How regional predictions of heat events in the coming summer and their forward-attribution to climate change affect support for adaptation and mitigation measures as well as attribution of guilt across generations. (second wave)

How to cite

Longo, Enrico; Perino, Grischa; Lange, Andreas; Drupp, Moritz; Damania, Mrunali; Baehr, Johanna. 2024. "How regional predictions of heat events in the coming summer and their forward-attribution to climate change affect support for adaptation and mitigation measures as well as attribution of guilt across generations. (second wave)." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014419. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14419-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Enrico Longo* , Grischa Perino , Andreas Lange , Moritz Drupp , Mrunali Damania , Johanna Baehr

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014419
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14419-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-10-22 – 2024-11-05
Countries
Private
JEL codes
Q54, Q58, D91
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14419

Abstract

In this second, ex-post wave, we re-contact participants of all experimental conditions after having experienced the summer (June - August) of 2024. We investigate how heterogeneity in experience and in the accuracy of prediction shape willingness-to-pay (revealed preferences) for seasonal and trust in long-run climate prediction, as well as revealed-preference support for adaptation and mitigation measures.
Design: All (including the control group) are given the prediction/risk-assessment (75th percentile of the number of tropical nights) and the observation according to official records for their region as well as information on the nation-wide accuracy of the risk-assessment. Half of participants are in addition presented with a graphical representation (on a map) of how the risk-assessment performed relative to observations. With respect to the elicitation of the willingness-to-pay (WTP) for seasonal predictions for summer 2025, we elicit WTP of the same risk assessment as used in the current study for half of participants. The other half is first asked to choose their preferred risk assessment (tropical nights vs. hot days / three levels of risk) before the WTP for the selected seasonal prediction is elicited.
In an independent random draw, half of participants is confronted with a statement that seasonal and long-run climate predictions are based on the same basic principles and similar models. The latter is inteded to exogenously vary the degree to which trust in seasonal predictions spills over to long-run predictions.

Intervention

Assignments of all interventions/treatments are independent of each other and of interventions in wave 1.

Intervention 1 "Map" (Text+Map vs Text group):
Half of participants is presented with a map that details the geographical distribution of the nation-wide accuracy of the risk-assessment (75th percentile of seasonal prediction).

Intervention 2 "Preferred risk assessment" (PredefinedChoice vs. FreeChoice group):
Half of participants can choose from a set of six (2 x 3) different risk assessments to be ordered for 1st of June to 31st of August 2025 (delivery in May 2025) rather than stating willingness-to-pay for the risk assessment used in waves 1 and 2 (75th percentile of number of tropical nights).

Intervention 3 "Same science" (WithNotice vs. WithoutNotice group):
Half of participants is presented with a statement that seasonal and long-run climate predictions are based on the same scientfic understanding of the climate system and similar models.

Experimental design

All participants (including the control group) are given the prediction/risk-assessment (75th percentile of the number of tropical nights) and the observation according to official records for their region as well as information on the nation-wide accuracy of the risk-assessment used in wave 1.
Half of participants are in addition presented with a graphical representation (on a map) of how the risk-assessment performed relative to observations.
With respect to the elicitation of the willingness-to-pay (WTP) for seasonal predictions for summer 2025, we elicit WTP of the same risk assessment as used in the current study for half of participants. The other half is first asked to choose their preferred risk assessment (tropical nights vs. hot days / three levels of risk) before the WTP for the selected seasonal prediction is elicited.
In an independent random draw, half of participants is confronted with a statement that seasonal and long-run climate predictions are based on the same basic principles and similar models. The latter is inteded to exogenously vary the degree to which trust in seasonal predictions spills over to long-run predictions.

Design details

Randomization method
all randomizations (experimental conditions, assignment of cash payment levels, and selection of winners in lottery) are random draws done by a computer Assignment of experimental conditions and cash payment levels is done in real time by the survey company. Drawing of winners is done after completion of the study by the authors.
Randomization unit
Experimental conditions (treatments/interventions), assigment of cash payments for willingness-to-pay elicitations and drawing of winners of the lottery randomizes at the level of all participants.
Observations
about 3,000 individuals - as many as we can attract from those having completed wave 1 (4.251 individuals).
Arms
All interventions are independent random draws that split the group in half.
Primary outcomes
The following revealed-preference outcomes are elicitied: Willingness-to-pay for risk assessment for summer 2025 (June 1 to August 31) to be delivered in May 2025 either for the risk assessment used in waves 1 and 2 or the risk assessment preferred by the participant (see intervention 2). Participants are randomly presented with a monetary payment (ranging from 0.10 € to 5 €) that they would forgo when opting to receive the risk assessment (seasonal prediction) for summer 2025 in May 2025. Willingness-to-donate to support adaptation in the form of plant trees in a large German city. Participants are enroled in a lottery (chance of winning is 1 in 200) and are asked to specify how much of the 100 € prize they would be willinging to donate to plant trees in a major German city. They are informed that urban trees improve air quality and provide cooling services. Willingness-to-support mitigation in the form of a costly vote in favor of retiring emission allowances from the EU Emission Trading System. Participants can choose between a certain payment of 0.70 € and voting in favor of retiring allowances corresponding to 10 tons of CO2 from the European Union Emission Trading System. If at least half of the valid votes is in favor of retiring, then allowances will be retired and no payments made to participants. We use intervention 3 (climate modeling) to separate participants in two groups for which we count votes separately. For more details on all three primary outcomes see survey.
Secondary outcomes
Stated-preference: Measure of trust in seasonal prediction/risk assessment identical to the one used in waves 1 and 2. (5-point Likert scale) Yes/No question about whether participant has bought an air fan for the summer of 2024. Support for five adaptation measures elicited on 5-point Likert scales a) mandatory insurance against natural hazards for all landlords b) more space for and planting of urban trees to reduce heat in cities c) Subsidies for the installation of air conditioning in private homes and offices d) provision of reuasable water bottles for homeless people free of charge f) Heat-warning app that also provides advice on how to protect oneself Further variables are: Beliefs regarding climate change, its origin and severity recollected number of tropical nights (>20°C) and hot days (>30°C) for June 1 and August 31, 2024 Experienced extreme weather events (flooding, strong rainfalls, storms, draughts, bushfires, heat waves, other) Experienced health impacts
Sponsors
Name: Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft e.V. (DFG) Location: Bonn, Germany Url: https://www.dfg.de

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords