Entrepreneurial strategies and domains: evidence from a simulation-based lab experiment
How to cite
Frosi, Claudia; Chondrakis, George; Gagliardi, Luisa; Mariani, Myriam. 2024. "Entrepreneurial strategies and domains: evidence from a simulation-based lab experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014513. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14513-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Entrepreneurs are often depicted as boundedly rational and myopic decision-makers who rely on local search and readily available data (Moore, Oesch, and Zietsma, 2007; Simon, 1957). When searching and attempting to define or assess market opportunities, entrepreneurs are guided by their pre-existing experiences. Their knowledge sets coming from individual experiences, backgrounds, values, and beliefs, or domains, define what is salient when framing strategic and entrepreneurial problems (Camuffo, Gambardella, and Pignataro, 2024).
While there is a growing body of literature arguing that theory framing is essential in strategic and entrepreneurial decision making (Felin and Zenger, 2017), little is known about the relationship between entrepreneurial domains, theory framing, and entrepreneurial idea (and solution) generation.
The goal of this project is to understand whether making entrepreneurs aware of the impact exerted by their domains on their entrepreneurial ideas triggers a change in experimentation and search, beyond initial domains.
Since exploration beyond what is known can expand the opportunity set at the expense of increased uncertainty and monetary and non-monetary (i.e., time, effort) costs, it is unclear whether exploration beyond initial domains can be beneficial or not. Given this trade-off, we argue that entrepreneurs who engage in “scientific entrepreneurship” (Zellweger and Zenger, 2023), adopting a theory-based experimentation approach, explore in a more structured way and are able to reduce the burden of expanded search (Camuffo, Cordova, Gambardella, and Spina, 2020).
To this aim, we investigate the impact that domain awareness (which shall trigger increased exploration) has in addition to scientific or theory-based experimentation (which shall reduce the cost of exploration). A companion study finds that domain awareness and theory-based experimentation have a complementary effect on the number of high-value strategic alternatives generated by entrepreneurs (Frosi, Chondrakis, Gagliardi, and Mariani, 2024), but it remains agnostic as to what mechanism underlies this increase in idea generation. This study adopts a similar design, and administers a similar manipulation, but aims to uncover the mechanisms through which the domains intervention, conditional on the scientific intervention, impacts exploration, theory framing, and decision-making. In particular, the project designs and implements a laboratory experiment following up on a field experiment with early-stage entrepreneurs carried out at ESADE University in Spain (previously pre-registered on AEA under the code AEARCTR-0009325) and a laboratory experiment with entrepreneurship graduate students carried out at Bocconi University in Italy (AEARCTR-0013189).
Intervention
The experiment is based on a Qualtrics-based business simulation where participants will first be asked to complete a baseline survey, collecting both demographic variables and variables assessing the level of each participant’s absorption of the theory-based approach.
Next, participants will be shown a training video (including the “domain” intervention or a placebo video). In particular:
1) Treated participants will receive an 8-minutes training video emphasizing the existence of domain-defining factors, their impact on theory formulation, and the advantages and disadvantages derived from exploring beyond them. Moreover, they will be asked to reflect on their own individual domains and how these may be influencing their decision-making; the “treatment video” will also talk about scaling a business, and focusing on how start-ups move from theory formulation to execution.
2) Non-treated participants will receive an 8-minutes training (placebo) video talking about scaling a business, and focusing on how start-ups move from theory formulation to execution.
Next, participants will be provided with 3 business models in the form of “theories of value” (Agarwal et al., 2023) developed by 3 early-stage start-ups in the process of defining their first strategic configurations.
At this point, we will ask participants whether they want to explore further or whether they want to launch the start-ups with the presented business models. In case they decide to engage in further exploration, we will ask them to propose elements (i.e., attributes) that they would explore on before going to the market, as well as any additional connections that they would draw among those elements.
Throughout the simulation, we will collect a number of measures, including participants’ beliefs about the final business models, and whether they would have considered additional attributes (and links) or not. Moreover, we will collect the time that it takes each participant to complete relevant steps (i.e., questions related to exploration and to additional attributes / links).
Experimental design
In this laboratory experiment, we rely on a sample of 75 MSc students (enrolled in the entrepreneurship MSc program at Bocconi University) who have been trained on the theory-based approach to decision-making (the “scientific” or “theory” intervention), and we expose them to a second intervention, the “domains” intervention. In subsequent waves, we plan to involve more students from different courses.
The domains intervention, which is at the core of this pre-analysis plan, makes participants aware of their domains (the set of knowledge they derive from their past experiences and background) and of the impact that domains exert on the framing of their entrepreneurial theories, and subsequent strategic alternatives.
Participants to the study, who have already received the theory intervention, are randomly allocated to two groups for the domains intervention (treated, untreated). We adopt a simple randomization routine.
The activity is presented as one of the requirements of a curricular course on strategic decision-making, and will take place during one of the course’s sessions (after participants have received the “theory” intervention). Students are rewarded with up to a bonus point (1/10) based on their performance during the experiment. Students who participate in this experiment are unaware of the goals of the experiment.
The experiment is based on a Qualtrics-based business simulation where participants will first be asked to complete a baseline survey, collecting both demographic variables and variables assessing the level of each participant’s absorption of the theory-based approach.
Next, participants will be shown a training video (including the “domain” intervention or a placebo video). In particular:
1) Treated participants will receive an 8-minutes training video emphasizing the existence of domain-defining factors, their impact on theory formulation, and the advantages and disadvantages derived from exploring beyond them. Moreover, they will be asked to reflect on their own individual domains and how these may be influencing their decision-making; the “treatment video” will also talk about scaling a business, and focusing on how start-ups move from theory formulation to execution.
2) Non-treated participants will receive an 8-minutes training (placebo) video talking about scaling a business, and focusing on how start-ups move from theory formulation to execution.
Next, they will be provided with 3 business models in the form of “theories of value” (Agarwal et al., 2023) developed by 3 early-stage start-ups in the process of defining their first strategic configurations.
At this point, we will ask them whether they want to explore further or whether they want to launch the start-ups with the presented business models. In case they decide to engage in further exploration, we will ask them to propose elements (i.e., attributes) that they would explore on before going to the market, as well as any additional connections that they would draw among those elements.
Throughout the simulation, we will collect a number of measures, including participants’ beliefs about the final business models, whether they would have considered additional attributes (and links) or not. Moreover, we will collect the time that it takes each participant to complete relevant steps (i.e., questions related to exploration and to additional attributes / links).
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.