Better Together? Returns to Capital, Group Consulting, and Inter-firm Relationships Among Small Firms in Ghana
How to cite
Awadey, Amanda; Boudreau, Laura; Davies, Elwyn. 2025. "Better Together? Returns to Capital, Group Consulting, and Inter-firm Relationships Among Small Firms in Ghana." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014260. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14260-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Entrepreneurs in developing countries often have small and stagnant businesses, frequently reporting capital constraints and failing to implement standard best management practices. There is evidence that providing capital alone spurs growth while providing consulting services (group or individual) also improves management practices for such firms. In the case of group consulting, firm growth also increased significantly, delivering a cheaper yet superior alternative to individual consulting (De Mel et al. 2008; McKenzie & Woodruff 2008; Fafchamps et al. 2014; McKenzie, 2017; Iacovone, Maloney, and McKenzie, 2022). However, the mechanisms underlying the effectiveness of group consulting remain unknown, and any complementarities from jointly providing it with capital among the same firms is still an open question. We extend this literature, incorporating promising evidence on peer learning among entrepreneurs from Cai and Szeidl (2018), by evaluating the impact of providing 1,000 small firms (6-30 employees) in Ghana with scale-up grants, group-based managerial consulting, and peer learning opportunities in a randomized control trial (RCT). Specifically, we design our research to examine mechanisms underlying the effectiveness of group consulting and test for complementarities between large grants and group consulting on revenue and employment in a scalable setting. In a linked survey experiment, we also explore the possibility of eliciting information about participating entrepreneurs’ marginal returns (MRs) to the business support interventions and future business performance from their business networks of peer entrepreneurs, suppliers, and customers.
Intervention
We conduct an RCT to evaluate the impact of a large-scale business support program, the Enterprise Grow Program, implemented by the Government of Ghana through the Ghana Enterprises Agency (GEA) in partnership with the World Bank. In the RCT, 1,000 small enterprises (sized 6-30 employees) are randomly assigned to receive large grants of variable size (estimated mean: $10,000) and/or group-based managerial consulting (Iacovone, Maloney & McKenzie, 2022), group-based peer learning, and control conditions. Using this research design, we identify the causal effect of the program’s interventions and explore the underlying mechanisms of the effectiveness of group consulting and complementarities with grants in a scalable setting. Peer learning can be a cheaper alternative to group consulting and of policy relevance. We also examine heterogeneity in the marginal returns to capital, managerial group consulting, and peer networks/learning across small firms. With this, we can provide policy-relevant evidence on how these types of business support services could be targeted by firm type.
In a related prediction survey experiment (AEA’s RCT registry (AEARCTR-0013786)), we leverage this RCT to examine the ability of entrepreneurs’ business networks – their peers, suppliers, and customers – to predict entrepreneurs’ marginal returns to the program’s interventions and their future business performance in the short to longer term. By combining these experiments, we can obtain unbiased estimates of the marginal returns to these interventions across the distribution of predicted returns, allowing us to test the accuracy of marginal return predictions, and to measure the predictive power of information gathered about entrepreneurs’ absolute and relative performance.
This RCT includes firms from the GEA’s four calls for applications rolled out over two years. The program aims to use a rigorous screening process to target “high-growth potential” small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) – SMEs with promising prospects of scaling up their operations through increasing sales and job creation. Our study’s sample focuses on 1,000 small firms (6-30 employees) in the program. The treatment arms are: group-based consulting only, group-based peer learning only, group-based consulting and cash grant, cash grant only and a control group.
By combining the group-based consulting treatment and the group-based peer learning treatment in the same RCT, we can evaluate their relative performance and begin to disentangle possible underlying group mechanisms at play using experimental games. Furthermore, our research design allows us to examine heterogeneity in the marginal returns to capital, managerial group consulting, and peer networks/learning across small firms along many characteristics.
Experimental design
The study is designed as a randomized controlled trial (RCT), with eligible firms being randomized across five treatment arms: (1) control (no grant, only 360 assessment), (2) peer learning without grant, (3) group consulting without grant, (4) grant with only 360 assessment, (5) group consulting with grant. Each treatment arm has a target of 200 firms to be included.
Across all four cohorts, firms apply in a two-stage process. In the first stage, firms apply through an online portal. Based on the application data, an automated score is generated, and about 2,000 top-scoring firms are selected. Selected firms are invited to participate in a 4-day business management training.
In the second stage, each participant from the business management training is invited to submit a business proposal highlighting areas for improvement and goals they expect to reach during the program. These proposals are screened and assessed by technical experts based on technical criteria (e.g., feasibility or potential). The successful firms (about 1000 across the four cohorts) are then eligible for randomization by the research team into five treatment arms.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.