Promoting entrepreneurship among migrants and host populations in Colombia
How to cite
Valdivia, Martin; Crosta, Tommaso; Karlan, Dean. 2025. "Promoting entrepreneurship among migrants and host populations in Colombia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014572. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14572-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The purpose of this study is to examine whether entrepreneurship training enhances the sustainability and growth of businesses run by migrants in Colombia. We will collaborate with the Ministry of Commerce and USAID's Oportunidades sin Fronteras for the implementation of a randomized controlled trial to study the effects of business and soft-skills training on business outcomes as well as psychometric and household-level outcomes. Additionally, through pre-treatment expectations we will explore how interventions can be better targeted to potential high-growth entrepreneurs. By comparing traditional business training with a combined technical and soft skills approach, the study aims to determine the additional value of soft skills in fostering business success and improving the effectiveness of such programs. The findings will contribute to better targeting and cost-effectiveness of entrepreneurship support initiatives for migrants and other vulnerable populations.
Intervention
We will collaborate with two key organizations in Colombia: The Ministry of Commerce, Industry, and Tourism (through iNNpulsa and Colombia Productiva) and USAID Opportunities without Borders Program (OSF-USAID). These programs include skills training, asset transfers, seed funding, and market access activities. Skills training covers technical and soft skills, though the latter is often informal and not evidence based. Seed funding provides essential business resources based on initial assessments, while market access is facilitated through business fairs and one-on-one connections. The theory of change for these interventions is to provide entrepreneurs with skills to enhance their business models, seed funding to launch and sustain their activities, and market connections to expand their client base. The programs aim to improve income generation.
We consider two treatment arms and a control group. One treatment arm (T1) implies offering a state of the art business training program that can transmit key business practices associated with successful enterprises. The second treatment arm (T2) will combine the transmission of the same business practices as in T1 with the transmission of key soft skills through the open access soft skills curriculum developed by IPA and iNNpulsa. Both treatment arms will include a transfer of assets, tailored for the specific entrepreneur's needs.
Regarding timing, we will organize the three modules (hard skills, soft skills, placebo) homogeneously throughout the training program, so that at any effective exposure, T2 beneficiaries will differentiate from T1 beneficiaries in that the former will include some training on soft skills.
Experimental design
Treatment assignment will be stratified based on the implementer, Ministry (iNNpulsa and Colombia Productiva) and OSF-USAID, cities, population origins (Venezuelan migrants and local population), and individual and business characteristics and individually randomized, with an equal proportion of participants being assigned to each group (Control, T1, and T2). The total sample size will be of around least 1,587 entrepreneurs: 529 in T1, 529 in T2, and 529 in the control group in four cities.
Comparing the treatment group T1 with the control group allows us to evaluate the impact of a traditional business training program and asset transfer over the success of the businesses run by the treated, plus some other key individual and household income indicators. Comparing T2 with the control group allows us to estimate the impact of the full treatment (hard + soft skills + asset transfer). The comparison of T1 and T2 allows us to establish the marginal contribution of the soft skills module. We will conduct follow-up surveys 3 months and one year after the end of the intervention.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.