Discrimination in Finance

How to cite

Balakina, Olga; Putz, Bianca; Eyting, Markus; Laudenbach, Christine; Kessler, Judd B.. 2024. "Discrimination in Finance." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014745. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14745-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Olga Balakina* , Bianca Putz , Markus Eyting , Christine Laudenbach , Judd B. Kessler

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014745
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14745-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2024-12-19 – 2024-12-29
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14745

Abstract

In this project, we want to investigate the general perception of discrimination in financial services. In particular, we want to find out whether individuals anticipate disparate treatments and outcomes in financial advice situations and what they perceive to be the reason for this. To do so, we run an online survey (Prolific) in which we elicit individuals' experiences with financial advice, perceptions about potential or experienced discrimination, ideas of potentially underlying reasons, as well as strategies to avoid discrimination. While we focus on gender discrimination in financial advice situations, we also ask about discrimination in other domains and across alternative group attributes.

Intervention

We sequentially present four scenarios to participants: receiving financial advice, using the postal service, obtaining services at a car repair shop, and gaining admission to a nightclub. In each scenario, participants are shown five avatars: their avatar plus two pairs representing different-gender fraternal twins—two women and two men—split between two racial groups, with two Black and two White individuals. Participants are asked to assess whether they believe the price and quality of the services would vary based on the avatars in each scenario and to asses how different the prices and quality of the service would be between the avatars presented.
If participants indicate that they expect differences in price or quality, they are then asked to assign a rating from 0 to 100 to each avatar to gauge the perceived price/quality of the services each would receive. Questions regarding price and quality are posed separately.
To introduce variability, we randomly alter the sets of twin-avatars across participants and the sequence of scenarios for each participant. Consequently, each participant encounters the same set of avatars, presented in a randomized order, across all scenarios.

Experimental design

We run the survey, which consists of the following steps:
1. We ask participants for their consent to store their data;
2. In the set of questions, we ask participants to describe themselves by choosing an avatar with their features: skin tone, haircut or a hair accessory, facial hair, glasses or no glasses, and clothing;
3. We follow up with an intervention described above.
4. We asked respondents about the frequency and necessity of the service (all examples) and about their expectations of being discriminated against while getting the service.
5. We inquire about respondents' attitudes to financial advice and how different measures could make the experience of financial advice more pleasant/likely.
6. We finish with five financial literacy questions and questions on demographic characteristics.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
Order of situation within a subject; Avatars presented to respondents between subjects
Clusters
around 600 individuals
Observations
around 600 individuals
Arms
around 600 individuals
Primary outcomes
The following questions identify the outcome variables of interest for each situation: Do you think that, if all five individuals were charged the same price, they would receive the same quality of service or do you think there would be differences in the quality of service they received? (They would all receive the same quality of service/They would receive different qualities of service.) Please specify the qualities of service that you think the different clients would receive by dragging and dropping the avatars to the respective positions on the slider (0-100). This measure is considered both in absolute terms (for each avatar individually) and in relative terms (in comparison between avatars).
Secondary outcomes
The following questions identify the secondary outcomes for each respondent in each situation: 1. "If you were to use the postal service, what gender would you expect the postal worker to have?" and "Have you ever avoided using the postal service because you expected unfair treatment from the postal worker?" The answers will indicate if participants expect discrimination and if it affects the demand for the service. 2. We ask participants to reflect on how different measure could affect their willingness to use financial advice services.
Sponsors
Name: SAFE Experiment Center Location: Frankfurt, Germany Url: https://safe-frankfurt.de/research/experiment-center.html

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords