Knowledge Hoarding

How to cite

Swanson, Nicholas; Cefala, Luisa; Naso, Pedro; Irakoze, Franck. 2024. "Knowledge Hoarding." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014206. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14206-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Nicholas Swanson* , Luisa Cefala , Pedro Naso , Franck Irakoze

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014206
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14206-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-08-19 – 2024-09-30
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14206

Abstract

The diffusion of new technologies is a crucial driver for growth in low-income countries, especially in the agricultural sector. Motivated by theory, researchers and policymakers have relied on networks as a source of rapid knowledge diffusion, yet often with modest empirical results, suggesting that information transmission is not frictionless. We propose a novel mechanism that might prevent information diffusion: “knowledge hoarding.” In settings where early technology adopters (incumbents) derive rents from it, they might strategically halt its diffusion to preserve the rent their knowledge grants them. This project asks whether knowledge hoarding limit aggregate productivity gains because of distributional consequences generated by knowledge diffusion.

We study this question in the context of modern agricultural technologies in Burundi, where agents already trained in the new technology (incumbents) have a private incentive not to share knowledge in the labor market: they face higher labor demand and a wage premium from mastering the planting technologies. We design two experiments to quantify the effect of knowledge hoarding on knowledge diffusion, and to show the distributional and aggregate consequences of knowledge hoarding on labor market equilibria, technology adoption, and productivity.

Intervention

In this project, we conduct two different sets of experiments that identify different incentives that workers have to “hoard” knowledge from others. We described one set of experiments in a PAP on the AEA called “Knowledge Hoarding”. In this registration we describe the second set of experiments.

In this experiment, we vary both the identity of the individual to be trained, as well as the task (and whether it is perceived as rivalrous or not) to look at under which conditions individuals hoard knowledge.

In this experiment, we measure the effects of hoarding behavior on labor market outcomes. To do this we identify workers in each village who are skilled in row-planting/microdosage, and workers who are unskilled in these techniques. Villages are then assigned to one of four treatment arms:

1) Same village workers, rivalrous task: skilled workers are invited to a training event. At this training event, they are asked to spend the entire day with unskilled workers. At this event, they are told that they can use the time together to do different activies, one of which is teaching the other workers row-planting and fertilizer microdosage. Unskilled workers in this treatment are from the same village (labor market).

2) Same village workers, placebo task: skilled workers are invited to a training event. At this training event, they are asked to spend the entire day with unskilled workers. At this event, they are told that they can use the time together to do different activies, one of which is teaching the other workers a non-rivalrous agricultural task. Unskilled workers in this treatment are from the same village (labor market).

3) Different village workers, rivalrous task: skilled workers are invited to a training event. At this training event, they are asked to spend the entire day with unskilled workers. At this event, they are told that they can use the time together to do different activities, one of which is teaching the other workers row-planting and fertilizer microdosage. Unskilled workers in this treatment are from a different village (labor market).

4) Different village workers, placebo task: skilled workers are invited to a training event. At this training event, they are asked to spend the entire day with unskilled workers. At this event, they are told that they can use the time together to do different activities, one of which is teaching the other workers a non-rivalrous agricultural task. Unskilled workers in this treatment are from a different village (labor market).

Experimental design

We sample in all villages a set of laborers who have skills in row-planting/fertilizer microdosage, as well as a set of unskilled laborers in those tasks.

Skilled workers are invited to a training event. At this training event, they are asked to spend the entire day with unskilled workers. At this event, they are told that they can use the time together to do different activities, where the task is either row-planting and microdosage, or another task, depending on the villages treatment condition. In Same-village treatment arms, unskilled workers in this treatment are from the same village (labor market). In Different-village treatment arms, unskilled workers in this treatment are from another village (labor market). Specifically, we take the same workers that were the same village workers for one task, and then use the same laborers as the laborers to be trained for the other task in the different village treatment.

We then measure the likelihood that the worker is trained (as measured by their skill in the task at the end of the event) as described above.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer
Randomization unit
Village
Clusters
Approximately 100 villages
Observations
We expect to sample 8-12 skilled workers per village, and 8-12 unskilled workers in villages assigned to the “Same village treatment”. This entails a total sample size of 1,600 to 2,400 workers.
Arms
We expect to have around 25 villages per treatment arm
Primary outcomes
Our primary outcome is whether the individual is “trained” in the task taught during the training. We measure training in two ways: 1) the duration of the training (as reported by the unskilled worker), 2) using the score from some incentivized quizzes that the unskilled workers take at the end of the event. For the training duration, we compare the (standardized) time that the skilled worker spent training the unskilled in the task.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords