of sampled farmers per group. Overall, more farmers were sampled to prevent a loss in power in case of attrition.
Spillovers
Given the design of our study, we do not expect significant spillover effects. The treatment groups are geographically dispersed, which minimizes the likelihood of interaction between treated and untreated units. Furthermore, the treatment is highly specific and tailored to individual participants, further reducing the possibility of spillovers. These factors together suggest that any unintended influence of the treatment on control groups is likely to be minimal.
However, we cannot be certain to rule out spillover effects for communities that were assigned a different treatment status, but are located within the same region and geographically relatively close to one another. Therefore, we will test whether knowledge and demand for the use of soil tests and credit services is higher in the untreated communities in our sample that are closer in distance to the respective treatment groups. We can estimate this by incorporating the number of treated soybean farmers within a meaningful radius. This variable will be included both linearly and interacted with the treatment to examine whether spillover effects differ between treated and untreated farmers.
Another way of looking at spillovers is to check for impacts directly at the market level. In the case that the treatments lead to significant improvements in productivity for treated farmers, it could potentially affect local labor markets. Increased demand for labor to manage higher yields or expanded cultivation could drive up wages in treated areas. This effect might spill over into neighboring areas, particularly if there is labor mobility between treated and untreated regions. Similarly, if the treatment results in a substantial increase in soybean production among treated farmers, this could affect local soybean prices. An oversupply in treated regions might lead to a decrease in prices, which could spill over into adjacent markets, especially if these markets are closely linked. Conversely, if the treatment enhances the quality of soybeans, it could lead to price premiums that might influence market prices more broadly. While these impacts are plausible, their magnitude would depend on the scale of the treatment effects and the degree of market integration across regions. It is important to monitor these potential spillovers as they could have broader economic implications beyond the immediate scope of the study. In order to better understand any potential spillover effects, we will collect qualitative data via focus group discussions, interviewing famers, farmer group leaders and field agents in the control and treatment groups.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.