Gender Gaps in Depression Diagnosis

How to cite

Franco, Catalina; Abrahamsson, Sara; Moorthy, Akshay. 2024. "Gender Gaps in Depression Diagnosis." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014621. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14621-1.7

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Catalina Franco* , Sara Abrahamsson , Akshay Moorthy

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014621
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14621-1.7
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2024-10-22 – 2025-10-31
Countries
United States of America ()
JEL codes
I12, I14, I18, J16, C91
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14621

Abstract

Worldwide, depression is more prevalent among women than men, but it is unclear whether this reflects differences in underlying mental health or diagnosis. This project seeks to understand behavioral drivers of the observed gender disparities in depression. We hypothesize that the gender gap partly arises from: (i) differences in the threshold at which potential patients interpret a set of symptoms as depression, and (ii) differences in how specialists diagnose and recommend further steps for male and female patients presenting similar symptoms. To isolate differences in reporting and diagnosing from differences in underlying symptoms, we design online experiments where participants evaluate hypothetical depression scenarios in which the severity and symptoms of depression are randomly assigned. Each scenario is defined by a randomly selected PHQ score and a corresponding set of symptoms and frequencies randomly drawn to match that score. Workers in online platforms evaluate hypothetical scenarios about themselves or about another hypothetical individual. Mental health specialists recruited through the American Psychological Association (APA) evaluate scenarios about hypothetical male and female patients.

Intervention

The study uses a within-subjects design wherein all participants are exposed to two treatment blocks. In each of these blocks, participants will be shown one or more hypothetical scenarios. A scenario involves a list of depression symptoms and the frequency of their occurrence. The study uses a within-subjects design wherein all participants are exposed to two treatment blocks. In each of these blocks, participants will be shown one or more hypothetical scenarios. A scenario consists of a list of depression symptoms and the frequency of their occurrence over the past two weeks. The displayed symptoms are chosen from the PHQ-9 questionnaire, which is a widely used (and often self-administered) instrument that screens for depressive disorders. The list of symptoms and frequencies are randomly chosen to meet certain thresholds which indicate different levels of depression severity.

After reviewing the hypothetical scenario, participants are asked to state their views on: (i) whether the symptoms indicate that the subject of the scenario suffers from depression (recognition), (ii) perceptions of depression severity, (iii) the likelihood of seeking help from different sources, and (iv) beliefs and attitudes regarding depression and mental health.

[NEW August 2026] A similar experiment will be conducted with mental health specialists recruited from the members of the American Psychological Association to establish whether there are differences in how specialists diagnose and recommend further steps for male and female patients presenting similar symptoms.

Experimental design

The experiment involves randomly choosing a list of depression symptoms and severity of symptoms from the PhQ-9 questionnaire to build a scenario that participants are prompted to assess. The two treatment blocks refer to who is the subject of the scenario (Self or Other). we choose symptoms (i.e., items form the PHQ-9 scale) and frequencies so that the combinations of symptoms and frequencies gives an overall score between 4 and 21.

[NEW August 2026] For the APA sample, we use the PHQ-8 questionnaire (eliminate the suicidal ideation question from the PHQ-9 list).

Design details

Randomization method
All participants see scenarios in both Self and Other in randomized order. The list of symptoms and frequencies is randomly selected based on a pre-defined algorithm. [NEW October 2026] For the APA sample, we use the PHQ-8 questionnaire (eliminate the suicidal ideation question from the PHQ-9 list). We randomize the gender of the subject of the subject of the scenario, which is our main focus. We also randomize the attributes we mention about the subject like age and occupations, keeping these attributes as close as possible.
Randomization unit
Individual - within subject.
Clusters
Non-clustered design.
Observations
300 individuals who evaluate 4 scenarios.
Arms
1200 observations from 300 individuals who evaluate 4 scenarios each. [NEW August 2026] For the APA sample, we aim to recruit at least 100 respondents. Recruitment will occur through relevant professional psychology listservs and networks. In addition, we plan to supplement the APA sample with Prolific participants who report they are currently working in the following occupations: Clinical psychologist, Counselor - mental health, Psychiatrist, Psychologist. We aim to recruit 300 responses from this sample.
Primary outcomes
The three primary outcomes are Recognize, Correct and Seek help. Recognize is a binary variable equal to 1 if the answer to Q1 is definitely yes or probably yes, and 0 otherwise. Correct is the outcome to assess whether participants assess the severity of depression correctly. It takes the value of 1 if the severity level is identified correctly and 0 otherwise. Seek help captures the willingness to seek help after seeing the list of symptoms and answering Q1 and Q2. We will use the responses to Q3 to generate an outcome variable which equals 1 if the response is somewhat likely or very likely for one or more of the options presented in Q3 and 0 otherwise. [NEW August 2026] For the APA sample, we have three main outcomes: (1) Depression labeling: an indicator equal to 1 if the respondent answers "Definitely yes" or "Probably yes" when asked whether the hypothetical patient would have depression, and 0 otherwise. (2) Accurate severity assessment: an indicator equal to 1 if the respondent correctly identifies the PHQ-8 severity category of the hypothetical scenario, and 0 otherwise. (3) Recommendation for professional assessment: an indicator equal to 1 if the respondent is "Somewhat likely" or "Very likely" to recommend that the hypothetical patient seek a professional evaluation for depression, and 0 otherwise.
Secondary outcomes
The first set of secondary outcomes contained whether help would be sought from a mental health specialist or from non-specialists. The specialist variable will be equal to 1 if the response is somewhat likely or very likely in at least one of options 1-3 in Q3 and 0 otherwise. The non-specialist variable will be equal to 1 if the response is somewhat likely or very likely in at least one of options 4-6 in Q3 and 0 otherwise. The second set of secondary outcomes we intend to capture three different factors that could underlie gender differences in recognizing depression and seeking help. We refer to these three factors as perceptions, psychic costs and norms. To capture gender differences in perceptions we will generate binary outcomes from each of the answer options in Q4. Each of these variables would be equal to one if the response is somewhat or strongly agree and 0 otherwise. We will also generate an index summarizing the perceptions in a single variable. To study psychic costs, we will use the Self and Other scenarios and create a binary variable equal to 1 if the scenario being evaluated corresponds to Other. To study norms, we will survey responses to Q5. [NEW August 2026] For the APA sample, secondary outcomes capture recommendations to seek help from different sources and respondents' perceptions of whether professional evaluation or help is warranted.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords