The effect of pre-paid vs post-paid subsidies on electric heating
How to cite
Shen, Peiyao; Friesen, Lana; Nauze, Andrea La; Chen, Yvonne Jie. 2024. "The effect of pre-paid vs post-paid subsidies on electric heating." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014773. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14773-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Existing literature shows that pre-paid metering can reduce electricity consumption by increasing the salience of marginal prices and therefore be welfare improving (Jack & Smith, 2020). Pre-paid metering is also the default charging method for electricity consumption in many developing areas including our study area, which may contribute to their low electric heating consumption in winter. This project builds on the understanding of the impacts of pre-paid metering by considering the design of subsidies when governments wish to increase electric heating consumption, for example, to increase access to homes heated to health standards. In this study, we plan to implement a field experiment linked to administrative data to explore whether low electric heating demand is due to credit constraints, income constraints, or simply a lack of knowledge and experience of electric heating and its health benefits.
Intervention
This registration is for a pilot field study. In this pilot study, villages will be randomly assigned to “treatment 1”, “treatment 2” or “control”. Low-income households will be identified by the government and local village heads. In treatment 1, households will receive a pre-paid subsidy from our research group; in treatment 2, households will receive a post-paid subsidy from our research group.
Experimental design
In the study area, all households must pre-pay for their electricity consumption. To support poor households with the cost of electric heating, the local government provides them with a winter heating subsidy, paid after the winter heating season. Control participants in the study will continue to receive this subsidy (i.e. no intervention). “Treatment 1” villagers will receive an additional maximum of 100 CNY monthly subsidies for December, January and February. The subsidy will be pre-paid directly onto their electricity account. “Treatment 2” villagers will receive the same subsidy for December, January and February but post-paid directly onto their electricity account at the end of winter. In addition, we also use villagers who do not participate and have never been contacted by our research team as a pure control group. To gauge the effect of subsidies on the actual heating, we encourage all participants in treatment 1, treatment 2, and the control group to inform us of their indoor temperature (measured through a provided thermometer) via incentivised text messages (1.5 CNY per message paid on their phone) 18:00-22:00 on Mondays and Fridays of winter.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.