Gender-STEM Stereotypes and College Major Choice

How to cite

Owen, Stephanie; Rury, Derek. 2024. "Gender-STEM Stereotypes and College Major Choice." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014221. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14221-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Stephanie Owen* , Derek Rury

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014221
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14221-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-09-09 – 2025-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14221

Abstract

This project investigates the role of gendered stereotypes about STEM in perpetuating gender gaps in college major choice. We will study a population of undergraduate students at a large research university. To measure implicit gender stereotypes, we will administer a gender-science Implicit Association Test (IAT). We will combine IAT results with administrative transcript data and with original survey data to measure outcomes such as STEM course-taking, intended and declared major, and academic performance. To obtain causal evidence, we will administer an experimental treatment to assess how much college students’ gender stereotypes can be altered and how their observed, real-world academic choices (e.g., major selection) are affected as a result. Specifically, we will show a random subset of students their IAT results, making implicit stereotypes explicit. All students will take the IAT a second time, so we can observe whether and how implicit stereotypes are altered by the treatment. We hypothesize that in the absence of any intervention, women (men) with stronger implicit bias against women in STEM will be less (more) likely to take courses in or declare a major in a STEM subject. We also hypothesize that students being confronted with their own unconscious biases may cause them to question those implicit associations and make academic choices better in line with their explicit goals, thus closing gender gaps in STEM persistence.

Intervention

Treated students will be informed of the results of the Implicit Association Test they took, revealing to them the extent of their gender bias (e.g., a strong/moderate/slight implicit association between male and STEM and female and humanities, or vice versa, or no gender association). These results will be accompanied with basic information about what the IAT measures. We will emphasize that implicit associations are not the same as explicit behaviors; holding a certain implicit attitude does not necessarily mean someone will behave in a certain way. The message will include the following statement, emphasizing that the link between stereotypes and behavior is not determinative:
"Research shows that making people aware of their implicit attitudes (stereotypes) may help them change their behavior to be less in line with the stereotype. We're hoping that by seeing your results, it will help you make a more objective and unbiased decision about your own academic path, without the influence of unconscious stereotypes."
The message will conclude with a link to learn more about the IAT.

Treated students will receive this information twice. First, as a debrief page immediately after the completion of the first IAT. Second, in an email sent around the time of next semester course selection.

Experimental design

In early fall 2024, we will recruit a sample of eligible students to take a short survey about academic preferences, and to take a gender-science IAT. Upon immediate completion of the IAT, half of participants will randomly be assigned to see a debrief page revealing the extent of their gender bias (i.e., how strongly they associate men with STEM and women with humanities, or vice versa). The other half will receive no debrief. In the second half of the semester, all participants will take another short survey and take the IAT a second time. All survey and IAT responses will be linked to administrative transcript data using unique identifiers.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization will be done within Qualtrics survey software, randomly assigning each survey respondent to take an IAT with or without the debrief page. We will do stratified randomization within gender.
Randomization unit
Individual student
Clusters
400-1000 students
Observations
400-1000 students (pending recruitment)
Arms
200-500 (50%) treatment, 200-500 (50%) control
Primary outcomes
Implicit gender-STEM stereotype measured at baseline (September) and endline (December); performance in STEM courses; intended STEM major; declared STEM major; any STEM course-taking; STEM credits
Secondary outcomes
Explicit gender stereotypes

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords