Post-Marital Settlements and Support Systems in Rural Malawi

How to cite

Barbeta, Anna. 2024. "Post-Marital Settlements and Support Systems in Rural Malawi." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014253. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14253-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Anna Barbeta*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014253
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14253-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2024-08-01 – 2024-09-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
J16, J12, Z13, D81, O15
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14253

Abstract

This project aims to examine the impact of post-marital settlements (i.e., patrilocality and matrilocality) on married women’s social networks in rural Malawi and estimate its effects on informal insurance, social capital, and investment behavior using a lab-in-the-field experiment, self-reported data, and vignette stories.

The lab-in-the-field experiment is structured as follows: women participants will be randomly assigned to roles as either decision-makers or associates. Decision-makers will choose between lotteries with varying levels of risk, while associates will decide when and how much to insure the decision-makers. We will manipulate certain conditions to observe if associates' insurance decisions change based on the risk level chosen by the decision-makers, the proportion of people experiencing losses, and the relationship between the decision-maker and the associate (e.g., relative, in-law, friend, acquaintance, stranger). The study will also explore how decision-makers risk-taking behavior is influenced by the availability of support from associates, the potential for performance comparison with others, and the relationship between the decision-maker and the associate.

Experimental design

We will begin by selecting 6 participants to serve as decision-makers. These decision-makers will then identify their 3 most significant community members for support and their 3 most important kin members. From each list, we will invite the 3rd most relevant individuals to act as “associates.” In each round, decision-makers will be randomly paired
with associates. The decision-makers will choose how much risk to take by selecting one lottery from a
list of two, each with different risk and profit combinations. Meanwhile, the associates will decide
whether and how much to insure. Decision-makers will be informed that associates will have an
endowment of around 1.7$ but the amount shared with the decision-maker will remain private.

Participants will play 2 main games in which different levels of information about the “Decision-Maker”
behavior will be revealed. These 2 games correspond to the main treatment conditions.
The details of each game are as follows:
* No signal round: Without any more information besides the identity of their partner, we ask the associate to choose how much MKW they are willing to give to the "DM” in case she loses the lottery chosen.
• Signal round: In this game, decision-makers choose a lottery to play, aware that their
associates will receive information about the performance of previous players who faced the
same choice between two lotteries. After reviewing the statistics of the losers,
the associates decide how much money to share with the decision-maker in case she loses. Additionally, associates will guess whether the decision-maker is among the people who lost or not.

Decision-makers will play 4 rounds of each of the 2 games, with a different player in each round. To account
for "social distance," decision-makers will play 1 round with a listed associate and the remaining 3
rounds with individuals not on their list. Associates will play 5 rounds, 2 without any information, 2 with information about the loser's statistics, and an additional round with a stranger to serve as a control group.

Design details

Randomization method
First, we divide the village into 6 sections, we will do a circular sampling strategy within the section. We interview a house in the boundaries of the section, we jump 5 houses and we interview a second house. We stop listing when we have found 2 eligible respondents (women between 18-35 years old). These respondents will be decision-makers. They list 3 friends and 3 relatives/in-laws and we select the 3rd of each group. We randomly form 2 groups of decision-makers and assign them numbers 1, 2, 3, 4 5, and 6 using Stata. We invite the decision-maker, the listed friend, and the listed family member. Pairs are predetermined before the game begins, and randomization is applied to the assignment of numbers. For example, in round 1, Decision-Maker 1 (DM1) will be paired with Friend 2 (F2), Decision-Maker 3 (DM3) with Relative/In-law 5 (R5), and so on.
Randomization unit
Individual-round
Clusters
N/A
Observations
414 individuals, 138 decision-makers (1380 decision-maker-rounds), 276 decision-makers (1380 associate-rounds).
Arms
Decision-makers: No-associate round: 138 decision-makers x 2 rounds = 276 decision-makers Associates no-signal round: 138 decision-makers x 4 rounds = 552 decision-makers Associates signal round: 138 decision-makers x 4 rounds = 552 decision-makers Associates: Stranger round: 276 associates No-signal round: 276 associates x 2 rounds = 552 associates Signal round: 276 associates x 2 rounds = 552 associates
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes are (a) the amount of MKW transferred from the associate to the decision-maker and (b) the risk rank of the lottery played by the decision-maker or the proportion of high-risk ranked lotteries over several questions

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords