Choice Versus State Satisfaction

How to cite

Ifcher, John; Zarghamee, Homa. 2024. "Choice Versus State Satisfaction." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014520. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14520-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

John Ifcher* , Homa Zarghamee

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014520
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14520-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-10-28 – 2024-11-01
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C91, D31, I31
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14520

Abstract

In this study we contribute to the growing economic literature on the extent to which subjective well-being aligns with observed
choices in the context of a straightforward social preference experiment. This is important as prior research has shown that while
choice and predicted subjective well-being often align, individuals do not exclusively maximize subjective well-being. Further, it has
been shown that reported subjective well-being can be influenced by question order as well as other factors.

We test whether these results hold in a straightforward experimental setting. Moreover, we test a novel question: whether observed
choice is influenced by stated satisfaction. To do so, we develop an online experiment building on Diaz et al. (2023) and examine
whether stated satisfaction aligns with observed choice, and vice versa.

Specifically, participants encounter various payment-profiles; in each profile, the participant’s payment is held constant while the
payment of an anonymous, randomly-assigned other experimental participant varies. There are two main tasks. In one, participants
choose their preferred payment-profile; in the other, participants state their satisfaction with each payment-profile. To test for order
effects, we vary the order in which participants complete the two main tasks.

Reference
Diaz, L., Houser, D., Ifcher, J., & Zarghamee, H. (2023). Estimating social preferences using stated satisfaction: Novel support for
inequity aversion. European Economic Review, 155, 104436. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.euroecorev.2023.104436

Intervention

The experimental protocol will be as follows:

1. Informed consent

2. General instructions

3. Complete two tasks

** Task 1: Stated Satisfaction with of each of nine payment profiles
** Task 2: Choice of preferred (of nine) payment profiles

***** NOTE 1: The nine payment profiles are a list of different allocations of money between the participant and and another person
participating in this study with whom they have have been randomly paired.

***** NOTE 2: The order in which subjects complete Task 1 and Task 2 is randomized by participant

***** NOTE 3: Whether participants complete Task 1 and Task 2 as the participant stating their satisfaction and choosing their
preferred payment profile or the other person is randomized by participant.

***** NOTE 4: Thus, this is a 2X2 design with two randomizations.

4. Complete questionnaire

5. Payment within 3 days via online platform for one randomly selected Task

***** NOTE 5: Participants receive detailed instructions regarding each task prior to starting each task including the payment for the
task.

***** NOTE 6: Participant payments will include: a $2 payment for completing the study and payment for one of the two tasks they
complete. The payment task will be determined randomly by the computer.
***** NOTE 7: A PDF of the complete Qualtrics survey is attached to this application.

Experimental design

The experimental protocol will be as follows:

1. Informed consent

2. General instructions

3. Complete two tasks

** Task 1: Stated Satisfaction with of each of nine payment profiles
** Task 2: Choice of preferred (of nine) payment profiles

***** NOTE 1: The nine payment profiles are a list of different allocations of money between the participant and and another person
participating in this study with whom they have have been randomly paired.

***** NOTE 2: The order in which subjects complete Task 1 and Task 2 is randomized by participant

***** NOTE 3: Whether participants complete Task 1 and Task 2 as the participant stating their satisfaction and choosing their
preferred payment profile or the other person is randomized by participant.

***** NOTE 4: Thus, this is a 2X2 design with two randomizations.

4. Complete questionnaire

5. Payment within 3 days via online platform for one randomly selected Task

***** NOTE 5: Participants receive detailed instructions regarding each task prior to starting each task including the payment for the
task.

***** NOTE 6: Participant payments will include: a $2 payment for completing the study and payment for one of the two tasks they
complete. The payment task will be determined randomly by the computer.
***** NOTE 7: A PDF of the complete Qualtrics survey is attached to this application.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization will be completed as part of the Qualtrics survey. This is a 2X2 design. Qualtrics will allocate the participants randomly between the 4 treatments (conditions).
Randomization unit
Randomization will be done at the participant level
Clusters
800 participants; 200 in each of four treatments (conditions)
Observations
800 participants; 200 in each of four treatments (conditions)
Arms
The is only one treatment arm
Primary outcomes
1. Stated Satisfaction with of each of nine payment profiles 2. Choice of preferred (of nine) payment profiles 3. Amount that participants donate to charity from their bonus payment ***** NOTE: The nine payment profiles are a list of different allocations of money between the participant and and another person participating in this study with whom they have have been randomly paired.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords