Acceptance of Different Revenue Recycling Schemes for Carbon Pricing

How to cite

Flörchinger, Daniela; Eßer, Jana; Frondel, Manuel. 2024. "Acceptance of Different Revenue Recycling Schemes for Carbon Pricing." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014418. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14418-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Daniela Flörchinger* , Jana Eßer , Manuel Frondel

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014418
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14418-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-09-25 – 2025-06-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D83, H23, H30, Q58
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14418

Abstract

Carbon pricing is an effective and efficient measure to reduce carbon emissions. Previous research has shown that acceptance of carbon pricing is highest when its revenues are earmarked for green spending. This is because many people believe that the effectiveness in reducing carbon emissions depends on revenue use. In this study, we test whether explaining that carbon pricing increases the relative price of carbon-intensive products and thereby stirs demand towards more climate-friendly alternatives can increase acceptance and perceived effectiveness of revenue recycling schemes other than green spending. Our randomized experiment is embedded in a large-scale online survey (N=4,000).

Intervention

This study investigates whether explaining how carbon pricing works can increase support and perceived effectiveness of revenue recycling schemes other than green spending. To this end, we conduct an online survey-experiment among 4,000 respondents.
The sample is randomly split into a treatment group and a control group of equal size.

At the beginning of the experiment, both groups are asked about their familiarity with German carbon pricing, which was introduced in 2021.
After that, the treatment group receives an information treatment about the functioning and goals of German carbon pricing in the form of a quiz: In a set of multiple-choice questions, respondents are asked to select the correct answers. After each question, they are then provided with an explanation of the correct answer. By structuring the information treatment as a quiz, we aim to increase the respondents' engagement with the information provided, compared to simply providing it as a text.

Subsequently, we present all respondents of the treatment and control group with six suggestions of how the revenues generated by carbon pricing can be used. The suggestions (presented in random order) are:
- The expansion of renewable energies or climate-friendly transportation systems (green spending)
- An annual lump-sum repayment
- Support of low-income households
- Reduction of electricity prices by lowering the grid charge
- Integration into the overall government budget
- Reduction of government debt.

Afterwards, study participants are asked to state on a five-point Likert scale whether they agree with the suggested revenue use and whether they consider it effective.

Experimental design

This study investigates whether explaining how carbon pricing works can increase support and perceived effectiveness of revenue recycling schemes other than green spending. To this end, we conduct an online survey-experiment among 4,000 respondents.
The sample is randomly split into a treatment group and a control group of equal size.

At the beginning of the experiment, both groups are asked about their familiarity with German carbon pricing, which was introduced in 2021.
After that, the treatment group receives an information treatment about the functioning and goals of German carbon pricing in the form of a quiz: In a set of multiple-choice questions, respondents are asked to select the correct answers. After each question, they are then provided with an explanation of the correct answer. By structuring the information treatment as a quiz, we aim to increase the respondents' engagement with the information provided, compared to simply providing it as a text.

Subsequently, we present all respondents of the treatment and control group with six suggestions of how the revenues generated by carbon pricing can be used. The suggestions (presented in random order) are:
- The expansion of renewable energies or climate-friendly transportation systems (green spending)
- An annual lump-sum repayment
- Support of low-income households
- Reduction of electricity prices by lowering the grid charge
- Integration into the overall government budget
- Reduction of government debt.

Afterwards, study participants are asked to state on a five-point Likert scale whether they agree with the suggested revenue use and whether they consider it effective.

Design details

Randomization method
randomization by computer
Randomization unit
individual
Clusters
0
Observations
4,000 individuals
Arms
2,000 individuals in the treatment group and 2,000 individuals in the control group
Primary outcomes
Difference between agreement of revenue use for green spending and annual lump-sum repayment, support of low-income households, reduction of electricity prices, integration into the overall government budget, reduction of government debt. Difference in perceived effectiveness of carbon pricing when its revenue is used for green spending and annual lump-sum repayment, support of low-income households, reduction of electricity prices, integration into the overall government budget, reduction of government debt.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords