Evaluating California’s Guaranteed Income Pilot Program

How to cite

Benatar, Sarah; Lery, Bridgette. 2024. "Evaluating California’s Guaranteed Income Pilot Program." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014714. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14714-2.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Sarah Benatar* , Bridgette Lery

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014714
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14714-2.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-11-14 – 2029-09-30
Countries
United States of America (California)
JEL codes
D14 (Household Saving, Personal Finance); G51 (Household Saving, Borrowing, Debt, and Wealth); I14 (Health and Inequality); H24 (Personal Income and Other Nonbusiness Taxes and Subsidies); I24 (Education and Inequality); I31 (General Welfare, Well-Being); I38 (Government Policy, Provision and Effects of Welfare Programs); I24 (Education and Inequality); J24 (Human Capital, Skills, Occupational Choice, Labor Productivity); P46 (Consumer Economics, Health, Education and Training, Welfare, Income, Wealth, and Poverty)
Secondary IDs
Agreement # 21-3125
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14714

Abstract

Background and target population
As part of the fiscal year 2021-22 budget agreed to by California’s Governor and the Legislature, the California Department of Social Services (CDSS) is providing support and oversight for five pilot programs conducting a randomized controlled trial of guaranteed income (GI). The intervention targets two unique low-income populations facing a key life transition that puts them at higher risk for adverse outcomes: youth aging out of extended foster care and pregnant people.

Eligibility criteria
The eligibility criteria for each target population is as follows:

Former foster youth (FFY)
- Low-income according to Insight Center’s Family Needs Calculator based on county of residence and household composition at time of application
- Exiting/exited foster care on their 21st birthday during the site’s enrollment period
- Can apply up to 90 days before and up to 30 days after their 21st birthday
- California resident at time of application
- Can be temporarily living out of state if attending post-secondary institution
- Foster care case is/was under the jurisdiction of a county in the site’s catchment area

Pregnant population
- Low-income (definition varied by site, with some sites using the Insight Center’s Family Needs Calculator, some using Medicaid enrollment, and some using 80% of AMI)
- Within the first 27 weeks of pregnancy at the time of application
- Resides in the site’s catchment area
- Some sites have additional criteria based on risk factors for perinatal complications (e.g., be at increased risk of developing gestational diabetes, have one or more risk factors for pre-term birth)

Application and enrollment
Each of the pilot sites follows their own specific outreach and referral process for potential program participants. People who wish to participate in the GI pilot program must complete an application online determine if they meet the pilot site’s eligibility criteria. Those who are eligible and interested then enroll in the study.

Intervention groups and randomization procedures
Enrolled participants are randomized to either receive GI or be part of a control group that receives $20 per month. For FFY, GI consists of unconditional cash payments of $750 per month for 18 months. For pregnant people, GI consists of unconditional cash payments of $600-$1,200 per month for 12-18 months (duration and amount of payment vary by site). GI recipients also receive benefits waivers for some benefits, ensuring that the income they receive from GI does not impact their current benefits. CDSS secured benefits waivers for CalWORKs and CalFresh for all GI participants, and some pilot sites secured additional waivers from county agencies. Voluntary benefits counseling and other support services are offered to enrolled participants.

For all but one site (see more detailed explanation below in the Randomization Method section), the study team at Urban Institute conducts the random assignment using applicants’ data collected in the online platform. Randomization is conducted separately by pilot site.

Sample size
We anticipate enrolling a total of 3,021 participants in the study. This includes 774 FFY (395 treatment, 379 control) and 2,247 pregnant people (1,156 treatment and 1,091 control).

Data collection
Enrolled participants are offered the opportunity to participate in surveys to study the impact of GI. Surveys will be conducted at baseline, 3 and 9 months after enrollment, upon program exit (either 12 months or 18 months post-baseline, depending on the pilot site), and 6 and 12 months after program exit. We are also obtaining administrative data from several sources to examine outcomes related to GI. These data include records such as Homeless Data Integration System (HDIS) data, CWS/CMS (California child welfare), National Student Clearinghouse and California Community College Chancellor’s Office (higher education outcomes), California Employment Development Department (employment outcomes), CalWORKs (TANF) and CalFresh (SNAP) (public assistance utilization), Medi-Cal (Medicaid) enrollment and claims (healthcare utilization and outcomes), and California Department of Justice (justice system outcomes). We will follow participants for 24 months after GI ends (or 3.5 years post-randomization) using administrative data.

Outcomes
The outcomes of interest for both populations include physical health, mental health, financial strain and well-being, housing security, food security, transportation security, employment, education, child welfare involvement for participants with children, and participation in other benefits. For the FFY population only, we will examine criminal justice involvement. For the pregnant population only, we will examine perinatal mental health, perinatal health conditions, and birth outcomes.

Intervention

This RCT focuses on two unique low-income populations facing a key life transition that puts them at higher risk for adverse outcomes: pregnant people and youth aging out of extended foster care. Participants in the GI treatment group will receive unconditional cash payments of $600-$1,200 per month for 12-18 months (duration and amount of payment vary by site). GI recipients also receive benefits waivers for some benefits, ensuring that the income they receive from GI does not impact their current benefits. Benefits counseling and other support services are offered to enrolled participants, but participation in these services is voluntary. All participants receive a link for a self-guided benefits assessment that helps the participant determine any additional benefits for which they may be eligible and any benefits that may be impacted by the receipt of GI. Some sites also follow up with in-person benefits counseling for those who express interest.

