Keeping Girls on the STEM Track: an Exploration of Role Model Effect and its Mechanisms

How to cite

Ramirez-Espinoza, Fernanda. 2024. "Keeping Girls on the STEM Track: an Exploration of Role Model Effect and its Mechanisms." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014662. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14662-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Fernanda Ramirez-Espinoza*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014662
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14662-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2024-05-01 – 2024-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
I21, J16
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14662

Abstract

This experiment evaluates the effects of two complementary interventions designed to provide role models to low-SES students. These interventions focus on students enrolled in 10th grade in Chile. The sample consists of 320 schools. To evaluate the interventions, high schools were randomly assigned (at the school level) into two groups: a pure control group and a web-based role model curriculum treatment group. Top-math female students of the web-based treatment schools were randomly assigned to a personal role-model treatment. This originates three arms of the main experiment: a pure control group, a group of students who are exposed to role models only through a web-based curriculum, and a group of students who are exposed to role models through the web-based curriculum and through personal interaction.

To study the underlying mechanisms of the role model effect, I randomized the gender of role models in the web-based curriculums to test if there is any heterogeneity of the treatment effect due to gender match between the role model and the student. The intervention design includes features that allow us to study the effect of female and male role models in girls and boys. With this feature of the experiment, I aim to understand to what extent having a male or female role model differentially affects boys and girls. This pre-analysis plan provides some background information on the intervention, outlines the study design, and describes the inference and estimation procedures.

Intervention

The two randomizations originate three groups of students:
- Pure Control Group
- Only Role Model Videos
- Role Model Videos + Personal Interaction with Role Models

Control group: Students in the control group will not receive any interventions. However, like the rest of the students in the project, they will answer a baseline and an endline survey.
Only role model videos: Students in the only role model videos groups receive several videos of role models through a digital curriculum. Each student logs into a platform with their username and password, and is presented with the materials in sequence. The digital curriculum consists of 5 sessions where students are exposed to videos with role models that guide students through the process of choosing electives.
Personal Interaction with Role Models: in addition to receiving role model videlos The personal interaction component consists of four synchronous online sessions held after school. In each session, a STEM college student will guide a conversation with a group of five female students, randomly selected from the top-5 math-performing female students of the schools that received the role model curriculum.

Experimental design

To evaluate the interventions, high schools were randomly assigned (at the school level) into two groups: a pure control group and a web-based role model curriculum treatment group. Top-math female students of the web-based treatment schools were randomly assigned to a personal role-model treatment. This originates three arms of the main experiment: a pure control group, a group of students who are exposed to role models only through a web-based curriculum, and a group of students who are exposed to role models through the web-based curriculum and through personal interaction.

To study the underlying mechanisms of the role model effect, I randomized the gender of role models in the web-based curriculums to test if there is any heterogeneity of the treatment effect due to gender match between the role model and the student.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in the office by a computer
Randomization unit
The role model video provision was clustered at the school level, and personal interaction with role model was randomized at the individual level.
Clusters
The randomization at the school level was done within 320 schools. At the individual level, it was done within 1.055 students.
Observations
25,600 students
Arms
109 school control schools, 211 schools in the role model video treatment, 528 students in the video + personal interaction
Primary outcomes
- Interest in math and science themes - Choice of electives in 11th and 12th grade - Aspiration to study in higher education - Interest in STEM majors - Post- secondary education trajectories: - Enrolls in higher education. - Enrolls in STEM higher education. - Enrolls in STEM higher education at a top university.
Secondary outcomes
Longer-Term Outcomes - Post-secondary education trajectories: -- Applies to higher education -- Registers to take the university admission exam. -- Takes the university admission exam. -- Characteristics of the institutions and programs in which they enroll: peers' quality, graduation rates, over-duration, accreditation, expected earnings, expected employability. - Higher Education Aspirations -- Desire to continue studying after high school graduation. -- Self-efficacy beliefs -- Characteristics of the institutions and programs in which they wish to enroll: peers' quality, graduation rates, over-duration, accreditation, expected earnings, and expected employability.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords