Do Robotic Calls from Credible Sources Influence Voter Turnout or Vote Choice?

How to cite

Green, Donald; Shaw, Daron; Gerber, Alan. 2016. "Do Robotic Calls from Credible Sources Influence Voter Turnout or Vote Choice?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001430. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1430-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Donald Green* , Daron Shaw , Alan Gerber

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0001430
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1430-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2003-03-06 – 2003-03-08
Countries
United States of America (Texas)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/1430

Abstract

The effectiveness of prerecorded phone calls was assessed in the context of a Texas Republican primary election that featured a contest for state Supreme Court. Automated calls endorsing one of the judicial candidates were recorded by the sitting Republican governor and directed at more than a quarter million people identified as likely voters and probably supporters of the governor. Two experimental designs were used to evaluate the calls' effectiveness. The first design randomly assigned households to treatment and control conditions in order to gauge the calls' effects on individuals' voter turnout, as measured by public records. The second design randomly assigned precincts to treatment and control conditions in order to assess whether the calls increased the precinct-level vote margin of the endorsed candidate. Results suggest that the automated calls had weak and statistically insignificant effects on turnout and vote margins.

Intervention

Automated phone calls with the recorded voice of Governor Rick Perry urging Republicans to support a candidate for Texas Supreme Court.

Experimental design

This study consisted of a two-tiered experiment aimed at evaluating how automated phone calls affect both voter mobilization and persuasion. This evaluation was conducted in the context of a Texas Republican primary election that featured a contest for state Supreme Court. Automated calls endorsing one of the judicial candidates, Don Willett, were recorded by the sitting Republican governor, Rick Perry, and directed at more than a quarter million people identified as likely voters and probable supporters of the governor. The working hypothesis was that calls conveying a message from a prominent and credible source, such as the sitting Republican Governor, should have a persuasive effect.

The first experimental analysis randomly assigned precincts containing between 100 and 700 (likely) Republican and pro-Perry households to treatment and control groups. The turnout and persuasion hypotheses were assessed by comparing average outcomes in the treatment and control precincts.

The second analysis occurred in precincts containing fewer than 100 or more than 700 Republican households. Within these precincts, households, rather than precincts, were randomly assigned to treatment or control groups.

Design details

Randomization method
Experiment 1: Turnout was measured at the level of the individual voter. Random assignment of targeted households was conducted using a random generator in SPSS. Experiment 2: Within the precincts selected for experiment 2, households, rather than precincts, were randomly assigned to treatment or control groups. Robotic calls were directed only to phone numbers belonging to individuals in the treatment group.
Randomization unit
Experiment 1: - Turnout measured at the level of the individual voter and assigned at the household level (where households were defined as shared phone numbers) - Vote choice observed at the precinct level Experiment 2: Precincts were assigned to treatment or control using the same targeting criteria as the household-level random assignment. Turnout and vote choice observed at the household level
Clusters
1,597 precincts
Observations
292,602 voters
Arms
Experiment 1: - The 815 treatment precincts contained a total of 147,660 voters, as compared to 782 control precincts, which contained 144,942 voters. Vote choice was observed only at the precinct level. Experiment 2: - A total of 105,270 voters lived in households whose phone number was assigned to the treatment group. The control group comprised 65,657 voters.
Primary outcomes
Effects of Robotic Calls on Voter Turnout Based on Precinct Level Random Assignment - Percentage Voting Effect of Robotic Calls on Voter Turnout Based on Household Level Random Assignment, by Household Size: - One-Voter Households Percentage Voting - Two-Voter Households Percentage Voting Estimated Effects of Robotic Calls on Precinct-Level Outcomes: - GOP Primary Votes Cast - GOP Turnout - Votes Cast for Willett or Smith - Willett Votes - Net Willett-Smith Difference

Materials

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords