Hedging Criteria: An Experimental Study on Minimum Variance vs. Lower Partial Moment Approaches
How to cite
Lee, Siun; Feldman, Paul. 2025. "Hedging Criteria: An Experimental Study on Minimum Variance vs. Lower Partial Moment Approaches." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014675. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14675-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study investigates whether investors’ hedging behaviors align more closely with the traditional minimum variance (MV) approach or the second-order lower partial moment ($LPM_2$) criterion. Using a scenario-based design that differentiates MV and $LPM_2$ hedge ratios, participants allocated assets between two correlated lotteries representing spot and futures prices. The results reveal a divergence in hedge ratios, with some participants favoring $LPM_2$ due to its focus on downside risk rather than treating upside and downside risk equally, as MV does. This suggests that MV may underestimate risk aversion in scenarios involving asymmetric risk profiles. Notably, $LPM_2$ hedge ratios likely align more closely with participant decisions, particularly in situations where managing downside risk is prioritized over variance minimization. These findings bridge the gap between normative hedging theories and observed behaviors, offering insights for refining risk models and enhancing portfolio management strategies.
Experimental design
Participants decide asset allocation between two correlated lotteries with 45 rounds. This design aims to compare the predictive power of two theoretical models: the minimum variance (MV) approach and the Lower Partial Moment (LPM_2) approach.
The experiment consists of two lotteries, L1 and L2, each with two possible outcomes. These lotteries are designed to reflect the relationship between spot and futures prices in financial markets. The outcomes represent the changes in spot and futures prices.
A key feature of this design is the perfect negative correlation (-1) between the two lotteries. This means with probability p, L1 yields a positive outcome while L2 yields a negative outcome. By the same token, with probability (1-p), L1 yields a negative outcome while L2 yields a positive outcome. This correlation structure is crucial because it accurately reflects the high correlation typically observed between spot and futures prices in financial markets. Also, it ensures a positive hedge ratio, which is consistent with real-world hedging strategies.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.