Giving a Voice - Increasing Individual Self-Expression to Enhance Group Welfare and the Resilience to System Disbelief
How to cite
Bechdolf, Mathilde Lea Editha. 2024. "Giving a Voice - Increasing Individual Self-Expression to Enhance Group Welfare and the Resilience to System Disbelief." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014170. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14170-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Individuals in a group, who repeatedly experience that their group's policy selection system does not decide in their favor, often develop system disbelief. The notion that the system is not favorable for the group, i.e., system disbelief, may be detrimental to the performance and welfare of the group. It may affect group members’ psychological well-being and their willingness to provide work effort, make financial contributions, or participate in cooperative coordination. In this experimental study, I investigate whether giving individuals a voice, i.e., the opportunity to express and explain their preferences, mitigates the development of system disbelief when decisions are made by a dictator, a dictator observing AI based decisions or a dictator observing borda count based decisions. The study adds to the knowledge on the drivers of discontent with policy selection systems. It provides insights for managers and policymakers concerning the design of such selection systems, especially in respect to welfare and resilience towards system disbelief.
Intervention
Subjects participate in a laboratory experiment and are randomly assigned to one of six treatments in a 3x2 experimental design. The treatments consist of three different systems of group policy selection (Dictator, Dictator AI, and Dictator Borda) combined with two communication modes (with and without voice). System discontent and system disbelief are elicited throughout a number of selection rounds. Additional items are self-reported by the subjects.
Experimental design
Subjects participate in a laboratory experiment and are randomly assigned to one of six treatments in a 3x2 experimental design. The treatments consist of three different systems of group policy selection (Dictator, Dictator AI, and Dictator Borda) combined with two communication modes (with and without voice). System discontent and system disbelief are elicited throughout a number of selection rounds. Additional items are self-reported by the subjects.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.