Factors Shaping Macroeconomic Expectations: Follow-Up
How to cite
Schröder, Simon G.; Bordalo, Pedro; Gennaioli, Nicola; Lopez-de-Silanes, Florencio; Shleifer, Andrei; Rooij, Maarten van. 2024. "Factors Shaping Macroeconomic Expectations: Follow-Up." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014544. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14544-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This project aims to understand how people form beliefs about the macroeconomy, particularly developments in inflation and house prices. We propose that memories of past experiences, both relevant and potentially irrelevant, shape these beliefs. Suppose an individual is forecasting whether the inflation rate over the next twelve months will be high (i.e., above a certain threshold). We argue that the individual will rely, in part, on past experiences that have some similarity to the hypothesis they are trying to imagine (elevated levels of inflation). Our theory proposes that individuals who have personal experience with very similar things – for instance, financial struggles – will have an easier time imagining a future with higher levels of inflation, boosting their estimates of the likelihood of it occurring. We will run a controlled experiment that investigates these memory mechanisms, exploring how exogenously varying which past (similar but objectively irrelevant) experiences “come to mind” impacts beliefs about the likelihood of future macroeconomic events. We are also interested in whether elicited similarity ranks are stable over time, both at the individual and aggregate levels. Moreover, we want to analyze whether priming the same experience in this second survey complements (reinforces) or substitutes (weakens) the original intervention on beliefs. This will shed light on the relative strength of different memory forces. We will also examine recall errors by comparing recollections of primed experiences in the second survey with their corresponding recollections from the first survey.
Experimental design
Participants are recruited through Centerdata. They will be asked to complete a 15 minute survey.
Participants were previously randomly assigned to one of three treatments:
- Health prime
- Financial struggles prime
- Control
In this follow-up survey, participants are part of the same treatment group as in the initial survey.
For individuals in the health prime group, participants will be reminded whether they previously reported a personal experience with a serious or chronic illness, or the consequences of a serious accident in the first survey. If they did, they will be prompted to recall and reflect on that experience, with the option to add to their previous responses. If they had not reported such an experience, they will be asked if they have since experienced any serious illness or accident consequences. They will then write a few sentences summarizing their reflections.
For individuals in the financial struggles prime, the process will be the same. Participants will be reminded of their previous response regarding financial difficulties. If they had reported such an experience, they will reflect on it and have the option to add to their previous answers. If they had not experienced financial struggles, they will be asked if any new financial difficulties have arisen. They will then write a few sentences reflecting on their experience.
Individuals in the control treatment do not see an experience prompt of this form.
After this part of the survey, we ask participants about their inflation forecast over the next twelve months. We then also ask them how likely they deem a scenario in which inflation is high.
Subsequently, we ask respondents about their forecasts on changes in house prices over the next twelve months. We then also ask them how likely they deem a scenario in which there is a significant increase in house prices.
Then, we ask all participants about whether they have had each of a series of life experiences (just yes/no), including the two possible primed experiences, and how similar they feel these experiences are to a scenario with high inflation and large increases in house prices, respectively.
Finally, we will ask participants if they have had any other significant experiences that have profoundly impacted their lives since they last took this survey.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.