Collective action problems pose significant barriers to addressing environmental problems in developing countries. In this project, we explore potential solutions to these challenges within the context of a rural area in a developing country. Our experiments compare the standard education approach which disseminates information about the environmental problem with three novel interventions. The first equips participants with a tailored set of tools aimed at enhancing cooperation and social capital within the community and thereby facilitating collective action. The second treatment adds a means for the community to monitor the environmental problem in public spaces. In the final variant, we provide additional information that enables the community to better understand their own exposure to the environmental issue. We also measure the impact on spillover farmers. We assess outcomes using metrics measuring changes in the environmental problem, production and cooperation within the community.
Intervention
In this project, we explore potential solutions to overcome a collective action problem within the context of a rural area in a developing country. We compare the standard approach which disseminates information about the environmental collective action problem with three novel interventions. The first equips participants with a tailored set of tools aimed at enhancing cooperation within the community and thereby facilitating collective action. The second one also provides communities with means to monitor the community in relation to the environmental problem. In a final variant the community can assess their own behaviour. We also measure the impact on spillover farmers.
Experimental design
In this project, we explore potential solutions to address a collective action problem in a rural area of a developing country. We compare the standard approach of disseminating information about the environmental issue with three innovative interventions. The first provides participants with tailored tools designed to strengthen community cooperation and promote collective action. The second adds a mechanism for communities to monitor their peers' behavior in relation to the environmental problem. In the final variant, the community members are given information to assess their own behavior. We also measure the impact on spillover farmers.
The experiment is conducted in Vietnam. The environmental problem is water pollution, and the spread of shrimp disease caused by the dumping of untreated and diseased water into public water ways. This water pollution harms the quality of the water, reducing the production of shrimp farmers in the local area.
Design details
Randomization method
In this study, a sampling approach will be employed to increase the representativeness of the sample. The sampling process will involve two stages: village selection and household selection.
First, four districts that are key shrimp producers are selected. A list of all villages in these four districts is obtained from the local government. The number of shrimp farms in each village is also obtained. From this village census, we exclude all villages that have less than 40 shrimp households. We then randomly select 74 villages and use the first 62 for our sample and the next 12 as possible replacements. We use stata to generate a random number for each village. A treatment is then assigned based on the ordering of the random number.
Second, in each selected village, we will obtain the list of all shrimp farmers from the local authorities and randomly select 24 farmers to participate. In cases when a household list cannot be obtained, we will work with the local village chief to ensure that the sample is close to being representative of shrimp farmers in the village.
Randomization unit
The cluster unit will be the village level. This is because the treatments are assigned at the village level.
Clusters
We will randomly select 62 villages==62 clusters.
Observations
Given the budget constraints and required logistics, we expect to reach about 2108 observations across 62 villages.
Arms
The sample will be distributed across the treatments as follows:
Baseline Environmental Info Only: 20 villages. With 24 observations in each village, for a total sample of 480 observations.
T1-T3: 14 villages in each treatment with 24 observations in each village, for a total sample of 336 observations in each treatment (T1 to T3).
Spillover control: The spillover control will be conducted in all villages. We will collect 10 observations in each village, for a total sample of 620 observations.
Primary outcomes
We will collect both short- and medium-term outcomes.
Short term outcomes: These are measured directly after the intervention
-Perceptions about the Community: We will use question s5_q2 to measure this. Further, we also use an index taken from a set of questions examining attitudes about the community. The index will be created by taking the mean of all the individual components. In both cases we will compare the cooperation treatments relative to the non-cooperation treatment.
Medium term outcomes: These are measured at least 3 months after the intervention (the exact time depends on availability)
-Shrimp farming production: We will collect a measure of total shrimp production in the relevant shrimp crop.
-Prevalence of the disease: We will elicit the proportion of shrimp impacted by disease as a total proportion of their current shrimp production.
- How much the farmer spent on treating the water released into public canals and rivers
Secondary outcomes
To understand possible mechanisms, we elicit the following secondary outcome variables:
-Contribution to the public good. This is measured using a standard public goods game.
-A dummy variable equal to one if the individual is doing something to overcome the environmental problem.
- A measure of the frequency with which an individual has discussed the environmental problem outside the households.
-Measure of social capital- this is an index created from the set of survey questions measuring social capital. The index is created by taking the average of all the survey questions. The index is measured at the household level.
-The amount spent on treating water taken in from public rivers and canals
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.