Low-income people, particularly those who are pregnant or leaving foster care, are at higher risk of experiencing a range of negative outcomes (e.g., housing instability, food insecurity, child maltreatment). Many experience financial instability, and existing benefits programs require a high administrative burden and do not adequately meet people’s needs – all of which lead to stress, material hardship, and difficulty accessing needed services. Therefore, providing low-income people with a guaranteed income and benefits waivers, should increase financial stability, reduce administrative burden, and ultimately reduce their risk of negative outcomes.

Experimental design

The GI evaluation employs experimental methods, i.e. a randomized controlled trial (RCT). The eligible population for GI includes youth aging out of extended foster care at age 21 during the study enrollment period and pregnant individuals who are within the first 27 weeks of pregnancy at the time of application. Each of the five pilot sites in the RCT identify, screen, and enroll participants. Eligible participants who choose to enroll are randomized to either the treatment group which receives unconditional cash payments of $600-$1,200 per month for 12-18 months (duration and amount of payment vary by site) or the control group which receives $20 per month. One site is not using control group payments. We anticipate enrolling a total of 3,021 participants in the study. This includes 774 FFY (395 treatment, 379 control) and 2,247 pregnant people (1,156 treatment and 1,091 control).

Design details

Randomization method
We use random assignment to determine which eligible applicants will receive GI. For all but one site, the randomization process is as follows: Enrollee data required to conduct randomization is transferred from the online application platform to the Urban Institute on a regular basis. Urban then conducts randomization using STATA. All randomization is stratified first by pilot grantee and then by target population (for pilots serving both the FFY and pregnant populations). Some sites are also stratified by county. Each batch is randomized until the point is reached that there are more applicants than remaining slots. Each site has specified its own treatment to control ratio based on funding and eligible universe. Urban then transfers randomization results back to pilot sites, and the pilot site staff contacts applicants to inform them of their group assignment. Once there are more applicants than remaining slots, excess applicants will be held on a waitlist. In the event a treatment group participant declines GI, two waitlist applicants will be randomly selected to treatment and control. For one of the pregnant population sites, Urban does not conduct the randomization, and the site runs the randomization process directly. Every two weeks, the site randomly selects 40% of new applicants from each county to be in the treatment group, and those that are no longer eligible are assigned to the control group. The individuals included in each randomization process include all newly eligible applicants as well as previous applicants that did not get selected for GI but are still eligible (<27 weeks gestation). This maintains a treatment: control group ratio of 1:1.5. Randomization is conducted using numbers randomly generated from a uniform distribution.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
We anticipate enrolling a total of 3,021 participants in the study (774 FFY and 2,247 pregnant people).
Observations
We anticipate enrolling a total of 3,021 participants in the study (774 FFY and 2,247 pregnant people).
Arms
We anticipate enrolling 774 FFY (395 treatment, 379 control) and 2,247 pregnant people (1,156 treatment and 1,091 control).
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes of interest for the FFY population are: • Healthcare utilization and access o Delay or avoid healthcare o Obtain routine healthcare • Mental health o Depression o Anxiety o Perceived stress • Financial strain and well-being o Financial stress o Financial well-being o Household income • Housing security o Episode(s) of homelessness o Worry about losing housing • Food insecurity • Employment o Employment status o Employment conditions • Education o School enrollment • Participation in benefits o Lose any benefits o Gain any benefits The primary outcomes of interest for the pregnant population are: • Healthcare utilization and access o Delay or avoid healthcare o Obtain prenatal healthcare • Mental health o Depression o Anxiety o Perceived stress • Financial strain and well-being o Financial stress o Financial well-being o Household income • Housing security o Episode(s) of homelessness o Worry about losing housing • Food insecurity • Child welfare involvement o Maltreatment referrals o Investigations o Substantiations o Case openings o Foster care entries • Employment o Employment conditions • Participation in benefits o Lose any benefits o Gain any benefits
Secondary outcomes
The secondary outcomes of interest for the FFY population are: • Health o Healthcare utilization and access: Medical debt, Hospitalizations, Chronic health conditions o Perceived health o Health-related quality of life o Physical activity o Sleep quality o Diet • Well-being o Well-being o Hope • Financial strain and well-being o Debt o Unexpected household shocks • Housing security o Satisfaction with living situation o Improve living situation • Transportation security • Child welfare involvement (for children of FFY) o Maltreatment referrals o Investigations o Substantiations o Case openings o Foster care entries • Employment o Satisfaction with employment • Education o Achieve educational goals • Criminal justice involvement o Arrests o Convictions o Incarcerations The secondary outcomes of interest for the pregnant population are: • Health o Healthcare utilization and access: Obtain routine healthcare, Medical debt, Hospitalizations o Perceived health o Chronic health conditions o Health-related quality of life o Physical activity o Sleep quality o Diet • Well-being o Well-being o Hope • Financial strain and well-being o Debt o Unexpected household shocks • Housing security o Satisfaction with living situation o Improve living situation • Transportation security • Employment o Employment status o Satisfaction with employment o Employment mobility • Education o School enrollment o Achieve educational goals • Perinatal health conditions o Gestational hypertension o Gestational diabetes • Birth outcomes o Pre-term birth o Birth weight o NICU admission o NICU length of stay
Sponsors
Name: The California Department of Social Services (CDSS) Location: Sacramento, California Url: https://www.cdss.ca.gov/ Name: The Constellation Fund Location: Minneapolis, Minnesota Url: https://constellationfund.org/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords