Eliciting preferences over distributive justice principles
How to cite
Lambrecht, Marco; Andersson, Ola; Miettinen, Topi. 2024. "Eliciting preferences over distributive justice principles." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014413. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14413-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Distributive justice principles are commonly used in societal debates to support policy positions and argue for their legitimacy. Prominent formal incarnations of such principles are the Rawlsian, Utilitarian, Efficient transfer (e.g. Pigou-Dalton), and Leaky-bucket transfer (e.g. Hammond) principles, but could also be formulated by the minimization of the Gini coefficient, for instance. Individual preferences over such principles may arguably depend on individuals’ understanding of their application. In an incentivized task, we observe heterogeneity in individuals’ abilities to apply distributive justice principles to specific income distribution scenarios. We systematically test whether exposure to applying these principles, with and without feedback, changes preferences over principles. We compare responses in a student sample to a sample representative of the general population in the UK. Our findings may have important implications for the elicitation of preferences over distributive justice principles.
Intervention
The experimental design includes three treatments:
1) Baseline: subjects apply a dummy principle to pairs of income distributions
2) Application: subjects apply distributive justice principles to pairs of income distributions
3) Feedback: subjects apply distributive justice principles to pairs of income distributions and receive feedback whether their answers are correct
Experimental design
Stages of the experiment:
- application task
- ranking
- survey questions
- summary
The experimental design includes three treatments:
1) Baseline: subjects apply a dummy principle to pairs of income distributions
2) Application: subjects apply distributive justice principles to pairs of income distributions
3) Feedback: subjects apply distributive justice principles to pairs of income distributions and receive feedback whether their answers are correct
We collect responses online from two different samples:
A) Student sample (UK students, via Prolific)
B) Representative sample (UK population, via Prolific)
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.