Understanding Occupational Mobility

How to cite

Miano, Armando; Heß, Pascal. 2024. "Understanding Occupational Mobility." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014651. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14651-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Armando Miano* , Pascal Heß

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014651
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14651-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-11-04 – 2025-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14651

Abstract

Job mobility is a crucial driver of labor market dynamism and an important factor shaping workers’ personal development and earnings growth. Occupational mobility specifically has gained increased relevance in this time of profound transformations in the labor market. Certain occupations are particularly affected by technological change (automation, AI) and the green transition and, thus, are at risk of becoming obsolete.

The goal of this project is to improve our understanding of how employed workers decide about occupational mobility, focusing especially on workers’ beliefs about the transferability of their skills, the costs of switching to a different occupation and finding a new job, and their perceptions of the opportunities they may have in other occupations – the benefits of switching to another occupation. We design a new survey and we plan to administer this survey to a sample of 5,000 employees between 20 and 50 years old in Germany. The new survey will capture detailed information on workers’ beliefs about the benefits and costs of transitioning to other occupations, as well as their willingness to switch occupations. It also features an experimental part where randomly selected groups of respondents receive different pieces of information related to other occupations that are closest to theirs in terms of task similarity, and (if applicable) information about how much their current occupation is exposed to automation or the green transition. These survey data will allow us to i) map respondents’ beliefs about occupational mobility and study how they are related to their mobility intentions; ii) study whether information is able to shift workers’ perceptions of other occupations and influence their career decisions. Furthermore, by linking survey data with administrative data on pre- and post-survey employment histories, we will assess whether workers’ perceptions are accurate and investigate how workers’ past experiences shape their beliefs and how (possibly distorted) perceptions affect workers’ employment choices and career trajectories.

Intervention

We design a new online survey and administer it to a large sample of 5,000 German employees (age 20 to 50), oversampling workers in occupations that are more at risk of being displaced by structural changes in the labor market – automation, green transition. The survey elicits workers’ beliefs about the transferability of their skills, the costs of moving to a different occupation – search costs, skills requirements, need and costs of re-training, need and cost of acquiring a license – and their perceptions of the occupations that are “adjacent” to theirs, probabilities of moving across occupations – and the benefits of making a career change – median wages in other occupations and starting wages if they were to move to different occupations. There are also additional questions aimed at understanding the main factors workers weigh in their decision to change occupations. The survey will have a panel structure. The first wave is going to be administered in November-December 2024 and a second wave is planned six months after. The main survey features multiple information experiments where random subsamples of respondents receive information on the transferability of their skills to other occupations paired with information on the costs or benefits of occupational mobility, and/or information on exposure to technological change or the green transition. For respondents who will provide their consent, we will be able to match survey records with administrative data on pre- and post-survey employment histories.

Experimental design

The main survey features multiple information experiments where random subsamples of respondents receive information on the transferability of their skills to other occupations paired with information on the costs or benefits of occupational mobility, and/or information on exposure to technological change or the green transition.
More specifically, we split respondents into two groups depending on their occupation: respondents in occupations at risk of being displaced by automation or by the green transition -- i.e., those who work in occupations performing a high share of automatable task or environmentally-damaging tasks -- and respondent in occupations not at risk. At-risk respondents are then split into 6 mutually exclusive groups: 1) Control; 2) Benefit treatment; 3) Cost treatment; 4) Displacement risk (from automation or green transition) treatment; 5) Displacement risk + Benefit treatments; 6) Displacement risk + Cost treamtents. Not-at-risk respondents are split into 3 mutually exclusive groups: 1) Control; 2) Benefit treatment; 3) Cost treatment.

All treated respondents receive personalized reccomendations on two occupations that are close to theirs in terms of task similarity. Then, depending on the groups they are randomized in, they receive attitional information on:
- Benefit treatment: some of the benefits of moving to the two aforementioned occupations -- median, 25th and 75th percentile of the wage distribution, and qualitative information on the number of vacancies available relative to jobseekers
- Cost treatment: sone of the costs of moving to the two aforementioned occupations -- likelihood of needing to re-train or acquire a licences
- Displacement risk treatment: respondents randomized in the Displacement risk treatment are informed that people in their occupation perform a high share of automatable tasks or environmentally-damaging tasks and are provided with similar information on the two aforementioned alternative occupations.
- Benefits + displacement risk treatment: information on displacement risk (as in the previous point) plus information on the benefits as above
- Costs + displacement risk treatment: information on displacement risk (as in the previous point) plus information on the costs as above.

Participants in the control group do not receive any piece of information and move directly to the next block of the survey.

If respondents are in an occupations for which there are no close alternative occupations, they do not receive any treatment.

Design details

Randomization method
As they take the survey, depending on their self-declared occupations, respondents are first classified into two groups: respondents in occupations at risk of being displaced by automation or by the green transition -- i.e., those who work in occupations performing a high share of automatable task or environmentally-damaging tasks -- and respondent in occupations not at risk. At-risk respondents are then split into 6 mutually exclusive groups: 1) Control; 2) Benefit treatment; 3) Cost treatment; 4) Displacement risk (from automation or green transition) treatment; 5) Displacement risk + Benefit treatments; 6) Displacement risk + Cost treatment. Not-at-risk respondents are split into 3 mutually exclusive groups: 1) Control; 2) Benefit treatment; 3) Cost treatment.
Randomization unit
Individual respondent.
Clusters
1 country (Germany)
Observations
5,000 employees (wage and salary workers) who are working full-time at the time they take the survey.
Arms
Within group (at-risk vs. not-at-risk), respondents are evenly assigned to the groups outlined above Not-at-risk respondents: we expect to have about 700 respondents per treatment group (or in the control group). At-risk respondents: we expect to have about 350 respondents per treatment group (or in the control group).
Primary outcomes
Beliefs about: skills transferability, close occupations in terms of skills similarity, common transitions between occupations, median wages and job availability in other occupations, own starting wage in other occupations, likelihood of needing re-training and licenses to access other occupations and effort to acquire these licenses/training, search costs to find a job in other occupations (applications, success rate, time costs, mental costs), probability of receiving an offer for a job in own or another occupation (arrival rate of offers), share of automatable and environmentally harmful tasks in own occupation, probability that automation or green transition will affect own earnings or employment. Labor market intentions: likelihood to fook for a new job in own current occupation, likelihood to look for a new job in another occupation, likelihood to look for a new job in specific other occupations, likelihood to ask current employer for a raise.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords