A Field Experiment on Agricultural Producers’ Responses to Weather Information and Soil Changes

How to cite

Wang, Siyu; Li, Tongzhe. 2024. "A Field Experiment on Agricultural Producers’ Responses to Weather Information and Soil Changes." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014213. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14213-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Siyu Wang* , Tongzhe Li

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014213
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14213-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-09-08 – 2024-09-15
Countries
Private
JEL codes
Q12
Secondary IDs
D83
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14213

Abstract

Information and narratives have been suggested as drivers of public opinion and triggers for major economic events. Opinion-based and factual information impact public opinions differently, with literature suggesting that echo chambers exist on various issues. We aim to explore three main questions: 1) whether individuals informed that their opinions will be shared are more expressive of their views; 2) whether beliefs differ when individuals receive factual information versus different types of opinion-based information; and 3) how identity interacts with individuals’ belief-updating processes. This experiment investigates whether reality aligns with theory in the decision-making of real agricultural producers.

We will conduct a lab-in-the-field experiment at the 2024 Canada’s Outdoor Farm Show (COFS) in Ontario, Canada. Subjects will be asked several belief-related questions regarding weather and soil changes, followed by a charitable giving question and preference elicitation for a soil test using a Becker-DeGroot-Marschak (BDM) mechanism (Becker et al., 1964). The outcome variables of interest will be farmers’ beliefs, charitable giving, and bids on the examined products under various between-subjects treatments.

Intervention

Treatment 1-1
In this treatment, subjects will first be presented with the rainfall estimate question, followed by a climate change question. They will be informed that their answers will be anonymously shared with other subjects. Subjects will be provided with factual information signals about rainfall change, after which they will be presented with the question again.
Treatment 1-2
In this treatment, everything is the same as in Treatment 1-1, except that subjects will be told that their answers will NOT be shared with other subjects.
Treatment 1-3
In this treatment, everything is the same as in Treatment 1-1, except that subjects will first be presented with the climate change question, followed by the rainfall question.
Treatment 1-4
In this treatment, everything is the same as in Treatment 1-3, except that subjects will be told that their answers will NOT be shared with other subjects.
Treatment 2-1
In this treatment, subjects will first be presented with a rainfall question, followed by a climate change question. They will be informed that their answers will NOT be shared with other subjects. Subjects will be provided with opinion-based information from those attributing rainfall changes to climate change, after which they will be presented with the rainfall question again.
Treatment 2-2
In this treatment, everything is the same as in Treatment 2-1, except that subjects will be provided with opinion-based information from those not attributing rainfall changes to climate change, after which they will be presented with the rainfall question again.
Treatment 2-3
In this treatment, everything is the same as in Treatment 2-1, except that subjects will first be presented with the climate change question, followed by the rainfall question.
Treatment 2-4
In this treatment, everything is the same as in Treatment 2-2, except that subjects will first be presented with the climate change question, followed by the rainfall question.

Experimental design

This experiment aims to establish the causal relationship between information and farmers' beliefs about precipitation changes, soil quality, their charitable-giving behavior, and their bids for a soil test kit. Before providing any information, we ask farmers to estimate the change in rainfall within Ontario over the last five years (2019-2023) compared to the previous five years (2014-2018). We also ask whether they believe this change is due to climate change. The sequence of these two questions is varied to determine whether declaring their stance on climate change influences their estimates of weather changes. Additionally, we inform the first-day farmers whether their answers will be shared with others to examine if the potential for social influence affects their stated beliefs.

Next, we provide the first-day farmers with factual information containing noise and measure their updated beliefs about rainfall changes. We also ask them to evaluate the change in soil quality in Ontario over the same periods. On the second and third days, instead of providing factual information with noise, we present opinion-based information, sourced either from first-day farmers who attribute the rainfall change to climate change or those who do not.

Besides belief elicitation, each subject bids on the required amount ∈ [-$50, $50] for a soil test kit. After submitting their bids, subjects will complete a post-experiment questionnaire that includes agricultural, demographic, and farm-specific questions, as well as their preferences for donating between two NGOs: The Canadian Environmental Network and the Canadian Olympic Committee. Each farmer will receive $15 CAD for participating in the experiment and an additional $10 for completing the belief elicitation questions. Subjects will input their responses via HTML pages displayed on iPads.

Design details

Randomization method
Treatment randomization is conducted by computer
Randomization unit
individual farmer
Clusters
512 farmers
Observations
512 farmers
Arms
around 64 farmers
Primary outcomes
prior belief of precipitation, posterior belief of precipitation, posterior belief of soil quality, WTP for soil test, other-other allocation

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords