Strengthening Property Tax Administration through Investments in Targeted Enforcement, Transparency, and Legitimacy

How to cite

Meriggi, Niccolò; Lizardo, Pablo Moises Guzman; Prichard, Wilson; Dercon, Stefan. 2024. "Strengthening Property Tax Administration through Investments in Targeted Enforcement, Transparency, and Legitimacy." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014758. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14758-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Niccolò Meriggi* , Pablo Moises Guzman Lizardo , Wilson Prichard , Stefan Dercon

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014758
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14758-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-09-17 – 2026-06-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
H1, H2, H260, H3, H7, H710, O1, O2, O23, P43
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14758

Abstract

This trial evaluates the impact of different strategies to increase property tax compliance amongst property owners within the context of a broader property tax reform in Kenema, Sierra Leone. The setting is characterized by low tax compliance, limited state capacity, limited provision of public services, limited and inconsistent enforcement strategies, and a low perception of legitimacy and trust in the local government.

The objective of this study is to evaluate experimentally how i) increased investments in the capacity of the state to levy taxes, ii) increased civic culture, and iii) increased perception of state effectiveness can help expand fiscal capacity and ultimately affect state effectiveness.

This will be done through three interventions:

1) an enforcement intervention in which defaulters are summoned to a court proceeding,

2) a religious sensitization campaign in which representatives of respected religious institutions motivate defaulter property owners to comply with the property tax, and

3) a public information campaign in which the enforcement activities are made more salient by targeted press coverage describing the enforcement action taken in the city.

We structure the enforcement and the religious interventions in a factorial design to estimate the complementarities between the two interventions. We then estimate the effect of the intervention both on compliance with property taxation and on different measures of perceptions of state capacity, perceptions of quality of local governance, and conditional and unconditional tax morale. We measure compliance using administrative payment data from the Kenema City Council and measure attitudes towards taxation using multiple rounds of data collection. We then implement the public information intervention during the following tax cycle by randomly exposing property owners to the pamphlets. We track the evolution of attitudes, perceptions, and compliance in the context of state effectiveness and property taxation.

Intervention

We have three main interventions. Described below.

1) Enforcement: We randomly assign owners of properties in the city of Kenema and default on their property tax to receive the “enforcement action.” The enforcement action consists of a set of four sequential steps that are part of the enforcement process. Each step is triggered by continued non-compliance after the previous step.
The four steps are:
i) sending an enforcement notice informing individuals that they might be subject to further enforcement action if they do not comply with the property tax and that they are subject to a 5% late payment penalty fee. It also informs individuals of how to pay. ii) Sending a formal court warrant to a specialized Court dealing with compliance with the property tax. This court will be led by representatives of the Paramount Chief and the Council of Chiefs in the Kenema District.
iii) On the day of the court, individuals will be reminded of the Court summon.
iv) The Court will settle the case and determine the course of action for Kenema City Council and the property owner in accordance with the Local Government Act.
For each of the steps described above, the information in the notices will be provided both in written form and in person by the individual delivering the written notification.

2) Religious sensitization campaign: We collaborate with the Interreligious Council of Sierra Leone (IRCSL) to recruit a team of religious experts representing the IRCSL and relevant religious communities. These religious experts will be assigned to visit the properties of the defaulters. During these visits, the religious experts will present a normative argument seeking to motivate tax compliance, following a previously prepared script. This script will emphasize three ideas:
A) The tax compliance is necessary to promote development,
B) That a good citizen must both comply with the tax and demand better public services, and
C) that tax enforcement is a necessary aspect of a well-functioning tax system.

Finally, the religious representatives will remind property owners how to pay property taxes.

3) Public information campaign: In collaboration with the Sierra Leone Association of Journalists (SLAJ), we are designing a campaign to inform the general public about enforcement activities implemented as part of the property tax administration of the city of Kenema. The information campaign is intended to increase awareness of enforcement activities and the new property tax administration system. We will manipulate the probability of exposure to this information via targeted distribution of local newspapers and information pamphlets.
The distribution of such types of papers and pamphlets is a common phenomenon in Kenema, and these are designed as independent media campaigns. As a result, this information will not be attributed to KCC, but rather to an independent third-party reporting on issues about the city.

Experimental design

Our experiment is conducted in two phases.

In the first phase, we will implement the two interventions, “enforcement” and “religious sensitization” following a 2x2 factorial experimental design. Under this design, each property (and their respective property owners) will be assigned to one of four treatment conditions: a pure control condition, an enforcement condition, a religious sensitization condition, and an interaction condition in which the individual is exposed to both the religious sensitization and to enforcement. Upon completion of the intervention, we will conduct another round of data collection to measure all key indicators.

The second phase of the intervention will commence upon completion of the new round of data collection and will consist of the public information campaign. We will randomly assign properties (and their respective property owners) to receive the paper/pamphlet detailing information about the previous enforcement actions that were implemented during the previous cycle as well as the different aspects of the reform. We then again measure both attitudes (through another wave of surveys) and compliance using administrative data.

Finally, at the end of the fiscal cycle, we measure these outcome variables again to estimate the long-term impact of the interventions.

Design details

Randomization method
For all properties that participate in the study, each observation will be randomly assigned to each intervention through a computer algorithm. For example, for the factorial experiment, for each property, we make a draw out of a uniformly distributed variable that can take one of four values. Each value is associated with one treatment condition. Similarly for the public information campaign, each property is assigned to receive the pamphlet based on a draw from a Bernoulli distribution.
Randomization unit
We selected the experimental sample by first clustering all of the defaulter properties in the city based on geographical proximity to each other. Each cluster consisted of approximately 40 to 60 properties. Afterwards, we stratified by cluster. Once we had the experimental sample, we simply randomized at the level of the individual property. Since, we only account for one property owner within each property, this is equivalent to randomizing at the level of the property owner. In the public information intervention, pamphlets will also be randomized at the property level.
Clusters
6357 properties; Sample size of the public information intervention not yet defined.
Observations
6357 properties; Sample size of the public information intervention not yet defined.
Arms
1658 properties control; 1595 properties enforcement action; 1559 properties religious action; 1545 properties both religious action and enforcement action Sample size of the public information intervention not yet defined.
Primary outcomes
The experiment has two main outcome variables. The first is compliance with the property tax at the end of the study. The second is measures of Tax Morale.
Secondary outcomes
As part of our secondary analysis, we have four sets of secondary outcomes: 1) perceptions of the local government’s capacity for enforcement, 2) perceptions of the state legitimacy and quality of governance, and 3) acceptance of enforcement as part of the tax system, and 4) substitute behaviours to tax compliance. Each of these measures is explained more in the following section.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords