Workplace Charging Network Expansion

How to cite

Tebbe, Sebastian. 2024. "Workplace Charging Network Expansion." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014731. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14731-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Sebastian Tebbe*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014731
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14731-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-01-01 – 2025-04-01
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14731

Abstract

We provide estimates of the impact of a workplace EV network expansion on driver charging behavior by leveraging the staggered installation of new chargers at parking lots. Our analysis couples data on charging behavior around the networks’ expansion with a generalized difference-in-differences empirical strategy.

Intervention

The UCSD charging network is currently undergoing a substantial expansion, with increases in infrastructure projected between December 2023 and June 2024, and again from November 2025 to January 2026. According to the Transportation Office, the number of Level 2 chargers is expected to increase from approximately 331 Level-2 charging stations, including 250 ChargePoint and 72 PowerFlex stations, in December 2023 to around 480 by June 2024.We exclude eight Level-2 chargers operated by SemaConnect. Following this period of rapid growth, the network was anticipated to remain relatively stable until November 2025, when the expansion will accelerate sharply, reaching an estimated 1,250 chargers by January 2026. However the initial phase of expansion is currently behind schedule and there may be an additional expansion in Q4 of 2024. While the posted expansion plans available at [https://transportation.ucsd.edu/initiatives/drive-electric/projects.html] provide a general timeline (with projections from December 14, 2023, to February 23, 2024), they are not fully precise due to phased project deliveries and varying award timelines. Thus, our analysis relies on internally tracked charger expansion dates, which accurately reflect the exact dates when old chargers are decommissioned and replacements are brought online. This internal data allows us to align planned and actual operational dates and identify when chargers are taken out of service based on the termination of their reporting histories.

Experimental design

This paper takes advantage of a natural experiment—the staggered roll-out of EV chargers on the UCSD campus. We also provide e-mail notifications to EV drivers on campus that enumerate the number and location of newly installed chargers sent once per month.

Design details

Randomization method
As a natural experiment, we do not directly employ a randomization method. However, we show that the roll-out of new chargers followed requirements in grants that partially funded the chargers, as well as on engineering and technical feasibilities, rather than on the basis of demand for charging. We therefore apply a difference in difference (DiD) method common in natural experiments. The technical details of the method, its assumptions, and how we meet them are covered in the attached pre-analysis plan.
Randomization unit
We use two levels of randomization—by driver and by parking lot—based on pretreatment charging behavior. At the driver level, we analyze the subset of drivers who charge primarily at a single lot and a second sample that inlcudes the remaining drivers who spread their charging activity across multiple lots. (We observe every campus charging session initiated by drivers and thus know where and how they charge.) Based on charging data collected before the roll-out \parencite{garg_electric_2024}, 60% of our EV drivers charge at a single lot at least 90% of the time. Our first driver-level analysis is on these single-lot drivers. These drivers are counted as treated if and when their primary lot is treated, ; otherwise they are untreated. The behavioral responses of these single-lot drivers form a good analog for EV network expansion by smaller institutions with only a single parking lot. Our second treatment includes drivers who charge at multiple lots (i.e., the remaining 40% of drivers who charge less than 90% of the time at any single lot). We will utilize a continuous or dose-level version of treatment in which a driver's treatment dose is a function of the lots they charge in ttimes the number of new chargers received by that lot. For example, a driver who charges 50% of the time at two lots will be counted as gaining 5 new chargers if one of those lots gains 10. At the lot level treatment, we analyze changes in the average of our outcomes of interest for each lot. This method has the disadvantage of reduced power, but the advantages of a cleaner mapping of treatment, as well as enabling us to explore the spatial nature of spillovers from other nearby garages. The lot averages include information from drivers who We include more details about each analysis in our pre-analysis plan.
Clusters
Treatment will naturally be assigned at the lot level. There are approximately 40 lots on the UCSD campus, of which we have reliable data on 35 with have approximately 1060 drivers.
Observations
Our sample consists panel data of 1060 drivers, across 35 lots.
Arms
530 control/530 treatment
Primary outcomes
Net benefits of charger installation, and how drivers react to a supply side shift in chargers. This will be measured by 6 outcome variables for each driver, both the log and level. Session duration indicates the total time plugged in, irrespective of charging, and is the sum of charging duration (when the EV is plugged in and charging) and idle duration (when the EV is plugged in but not charging). 1. Share of total charging done on campus 2. The number of campus sessions initiated 3. Energy consumed 4. Session duration 5. Charging duration 6. Idle duration.
Secondary outcomes
Charger network congestion and Substitution effects

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords