The Impact of Financial Market Exposure and Climate Disclosures on Knowledge of Climate Change and Attitudes towards Mitigation Policies

How to cite

Jha, Saumitra; Kala, Namrata; Hanlon, Michele; Weiss, Chagai; Shroff, Nemit. 2024. "The Impact of Financial Market Exposure and Climate Disclosures on Knowledge of Climate Change and Attitudes towards Mitigation Policies." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014492. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14492-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Saumitra Jha* , Namrata Kala , Michele Hanlon , Chagai Weiss , Nemit Shroff

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014492
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14492-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2024-09-27 – 2025-03-01
Countries
United States of America ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14492

Abstract

Climate change has proved to be one of the most important and salient challenges of our times. While informed and effective policies are essential to mitigate the adverse effects of climate change, attitudes towards climate change and preferences over climate mitigation policies in America are highly varied (Leiserowitz et al., 2019) and among the most politically polarized, making it highly challenging to develop support for bold, broad and bipartisan initiatives needed to address its challenges. Understanding which policy levers can be effective in reaching individuals, helping them to learn and overcome existing barriers that hinder support and action on climate change policies is thus vital.

Intervention

In past work (see references below), we have shown that learning by doing through financial market investment can provide a non-paternalistic approach to empowering individuals, helping them to learn, and rebuild trust, particularly among politically polarized groups. Building on these insights, we aim to see whether financial market exposure, both by itself and in combination with green disclosures, may also engender learning, and build broad support for climate change mitigation policies. . We will implement a large-scale experiment in which we endow investors with tailored investment portfolios, including assets in “green” or “brown” energy companies as well as climate disclosure information.

Combining data on asset allocation with surveys and behavioral data, we plan to answer three primary questions: 1) How do financial exposures impact beliefs about climate change, as well as support for climate mitigation policies? 2) How does climate disclosure information impact investors’ decisions, beliefs about climate change, as well as support for climate mitigation policies? 3) Do disclosures further impact the perceived risk-adjusted returns of financial portfolios, in a way that alters the effect of financial market exposures on these outcomes?

References
1) Leiserowitz, Anthony et al. “Climate Change in the American Mind”, Yale Program on Climate Communications, November 2019
2) Jha, Saumitra and Moses Shayo “Valuing Peace: The Effects of Financial Market Exposure on Votes and Political Attitudes”, Econometrica, Vol. 87. No. 5, pp.1561-1588, September 2019.
3) Jha, Saumitra and Moses Shayo, “Trading Stocks Builds Financial Confidence and Compresses the Gender Gap”, Economic Journal, July 2024.
4) Rivera, Eduardo, Enrique Seira and Saumitra Jha “Apex Corruption and the Erosion of Democratic Values”, Stanford GSB Research Paper 4166, May 2024.
5) Jha, Saumitra, Moses Shayo and Chagai Weiss “Financial Market Exposure Increases Generalized Trust, Particularly Among the Politically Polarized”, Stanford GSB Research Paper 4083, May 2024, conditionally accepted, Journal of Public Economics

Experimental design

Please see below.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization at the individual level done in an office by a computer. Stratification sequentially based on party ID, region, climate policy priority, and past trading experience.
Randomization unit
Individual level randomization.
Clusters
NA
Observations
3800
Arms
Total 3800 of which pure control 1400 Assigned to Trading 2400 Of which: Fantasy 500 Real 1900 Cross randomized into Brown and Green Stock portfolios. Brown 950 Green 950 Cross randomized into high initial value ($100):950, low value ($50): 950
Primary outcomes
We consider outcomes in two domains: 1. Climate Beliefs (4 item index): Please indicate how much you agree or disagree with each of the following statements about climate change (7 point Likert scale). a. Climate change will have a serious impact on the quality of life of people in the US during my lifetime. b. Human activities are a significant cause of climate change. c. Extreme weather events such as floods, fires, and hurricanes are made more likely due to climate change. d. Climate change is not a serious issue. 2. Perception of Transition Costs and Limitations (4 item index): Please indicate how much you agree or disagree with each of the following statements (7 point scale): a. Renewable energy will threaten many coal, oil and gas jobs in America. b. Renewable energy will take up land that could be used for more productive economic causes. c. Renewable energy will not be able to efficiently meet the needs of the American economy in the next 10 years. d. Renewable energy will not be able to efficiently meet the needs of the American economy in the next 20 years. 3. Perceptions of Transition Benefits (4 item index): Please indicate how much you agree or disagree with each of the following statements (7 point scale): a. Renewable energy industries, including those based on wind, solar, etc., will create many well-paying jobs for Americans. b. Renewable energy industries have the potential to be a central cause of economic growth in the U.S. c. Investing in renewable energy is an important way to fight climate change. d. On balance, the transition to renewable energy solar from fossil fuels like coal and gas will be beneficial for the US economy in the next 10 years. 4. Climate policy priority (single item measuring the position of climate in respondents’ priorities): Please order the following policy priorities from most (1) to least (7) important: a. Addressing climate change b. Addressing immigration c. Strengthening the nation’s economy d. Improving the nation’s healthcare system e. Strengthening the U.S. military f. Improving access to social services for low-income communities g. Other (please specify) 5. Support for government action on climate issues (2-item index): How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements (7 point scale)? a. The U.S. government should do more to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. b. The U.S. government should only contribute to climate mitigation if other countries like China and India do the same. 6. Support for business action on climate issues (2-item index): How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements (7 point scale)? a. U.S. companies should do more to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. b. U.S. companies should contribute to climate mitigation if companies in other countries, such as China and India, do the same. 7. Climate-friendly behavioral intentions (5 item index): How likely are you to engage in each of the following behaviors (7 point scale): a. Sign a petition in support of protecting the environment. b. Join or renew membership in an environmental group. c. Actively choose to walk, bike or use public transportation over driving your own vehicle. d. Actively attempt to use reusable bags when visiting the grocery store. e. Consciously reduce meat consumption. f. Donate survey award to climate-related NGO (amount donated). Second Domain: Polarization and Voting. 1. Affective polarization: Measured as in-party feeling thermometer subtracted from out-party feeling thermometer. 2. Vote intentions, turnout as well as candidate choice.
Secondary outcomes
Financial Literacy 1. Financial literacy (3 item index measuring correct answers to the following questions): a. Suppose you had $100 in a savings account, and the interest rate was 2% per year. After 5 years, how much do you think you would have in the account if you left the money in the account for the entire period? b. Do you think the following is true or false: Buying a company stock usually provides a safer return than a stock mutual fund? c. Suppose you had $100 in a savings account, and the interest rate is 20% per year, and you never withdraw money or interest payments. After five years, how much would you have in this account in total? 2. Generalized Trust.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords