Leader Selection and Performance in Public Sector Organizations: Experimental Evidence from Ghana

How to cite

Bancalari, Antonella; Augsburg, Britta; Loh, Julia. 2024. "Leader Selection and Performance in Public Sector Organizations: Experimental Evidence from Ghana." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014594. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14594-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Antonella Bancalari* , Britta Augsburg , Julia Loh

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014594
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14594-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2024-09-09 – 2025-12-31
Countries
Ghana (Greater Accra, Central and Western regions)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14594

Abstract

Effective leadership stands out as a key driver of organizational performance, but we know little about how to select the best leaders. We use a randomized controlled trial (RCT) to explore this question in a real-world, high-stakes public sector context. This project investigates how to select ‘Champions’ among midwives to lead the implementation of a new obstetric triage programme (OTIP). Given that the current management-led selection might miss opportunities to leverage peer networks, which is crucial for OTIP, we study if a bottom-up selection approach, based on peers selecting champions, could be more effective to improve performance of frontline workers than a top-down approach. We use primary data from patients on service quality as key performance measures. To understand mechanisms, we survey midwives, using elicitation methods and cutting-edge lab-on-the-field experiments, and gather comprehensive peer network data.

Intervention

In collaboration with Ghana Health Services (GHS)—Ministry of Health (MoH) and Kybele NGO, this project investigates how to select leaders among midwives to lead the implementation of a new protocol called obstetric triage package (OTIP). OTIP consists of a one-week training on clinical knowledge to accurately assess and prioritise the care of pregnant women with the goal of quickly identifying the severity of a patient’s condition, determine the appropriate level of care, and ensure that those with the most critical needs receive immediate attention. OTIP aims to tackle the inefficient practice of seeing obstetric patients on a 'first-come, first-served' basis, which puts patients at risk.

A key innovation of OTIP is the designation of up to ten midwives per hospital as 'Champions'—those selected to attend training, train their peers, as well as monitor and motivate the adoption of the protocol among colleagues.

Although OTIP was designed with a collaborative leadership approach in mind, the current method of selecting Champions remains a top-down process led by managers, reflecting a hierarchical model and potentially missing the advantages of tapping into peer networks. To address this, we introduced a bottom-up selection process, which fosters shared responsibility, teamwork, and collective decision-making, as commonly used in community-based service delivery.

The selection criteria are the same for the two treatment arms, asking to identify midwives with demonstrated ability to be a good leader, work well in teams, flexibility and ability to handle stressful situations, good communication skills, understanding of compassionate care, and ability to take initiative in difficult situations. In the `bottom-up’ treatment arm, we ask midwives in each hospital to nominate leaders through an online platform. The top nominees are then selected as OTIP champions in each bottom-up hospital.

Experimental design

This study is embedded within our ongoing impact evaluation of the OTIP Champions Programme. The impact evaluation randomizes the roll-out of the programme across 25 hospitals located in the Greater Accra, Central and Western regions, corresponding to the final phase of the national scale-up among all high-volume hospitals (above 1,200 annual deliveries in 2022). Hospitals are randomly assigned to either the early-treatment arm, where OTIP is implemented in September 2024, or the later-treatment arm, where OTIP is scheduled for introduction in January 2025.

We cross-randomize across both early- and later-treated hospitals whether leader selection remains the status quo, e.g. appointed by hospital management (top-down in 13 hospitals), or whether midwives select the ‘Champions’ among their peers (bottom-up in 12 hospitals).

Design details

Randomization method
The statistical software Stata, and specifically the random number generator setting a seed, were used to generate the randomization.
Randomization unit
Hospitals
Clusters
25 hospitals
Observations
- Hospitals: 25 hospitals, same as cluster size. - Midwives: panel data for roughly 30 midwives per hospital (randomly selected midwives plus all champions), totalling 750 midwives per hospital. - Patients: cross-section of 50 mother-newborn pairs per hospital, on average, in each round, totalling 1,250 mother-newborn pairs per round and 3,750 across 3 data collection rounds.
Arms
1. Top-down: 13 hospitals, roughly 390 midwives and 650 mother-newborn pairs per round. 2. Bottom-up: 12 hospitals, roughly 360 midwives and 600 mother-newborn pairs per round.
Primary outcomes
1. Service quality 2. Knowledge 3. Collaboration
Secondary outcomes
4. Leadership effectiveness 5. Social preferences 6. Attitudes

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords