Extinguishing the Blaze: Impact of Crop Residue Management on Stubble Burning in India

How to cite

Gandhi, Piyush. 2024. "Extinguishing the Blaze: Impact of Crop Residue Management on Stubble Burning in India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014559. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14559-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Piyush Gandhi*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014559
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14559-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2024-03-01 – 2025-03-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14559

Abstract

Crop residue burning is a major concern in developing countries, especially in India, where it exposes millions of people to extremely high levels of air pollution. Time constraints between harvesting rice and sowing wheat combined with lack of technical knowledge around relatively new methods of crop residue management encourages burning. Using a randomised controlled trial, this project will evaluate a program of subsidising early maturity rice seeds (which allow farmers more time to manage residues) along with technical training on methods of managing residues to rice farmers in Punjab, India. I evaluate the overall impact of these interventions on crop residue burning and agricultural production.

Intervention

This study investigates the effects of two interventions- a subsidised access to Early Maturity Variety (EMV) seeds and technical training about sustainable CRM methods. Specifically, I am interested in the effects of the EMV seeds on its own and the effects of EMV seeds with technical training. I randomly assign the farmers to one of the three groups: a seed-subsidy-only group, a seed-subsidy-plus-training group and a control group.

1. Seed Subsidy: Relatively new early maturity seed varieties developed by Punjab Agricultural University could mitigate time constraints between rice harvest and wheat sowing. For example, Punjab Agricultural University has developed short duration non-Basmati rice varieties like PR 121, PR 124 and PR 126 which mature in 110, 105 and 93 days after transplanting, respectively, as compared to the usual Pusa 44 varieties which take about 130 days after transplanting. Even though the yields of early maturity varieties are marginally lower than that of Pusa 44, Punjab Agricultural University estimated that the net income from shorter-duration varieties is slightly higher due to lower labor, fertilizer, and pesticide requirements. This reduces the pressure on farmers to burn and promotes sustainable CRM, while still leaving farmers no worse-off than before.
Farmers were offered 50% subsidy on the purchase of EMV seeds, covering their land holding size or 10 acres, whichever is lower. The offers were extended to farmers a month before they made their purchasing decisions (April-May 2024). The subsidies will be transferred upon providing a receipt of seeds purchased and a physical verification to distinguish the dwarf early maturity crop against taller alternate varieties.

2. Technical Training: Farmers in the ‘subsidy and technical training’ group will additionally receive technical training in sustainable methods of residue management before and after the harvest season (September-November). This involves providing them the information about costs of each alternate, time taken to manage crop residue, sources of inputs and remedies for pests/weeds, etc that they may face post harvest.

Experimental design

The study is designed as an RCT, with the farmers randomised into one of the three groups- ‘seed-subsidy-only’ group, ‘seed-subsidy-plus-training’ group and a control group.

1. Seed-subsidy-only group: Farmers in the ‘seed-subsidy-only’ group were be offered 50% subsidy (in April-May 2024) on purchase of early maturity variety of seeds, covering their land holding size or 10 acres, whichever is lower.

2.Seed-subsidy-plus-training group: Farmers in the `seed-subsidy-plus-training’ group were also offered 50% subsidy (in April-may 2024) on purchase of early maturity variety of seeds. In addition to the subsidy, they will also receive technical training in sustainable methods of crop residue management before and after the harvest season (September-November 2024).

Design details

Randomization method
Random assignment to treatment/comparison groups was generated by statistical software (STATA).
Randomization unit
Farmer
Clusters
1000 farmers
Observations
1000 farmers
Arms
400 farmers control 300 farmers subsidised seeds group 300 farmers subsidised seeds and training group
Primary outcomes
Crop residue burning

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords