Testing Identified Elements for Success in Fatherhood Programs (Fatherhood TIES)

How to cite

Michalopoulos, Charles; Israel, Dina; Manno, Michelle. 2024. "Testing Identified Elements for Success in Fatherhood Programs (Fatherhood TIES)." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014310. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14310-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Charles Michalopoulos* , Dina Israel , Michelle Manno

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014310
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14310-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2024-01-18 – 2027-06-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
I31, J12, J22
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14310

Abstract

Fatherhood TIES is testing several interventions within federally funded fatherhood programs with the goal of improving fathers’ economic stability, parenting, co-parenting, and relationship quality. The interventions include: (1) one-on-one coaching focused on improving parenting, (2) individualized, concierge-level supports for navigating various systems that affect fathers’ ability to spend time with their children, such as family court, child welfare, and child support; and (3) financial supports and financial coaching. In general, the interventions are intended to affect parenting behavior, father-child relationships, co-parenting relationships, economic stability, and father well-being. For the first two interventions, fathers are being randomly assigned to the intervention or business-as-usual. The third test is based on a factorial design, in which cohorts of fathers enrolled at the same time are being assigned to receive a financial payment or not, and within each group individual fathers are being randomly assigned to receive financial coaching or not. The study will include 2,060 fathers, of which 480 will be enrolled in the parenting coaching study, 600 will be enrolled in the systems navigation study, and 980 will be enrolled in the financial supports study.

Intervention

The study includes three different tests. In all three tests, the control group is receiving services from an existing federally-funded fatherhood program. Fathers are being randomly assigned to that control group or to a program group that receives additional services. In test 1, the additional services include one-on-one coaching focused on parenting in addition to other services at an existing fatherhood program. In test 2, the additional services are individualized, concierge-level supports for navigating various systems that affect fathers’ ability to spend time with their children, such as family court, child welfare, and child support. In test 3, the additional services are financial supports in the form of $1500 paid out over three months, financial coaching, or both. For test 3, fathers will be assigned to four groups using a factorial design. The four groups include (1) financial supports only, (2) financial coaching only, (3) financial supports plus financial coaching, (4) the control group.

Experimental design

The study includes three different tests. In all three tests, the control group will receive services from an existing federally funded fatherhood program. Fathers will be randomly assigned to that control group or to a program group that receives additional services. In test 1, the additional services will include one-on-one coaching focused on parenting in addition to other services at an existing fatherhood program. In test 2, the additional services will be individualized, concierge-level supports for navigating various systems that affect fathers’ ability to spend time with their children, such as family court, child welfare, and child support. In test 3, the additional services will include financial support in the form of $1500 paid out over three months, financial coaching, or both. For test 3, fathers will be assigned to four groups using a factorial design. The four groups include (1) financial supports only, (2) financial coaching only, (3) financial supports plus financial coaching, (4) the control group.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is done through the nFORM MIS system that all participating programs are using to enroll individuals into their program. Individual-level randomization in computerized in the nFORM MIS system and it is set up at the site level, for individuals to be randomly assigned within each of the five sites participating in TIES. An assignment block size is also set-up to achieve Treatment/Control ratio within a block of 10.
Randomization unit
For the first and second tests, individuals are being randomized. For the third test, individuals are being randomized to receive financial coaching or not, but cohorts of fathers who enroll at the same time are being randomized to receive the financial payment or not.
Clusters
Study 1 will include approximately 480 individuals. Study 2 will include approximately 600 individuals. Study 3 will include approximately 980 individuals within approximately 40 cohorts. The 980 individuals will be randomized to receive financial coaching or not. The 40 clusters will be randomized such that thirty percent receive financial payments and 70 percent will not.
Observations
Approximately 2,060 individuals.
Arms
Study 1: 192 parent coaching, 288 business-as-usual. Study 2: 180 systems navigation, 420 business-as-usual. Study 3: 12 cohorts financial payments, 28 cohorts no payments; 294 individuals financial coaching, 686 fathers business-as-usual.
Primary outcomes
The key outcome variables will vary with the intervention: • Parenting coaching: parenting skills and parent-child relationship quality (nurturing activities, non-violent discipline, harsh parenting, parent-child closeness, parenting stress, self-efficacy), and time spent with children (father-child frequency of contact, satisfaction with time spent with child). • Systems navigation: parenting skills and parent-child relationship quality (nurturing activities, non-violent discipline, harsh parenting, parent-child closeness, parenting stress, self-efficacy), quality of relationship with co-parent (destructive and constructive communication, satisfaction with ci-parenting relationship, overall quality of co-parenting relationship, frequency of contact), time spent with children (father-child frequency of contact, satisfaction with time spent with child), and successful execution of steps to navigate systems (child custody, child support, establishment of paternity). • Financial supports: Father well-being (depression, anxiety), and indicators of economic stability (employment status and earnings, food insecurity, material hardship) In addition, results will be pooled across all interventions to look at parenting skills and parent-child relationship quality, quality of co-parenting relationship, father well-being, and indicators of economic stability.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords