Accounting for Agriculture in Development: Impact of a Digital Platform for Farm Finances

How to cite

Maitra, Pushkar; Boudot-Reddy, Camille; Butler, Andre. 2024. "Accounting for Agriculture in Development: Impact of a Digital Platform for Farm Finances." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014359. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14359-1.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Pushkar Maitra* , Camille Boudot-Reddy , Andre Butler

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014359
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14359-1.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-11-01 – 2027-01-01
Countries
Private
JEL codes
G51, O12, O13
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14359

Abstract

Financial record keeping is rarely practised among farmers in low/middle income countries despite it being crucial to running a successful business. Through a randomised control trial we propose to study the impact of a digital farm financial management tool developed in conjunction with the Peoples Action for National Integration (PANI). The app, which will be deployed among small and marginal farmers in the state of Uttar Pradesh, India from November 2024, will enable them to record and review their expenses and income over the agricultural season. A comparison of the farmers having received the app with those that did not will enable us to measure the direct impact of farm financial management on production choices, revenue and profits. This project will employ empirical methods for robust causal inference on the behaviour of agricultural market participants to further our understanding of barriers to economic growth within the sector and consequently highlight potential paths to reducing income/wealth disparities.

Intervention

We propose to study the impact of a farm financial management tool implemented by People’s Action for National Integration (PANI) -- a social development organisation working in underdeveloped regions of Uttar Pradesh. PANI developed a mobile application which enables farmers to record and review their expenses and income over the agricultural season. Downloaded on the mobile phone of farmers, the application requests farmers to record their expenses (specific to practices along the growing season including preparing land, seed and sowing, soil health, plant growth, pesticide, irrigation, and harvesting), as well as their harvest value (including both quantity, verified through a crop cutting exercise on a square meter of cultivated land, and price received if the crop is sold). This information is reviewed monthly allowing farmers to update their records on a regular basis.

PANI plans to extend their programme across Eastern Uttar Pradesh in late 2024. We propose to leverage this new role-out to investigate the impact of farm financial management for farmers using the platform. Using a randomised control trial, our experiment will randomly allocate farmers to either receive the app or not. In the first agricultural season, farmers having been selected to receive the app will be visited on a monthly basis by PANI community workers to encourage them to update their financial records on the platform. This data will be used to calculate crop-wise the total costs, value of harvest, and returns to investment -- broadly termed as financial summary. At the end of the season, PANI community workers will visit the farmers to explain their customised financial summary.

While keeping track of expenses and having a better understanding of the farm business may prove critical for making important production choices, seeing this information benchmarked to other farmers in the area may also be valuable. Preliminary evidence from PANIs trial using their digital platform suggests that there may be valuable information to share on farmer practices. We therefore propose to include a separate intervention arm wherein farmers will receive the financial management platform as explained above, with the additional feature of having this summary benchmarked to the top 25% of producers.

This project will employ empirical methods for robust causal inference on the behaviour of agricultural market participants to further our understanding of barriers to economic growth within the sector and consequently highlight potential paths to reducing income/wealth disparities.

Experimental design

Financial-app: Randomly select 55 Gram Panchayats reached by PANI as part of their expansion to form the "Financial app" group. In each of these Gram Panchayats, 40 of the farmers listed by PANI as programme participants will be randomly selected and allocated to either receive the financial management application (T1: Treatment) or not (C1: Control). A comparison of the farmers having received the app with those that did not will enable us to measure the direct impact of farm financial management on production choices.

Benchmarking: Randomly select 55 Gram Panchayats reached by PANI as part of their expansion to form the "Benchmarking" group. In each of these GPs, 40 of the farmers listed by PANI as programme participants will be randomly selected and allocated to either receive the financial management application + benchmarking (T2: Treatment) or not (C2: Control). The benchmarking will be implemented by using the data across the pool of all study participants and provide the summary of farm finances of each farmer benchmarked to the top 25% of producers. A comparison of the farmers having received this intervention with those that did not will enable us to measure the direct impact of benchmarked farm financial management on production choices. A post-estimation comparison to the effect capture in the "Financial app" group will tell us the additional impact of having the benchmarking.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomisation will be conducted in office using a computer, based on the lists of Gram Panchayats and farming households identified by PANI as beneficiaries of their programme.
Randomization unit
For the purpose of the study design, the Gram Panchayats will be randomly selected from the total list of Gram Panchayats identified by PANI to roll-out their new programme. Within each selected Gram Panchayat, farmers identified by PANI as beneficiaries of their programme will be randomly selected and allocated to either receive the financial management app or not.
Clusters
4400 households across 110 Gram Panchayats
Observations
4400 households across 110 Gram Panchayats
Arms
Number of households and Gram Panchayats in each treatment arm: 1. Financial-app arm -- 2200 households across 55 GPs (40 households/GP) 2. Benchmarking arm -- 2200 households across 55 GPs (40 households/GP)
Primary outcomes
The key outcome variables in our analysis will be: 1. Crop choice 2. Expenses on inputs 2. Value of harvest 3. Farm profit, which will take into account imputed costs of family labour
Secondary outcomes
Some of the secondary outcome variables in our analysis will be: 1. Saving 2. Credit 3. Wellbeing

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords